Cilantro New York Yelp Reviews - Cilantro New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Cilantro New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Cilantro New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Cilantro New York
Cilantro New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
24 Reviews
0 Replys |
Lovely restaurant.
Chicken Taco soup and Potato Leek Soup is sublime. BUT!!!!? Query: why is it that you can not order a 3-piece Taco dinner which includes 3-different things: 1-fish, 1-beef, 1-chicken?? Why must you order 3-of the same????, Annoying restriction!
Be the first to ReplyWorst Mexican food ever.
Wait the only thing that nachos were good. I order the eggs Benedict and it was hard to cut. Need a steak knife to cut through an English muffin. So sad. My husband order the huevos rancheros they put the tortillas on the bottom and it got soggy the rest was a soup as we were leaving my husband heard the manager "if they don't like it go some were else" Well I will be going somewhere else and never there.
Be the first to ReplySo sad to put a low review here.
I don't eat in but I've ordered lunch delivery for years. Sadly, the options to get food delivered are slim. (seemless/grubhub) to which I've now canceled bc these companies are terrible to their workers ND charge OUTRAGEOUS delivery prices. NOT worth the terrible service. I placed an order today- super simple- enchaladas that's it! NO modifications. Did they ever arrive? NO! My delivery person called me 6 times, zero English what so ever. That's perfectly cool with me. I speak a little Spanish. But was I suprised and super annoyed that they couldn't do the job. The driver called me 6 times. neither of us understood each other. Told him my address 6 times...Did I mention I order All the time? Legit homey didn't understand ANYTHING I was saying and it never arrived. I was annoyed especially bc what on earth did the delivery person think? Did he think ALL OF A SUDDEN understand the same conversation we had 6 times? The apt is Easy to find. Not to mention when I called the restaurant trying to help, nobody answered. And I called more than 6times. I tried calling the restaurant to see if they could help. The person who answered said "he's new, not his problem, would try to fix it but then hung up on me. I canceled my delivery month expenses from seemless/grubhub and I will never order here again. Wake up! If you want people to eat your food, don't make it impossible to order and annoying to try to deliver on basic instructions.
Be the first to ReplyWe went to Cilantro on a whim, and all of us left extremely
We went to Cilantro on a whim, and all of us left extremely pleased with our experience. The hostess was very kind and accommodating (an additional friend was able to join at the last minute, and she was able to fit him in no problem). The waitress was kind, attentive, and professional, and even re-read our order aloud for us to make sure she got everything right. The food was unbelievably delicious and appropriately priced, too. I ordered a blackened chicken burrito and it was so so good. The portion was on the bigger side, so I was able to take it home and eat it for lunch the next day (and it tasted delicious then, too!). I also really recommend the guacamole and the queso served in a cast iron skillet. We were a bit rowdy as we were celebrating some birthdays, but the wait staff was so kind and attentive with us (we never even had to ask for chip refills, because they were constantly provided for us!) and made sure we had such a fun experience. The tres leches birthday cake was perfectly made as well. This is a truly great restaurant and I can't speak enough about how amazing the service was and how delicious the food was. Definitely recommend!!!
Be the first to ReplyVery unhappy with Cilantro after today's brunch.
While I have had dinner and drinks here before and everything was fine, today was, honestly horrible. First off, the waitress had A LOT of trouble taking our order. She was not listening at all. When the order came, things that we specified during the order taking were incorrect. Mainly that I requested a burger, Medium well. When I received it, it was literally RAW!! Seriously? I also ordered a side salad but got fries. I spoke to the manager who really didn't care about my concerns at all and said they would always support their staff. Most places will offer a free drink or dessert to compensate for poor service. Nope. Not here. Not going to eat there again. You shouldn't either.
Be the first to ReplyCilantro has been one of go tos forever.
Not sure anymore. Today they were understaffed and took a long time to get service. One of the employees shared with us a dirty little secret that they don't bring you the side of rice and beans to save money. It's on the menu. They just hope you don't ask. Plus they are still charging 3 percent credit card processing fees. A violation of state law. This is how you lose my business.
Be the first to Reply40 minute to get any food.
Got yelled at when we asked politely for the food. Food was burned and not tasty. Will not eat hear here again and will tell others not to come!
Be the first to Replywent out for lunch and I Do not recommend this place for
went out for lunch and I Do not recommend this place for anyone my Partner and I were 100% discriminated at this restaurant , they charged my card then tried to charge my card again then threatened me and said they Have my card info on my receipt they'll just charge my card again I asked for receipt they told me no .
Be the first to ReplyI was treated poorly and discriminated againt , I'm a
I was treated poorly and discriminated againt , I'm a lesbian African American who came for lunch with my partner. Once it was time to pay I asked for my receipt after signing my signature for my PAID bill, I was alarmed when the waiter & manager went over to the side took about 5mins to return & I was told I had to pay more money & was refused my receipt unless I made another payment. I was told my payment was voided & my card would be charged again. Left restaurant embarrassed & with no receipt.
Be the first to ReplyAhhhhh Yes Cilantro, Ok so I have gone to Cilantro more
Ahhhhh Yes Cilantro, Ok so I have gone to Cilantro more then a few times and less then a lot, also have picked up to bring it home. If there is one thing I need to HAMMER HOME is don, go for the entree's Monday to Wednesday. If you are going for sports and you want appetizers fine go o. Those days you're safe with those and maybe the steak or chicken entrees. I have found that the food and service is so much better Thursday to Sunday the fish is fresh the Head Chef and the A TEAM is there and 95 % of the time the knock it out of the park , the other 5% is you can't please everyone all the time. Also on these days the the to go is on point not saying you should check your order. But my suggestion is under have them under cook you steak. Example if you want a medium steak order it medium rare because it will rest and cook in the container it's not always perfect but it won't be well done. With these tips you should have a good experience at Cilantro Go and enjoy your self. Oh one more thing eat at the bar the service is good and so are the Margaritas traditional with simple syrup and real lime juice. Don't do that YUCK MARGARITA MIX in a bottle.
Be the first to ReplyI was a longtime patron of Cilantro.
On my last visit, when the waiter brought the bill, we paid on one of their new machines at the table, and left the restaurant. The waiter then came rushing out and grabbed us, saying the charge didn't go through. We returned and were met by the manager, who was rude to us immediately, asking us to run the card again. We showed them that the charge had gone through on our end, on the credit card website, and told them we wouldn't pay again. The manager then all but accused us of trying to steal the restaurant (?) and wanted us to write down the credit card number (!) which of course we refused to do. We offered to leave our phone number, and the manager said, "but what if you don't pick up?" The charge eventually went through, of course. Sadly, I can't recommend Cilantro anymore, and I won't be returning.
Be the first to ReplyGreat Mexican fast food.
Chicken fajitas are terrific as is the salsa, guacamole, chips and black beans. I love that I xan get a yummy frozen margarita delivered!
Be the first to ReplyCilantro is a casual dinner place with lots of seating and
Cilantro is a casual dinner place with lots of seating and no reservation required, usually. My friend and I came here to catch up and were pleased with the food overall. She used to come here all the time and I could see why: the food is good and filling and not too expensive. The Steak Fajitas were pretty good and my Wild Mushroom Quesadilla was solid - I mean, how could you go wrong with cheese guac and tortillas? We did sit next to a couple who was very upset with their food quality and had an argument with the servers about it; I wish it could've been resolved a little more gently, but it does seem like the couple was able to receive some sort of resolution.
Be the first to ReplyToday we had guacamole which was nice and chunky but it was
Today we had guacamole which was nice and chunky but it was good amount of onion and spicy level of jalapeños were plentiful. My fav was the chicken tortilla soup. its so homey and heart warming.The bathroom is nice, one for M and one for W. I mean, its the same. Clean and decor were matchy w the restaurant itself.Staffs were friendly nd gets to the point. Fill our water frequently nd the water is tasty too.Cobb salad were just ok, shrimps were big and seasoned but not grilled. My party ordered the steak quesadilla app which was cheesy and tasty(no pic sawrry). I would come backfor soup. Margarita were pretty bad tho.
Be the first to ReplyWe came here on a whim and absolutely loved it! Our service
We came here on a whim and absolutely loved it! Our service was amazing, the food was superb, and the ambiance was stunning! Would definitely come back... and we're from Texas.
Be the first to ReplySolid Mexican on the UWS.
We walked in and were able to be seated immediately. Staff were attentive and they were accommodating in my annoying lemonade and seltzer order. I didn't have any drinks but my friends did and they looked good. The guac was tasty and I tried some of my friend's chicken fajitas were also good. Would definitely come again.
Be the first to ReplyThe food is OK, but service was bad.
Took almost 30 minutes to get our drinks.I got the steak fajitas medium rare and some of the strips were straight rare. I cooked them up the next day but that still shouldn't happen. The queso is not creamy queso although that seems to be the case for most NYC mexican spots. I love mexican food and this is a super convenient location so I'm going to come back in hopes the food will be more consistent on a slower night!
Be the first to ReplyGreat spot to satisfy my craving for Mexican food while I
Great spot to satisfy my craving for Mexican food while I was in NY. Great simple menu with food done well. Plantains with the chips and salsa was a really nice surprise. Chicken tacos were delicious and my husband's fish burrito disappeared before I got a bite!Convenient stop offer visiting the Natural History museum.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food, great drinks, great service! I don't know what
Great food, great drinks, great service! I don't know what else to say. We got the guacamole, which was excellent. The service was outstanding. And then we split the enchiladas with the green sauce our waitress recommended. It was all so good!!!
Be the first to ReplyI love this place so much.
May not be traditional mexican food but still is BANGER. Would give 20 starts if I could
Be the first to ReplyAfter 15 years visiting Cilantro, we have run out of
After 15 years visiting Cilantro, we have run out of superlatives to describe how much we look forward to our next trip to Columbus & 83rd. The best margarita, the best guacamole, great service and generous portions of really good food. What else could you ask for?
Be the first to ReplyTheir nachos tasted just like MexicoAlso the host is very
Their nachos tasted just like MexicoAlso the host is very friendly and graciousDefinitely recommended!
Be the first to ReplySO SLAY i got the blackened fish burrito and it was so yum!
SO SLAY i got the blackened fish burrito and it was so yum! Also the margs were delish pur
Be the first to ReplyLove, love, love Cilantro and the staff.
For food, I highly recommend the Molcajete Azteca. It comes with Chorizo, Chicken, Steak & Shrimp w/Roasted Tomato Salsa, Oaxaca Cheese, Rice, Beans & Soft Corn Tortillas...beautiful presentation and delicious!
Be the first to Reply