American Cut New York Tripadvisor Reviews - American Cut New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at American Cut New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at American Cut New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of American Cut New York
American Cut New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
17 Reviews
0 Replys |
Extremely disappointing
When I went it was restaurant week, but two of us ordered off the regular menu. I asked if the price fix (restaurant week) steak was the same size as the regular menu. They answered if was half the size. The food was only fair, and it was very expensive. I ordered off the regular menu. I believe they gave me the price fix filet, as it was the same size, or even smaller than my friend's who ordered price fix. Additionally, it was fatty and tough. It was NOT a great steakhouse filet. The wedge salad was eh. I will not go back. While restaurant week is supposed to be a treat for guests, and an incentive to try a place, I think American cut compromised our entire experience.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing
Excellent food and customer service. We had a great experience here in New York. Definitely we will be back soon. Thank you AMerican Cut
Be the first to ReplySimply Amazing! Thank you Russ!
We are sure where to start with this one. Our concierge from Soho Grand suggested American Cut for dinner. We always eat early so it was awesome to show up and be greeted by all the staff. It felt like we were on Below Deck boarding the yacht. The food was amazing and the best we have had in a long time, by a long shot! Where this restaurant shines though the brightest is the service and the employees that make it run efficiently while remaining personal. Shout outs - Russ was an amazing server. He is super knowledgeable about the menu, made excellent suggestions, took time to explain everything but most importantly addressed us as humans rather than service numbers at a table. If we owned a restaurant, he would be our number 1 hire. We cannot say enough great things about him and talked about him most of last night after the meal. The other staff that made our dinner special were Emma the Assistant GM, Naz and Cesar! We will be back next time we are in New York City. We really hope American Cut realizes the value they have in their staff. We haven’t been to an establishment with this personal of a service in the city. Thank you soooo much! Very highly recommend.
Be the first to ReplyFriends get together
Dinner for the entire group of 7 people was excellent!! Every year we travel into NYC to celebrate a friends birthday. This experience was as good as we have enjoyed!!~
Be the first to ReplyDelicious
Made a reservation for dinner Friday night. The restaurant is classy and the staff is very friendly and attentive. Had a bottle of wine to start with Tuna tar tot, it was a special menu item that hopefully they add to the regular menu. My husband and I had NY strip that was delicious along with wedge salad, brass knuckle potato’s and mushrooms. Ended with a delicious dessert.
Be the first to ReplyFavorite Steakhouse in NYC
Love this place. This is the 2nd time I've been here and it's at the top of my list for steakhouses in NYC. The staff have always been pleasant, friendly, and attentive and -- most importantly -- the food has been phenomenal. On this occasion, my girl and I shared two appetizers (Tuna Tar Tot and the Seabass Ceviche) and both were amazing. The Tar Tot is so good as a sort of layer cake of flavors and textures -- tuna and a wasabi based cream/sauce sit on top of a perfectly fried hash brown patty. The ceviche was sooo fresh and love that it's served with a plantain for dipping/scooping/mopping (I recommend the scooping option). For dinner I had the Pastrami Rib Eye (which was a step down from the 40oz Tomahawk I shared with a friend on my first visit; it was unsalted and a bit burnt on the edges) but after using the accompanied mustard I liked it very much. My girl had the filet which was perfectly cooked and exactly what you'd expect from a world class steak house. We got the Mac and cheese du jour (and on this day, it was a three cheese blend) which was some of the best Mac and cheese I've had at a steak house. Loved that the pasta was al dente' -- that put it over the top for me. Will definitely return hungry!
Be the first to ReplyDon’t bother
For the hype and the price we expected much more. We’ve been to other venues by this owner and loved the experience. At American Cut there’s lots of frenetic energy but it’s empty. The service is a big miss and the food is only mediocre. We had to flag down our waiter to order cocktails when we arrived and then again when we started the meal. Service was slow and anodyne. No charm or personality. We’ve been to Marc’s other places and loved them. This was a big disappointment. Yes it’s a steak place but for a family meal the options for non- meat eaters were poor. Overall we spent lots of money and wanted to leave feeling satisfied. Instead I left thinking “ I need to write a review so other people don’t bother “.
Be the first to ReplyAnother great trip!
Truly wonderful experience. The service was top notch, thanks to Enrique. The food was exceptional. One of the best NYC dining experiences.
Be the first to Reply5 Star Steak and Service
Finally! - in NYC for our honeymoon - one full year delayed. A short walk from our hotel is the American Cut - dimly lit on the outside, we walked right passed the entrance - so be alert!, We had a reservation and were seated without delay.
Our waiter (Adrien) was absolutely fantastic! He answered our questions, made recommendations for sides and the perfect red wine! The entire wait staff was professional and personable - we felt like VIPs!
The opening salvo is a warm, flaky biscuit that comes with an out-of-this-world spread. From the appetizer menu, as we couldn't make up our minds, we selected both the crab cake and grilled bacon. The crab cake remoulade and the grilled corn took this to next level. No one does this. And the grilled Schaller & Weber bacon - thank you for gilling that with steak sauce.
But the reason we went was for steak - and American Cut did not disappoint! Our NY Strips were melt-in-our-mouths flavorful and tender. Each steak was cooked to perfection - mine a lite pink medium rare and my husband's medium well. Each bite delivered juicy full steak flavor. Ahhhhhhhhhhh!
Our waiter recommended the special side for that evening - Lobster Mac n Cheese - and it proved to be REAL mac n cheese - full flavored and creamy - with chunks of sweet lobster meat.
We added Maitake Hen of the Woods and Jalapeno Mashed potatoes. Each side delivered on flavor and texture.
We ended our meal with a Cracker Jack Sundae, courtesy of Adrien to congratulate us on our wedding!
So good, all around
Our hotel recommended as we were looking for steak and fish and so glad they did! Seated on time, in a quaint area (maitre d’ was personable too). Menu is enticing and our waiter, Russ was top notch and helped us with our choices. My friends filet was the best she’s ever had and my tuna tar “tot” was fresh and excellent, our other dish was halibut and we could have licked the bowl with the delicious sauce. Sides dishes were plenty and wine was excellent. We would return for sure, the place has a special vibe to it and great energy!
Be the first to ReplyThanksgiving
Came here for Thanksgiving dinner and couldn't fault a thing excellent food excellent service will defo be back x
Be the first to ReplyLoved it!
Our new fave steakhouse in NYC! My wife and I enjoyed my birthday dinner here and it was fantastic. The service from the time we walked in to the time we left was great. Thank you Rueben for making our experience a great one. The food was excellent: the lobster toast, caesar prepared table-side, the mac and cheese and the steaks were all great. Looking forward to our next visit this year.
Be the first to ReplyFavorite steakhouse in NYC
American Cut never fails to amaze!! The staff are incredible, the food is interesting and classic at the same time, and the ambiance cannot be beat. By far my favorite steakhouse experience in NYC. Don't miss the chili lobster or table-side caesar salad!!
Be the first to ReplyVery good
Friendly staff and warm welcoming.
Great location, decor and interiors.
Good selection of food and cuts.
Food is well seasoned and served at the right temperature by friendly staff.
We will back!
Very good steak
All round a very good experience - good quality steak and a decent selection of other things. Service on our visit was a bit slow but all very friendly.
Be the first to ReplyOutstanding
Great steaks and terrific service. The steaks are quite excellent - cooked perfectly. Being from Texas, we have very high expectations for our beef and American Cut does not disappoint.
Don’t miss American Cut on your next visit to Tribeca.
Great Service, medium cut
The service was really excellent at this place. They let me go into the wine cellar and pick the wines my table would like. Good wines too! But the food was average I thought. The meat very seasoned and the sides nothing special. I think there is better in town and would not go again
Be the first to Reply