Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Tripadvisor Reviews - Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa - Trade Reservations
Save up to 30% at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa!
Have someone use their loyalty points to book your stay or buy a reservation from someone who can't make it to theirs.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
- Any Room Type
- Any Standard Room
- Standard Ocean View King. Partial Ocean View Terrace. Newly
- One Bedroom Residence Ocean View 1181 Sq Ft (Full Kitchen Terrace)
- Two Bedroom Residence Has Ocean Views 1305 Sq Ft (Full Kitchen)
- Our 2 Bed Plus Den Residence Is A Private Custom Designed
- Ocean View Three Bedroom Cottage. Ocean View Fireplace. Full
- Any Suite
- Our Superior Jr Suite Has A Partial Ocean View. Superior Ocean
- Deluxe Ocean View Junior Suite Bi (Level Private Terrace Ocean)
- Standard Ocean View One Bedroom Suite. Partial Ocean View King
- Superior Ocean View One Bedroom Suite. Ocean View. King Bed.
- Superior Ocean View 2 Bedroom Suite Views Of Our Private White
- Deluxe Oceanfront 1 Bedrm Suite. King Bed. Two Terraces. Queen
- Deluxe Oceanfront Two Bedroom Suite. Steps From The Beach. Two
- Deluxe Oceanfront 1 Bedrm Suite. King Bed. Queen Sofa Bed Views
- Any Deluxe Room
- Deluxe Ocean View King. Ocean View. Private Terrace. Newly
- Deluxe Ocean Front King. Closest Rooms To The Beach. Floor (To)
- Deluxe Ocean Front 2 Queens. Closest Rooms To The Beach. Floor ()
- Dlx One Bedroom Oceanfront Cottage. Fireplace. Kitchen. Private
- Dlx 2 Bdrm Ocean Front Cottage.ocean Front Fireplace.private
- Deluxe Oceanfront 3 Bedroom Cottage.
- Any Superior Room
- Superior Ocean View King. Ocean View. Private Terrace. Queen
- Any Family Room
- Std Ocean View Jr Suite Bi (Level Living Space King Bed And A)
Montauk's Best Hotels that are most frequently booked by customers of Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Ranked #18 in Montauk's Best Hotels.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
29 Reviews
0 Replys |
Not pleasant
Not worth it. My expectations weren’t really high but I thought it would be at least pleasant for the price of a room. Only positives are location & housekeeping (they work really hard). Bait & switch on the rooms, no one answers from room service or restaurant and some guests let their children behave like wild animals.
Be the first to ReplyResort Excellence
I had an amazing experience at Gurneys Montauk. It started at the reception desk with Genevieve and her spectacular service and attention. I had all my meals at the restaurant on location, and the food was superb. The seawater pool and spa was clean and luxurious. Every single person I met that worked at this resort was pleasant and helpful.
Be the first to ReplyYou have to tip before your service ..
I loved the location and neighborhood. We got food from the bar and I was one of the most delicious burgers I’ve had. Valet was super kind , front desk agents not so much unfortunately. My biggest turnoff was the spa . Not the grounds or aesthetics because that was top of the line. There is just something about paying gratuity before receiving the service that seems backwards to me! 22 percent to be exact . As luck would have it my massage was soooo underwhelming. The therapist was extremely kind , it just wasn’t an amazing session .
Be the first to ReplyWonderful and Breathtaking Views
Had such a relaxing time at this beautiful resort. We were greeted by Genevieve who was warm and friendly and remembered me from my previous visit. For a nominal fee she upgraded us to a beautiful waterfront room. Everything was 5 stars from the warm friendly staff, to the beautiful views, comfy beds and wonderful facility.
Be the first to ReplyRelaxing and clean!
Exceeded our expectations!! Every staff member went out of their way to make our stay enjoyable and comfortable. We stayed in a 2 bedroom cottage… pleasantly surprised how clean and spacious it was! The views are breathtaking. The bathhouse and spa very very clean and lots of options for a relaxing trip. Cynthia was so helpful answering all of our questions and giving recommendations. Cynthia even helped us book the next trip!
Be the first to ReplyWe cannot wait to come back!
We had the most wonderful time on our girls trip to Gurneys! The staff, the spa, our cottage, dinner in the igloo - everything was absolutely perfect! We cannot wait to come back!!! A special thank you to Cynthia for helping to make our trip extra special!
Be the first to ReplyGreat stay on the sea in Montauk
We loved this sprawling resort on the sea and enjoyed spending time in the bath house, spa and out by the fire pits. Great for couples and families—and Cynthia made our stay even more special when she found out we were there for our anniversary!
Be the first to ReplyFamily fun
Perfect place for a family gathering. ❤️ Enjoyed Scarpetta for delicious dinners and breakfast. The indoor pool was a great addition being it was very cold outside. Our stay at Gurneys was just perfect and looking forward returning for a special occasion❤️ very soon.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing staff retreat!
The staff truly made my staff retreat super special. The warm welcome, amazing food and phenomenal staff. Lynn, Lorie, Carlos and Anna truly went above and beyond. I highly recommend for folks looking to do a staff retreat that energizes their staff.
Be the first to ReplyGreat to be back! What a wonderful stay!
We had such a fantastic time that I told myself I must leave a review. We had been to Gurneys a few times before the reno and wanted to go back when the seawater spa reopened. Having been diagnosed with cancer during the pandemic (doing well thankfully), my husband wanted to whisk me away for a few quiet days in January for my 60th. Huge thanks and kudos to Josh Strom (front of house manager) who made sure our stay was perfect and memorable, and the staff supported him in that effort as they were all very kind and wonderfully accommodating. As my legs can get a bit weak at times, Josh made sure our room was close to the spa, the main building (where the restaurant and coffee shop are located) and the beachfront--amazing how he achieved all that! Our room was on the ocean and spacious with an interior table and chairs and sofa and coffee table as well as a balcony with two chairs, a table and footrests--yes there was a bed too--a king which was our main request (smile). No sooner had we unlocked the door when a beautiful platter of fresh fruit and a bottle of Prosecco arrived with happy birthday wishes. It was a lovely surprise and generous gesture. We relaxed to the sound of the waves day and night. Even we were amazed how much time we spent out there in the winter! The air was so fresh. The seawater spa was wonderful. We swam two of our three days and experienced the new plunge pools--a first for us--which we enjoyed very much. Most of our meals were on property with tasty food and attentive service. It was so nice to be back that we really wished we had at least one more night. Thank you again to Josh and the team at Gurneys. We will be back!
Be the first to ReplyLovely
The reason for my 5 star rating is because of the service delivered by the staff. Everyone and I do mean everyone could not have been more helpful and friendly making a guest feel like family. In reference to the room, the view is spectacular, bed was extremely comfortable, wonderful linens, towels and robes. My disappointment was not being able to take advantage of the beautiful spa due to our schedule commitments during our visit. But this is a great reason to return. I look forward to this. If I am asked for one word attribute: SERVICE!
Be the first to ReplyWe will be back
Loved the salt water pool. Kathy who is the attendent in the women's locker room was patient and sweet showing me around; answering questions. Lovely woman. Room was nice great view. My husband loves a steam room. We questioned the attendants at the spa desk about acess to the steam room We were told they open at 10 the next day and would need bracelets to get in. Monday at breakfast I asked if I could get one plain pancake with syrup. Waiter wanted to accomadate me and told me I could: get one from the kid's menu. The pancake I got was unedible. Burnt. My husband enjoyed his yogurt and fruit. We also enjoyed the two coffees. The bill was 53 dollars. We looked forward to getting into the bath house for the steam room. Was informed when we got there at 10:00 a yoga class was in progress and come back at 10:45. I don't understand why we werent told that when we inquired the day before. Unfortuanelty we had to leave at 11 for some appointments and were disappointed. Other than the spa desk...all personel were wonderful. Helping with luggage, directions. Loveliest people. We enjoyed our stay and will be back.
Be the first to ReplyThe best winter getaway
My wife and I booked the one bedroom residence for Presidents’ Day weekend and it was incredible. We were traveling with our 2 month old baby and it was her first trip. Everyone we spoke with went above and beyond to accommodate any requests we had. When we checked into the room, we couldn’t believe it. Carlos helped us unload all of our baby equipment (there was a lot of it) and was super helpful in assisting us. There is an enormous terrace that wraps around with multiple lounge chairs, a full table with chairs, a BBQ and a wine fridge. You have an insane unobstructed ocean view. It’s laid out like an apartment and is just so beautiful. 2 bathrooms and 2 fireplaces. We hung out in the wonderful living room with the comfiest sectional! We took the baby to Scarpetta and they were beyond accommodating. There were so many other couples there with their babies too! We also even sat at the bar while I wore her in the carrier. Wasn’t sure if I could do that but nothing was an issue or problem! Every single employee was so nice to us. The new spa is amazing. I booked a 90 minute massage and the new facilities are beautiful. Definitely worth the splurge! Gurney’s in the off season is our favorite time to go. The winter is so beautiful there. Highly recommend!!
Be the first to ReplyWonderful multi-gen family friendly vacation
We've been to Gurney's before but this time we took both of our children (a 3 year old and a 3 month old) as well as my parents. They went over the top to accommodate us. They put our rooms together, had bumpers for the bed for our toddler, they sent us bottles of prosecco and cheeseboards upon arrival and even gave us swimmies for our toddler to use in the pool. Everyone was warm and friendly and made our experience so wonderful. Bravo!
Be the first to ReplyMom Getaways at Gurney's
My first visit to Gurney's was in October 2022. My friend and I relaxed by the newly renovated pool for hours looking out at the ocean - it was like being on a cruise ship. The 2-bedroom suite is perfect with a comfy living room with magnificent view. But skip the room service and be served gourmet food IN the restaurant - Its beautiful and the service is wonderful. The experience was so unbelievably comfortable, yet elegant that I grabbed a few girlfriends (& kids) and went out for a mid-week overnight in November. This time I had one of the best massages of my life (I've had them in 5-star resorts all over the world), enjoyed every second in the hot tubs, cold plunge pools and sauna (and sweet Angelo taking care of us all day at the spa/pool), and fabulous cocktails outside surrounded by firepits...so I had to go back AGAIN in January for another "mom getaway overnight". I hit the gym (since it was January) and actually enjoyed that too - looking over the ocean while on the treadmill put a little jig in my jog. Can't wait to take my son and mother-in-law in March for some VIP treatment, gourmet meals and walks on the beach!
Be the first to ReplyHappy Birthday 2023!
I felt like I had the place to myself! Above and beyond service, with a welcome bottle of Prosecco & Fruit. Got a sneak peek at the newly renovated Spa, which was amazing. Hoping to make this a yearly tradition!!
Be the first to ReplyWinter Retreat
It's the location, the cozy room, the setting on the beach and the light of the winter sun, but most of all it's the people. We never heard a "no", or "that's not possible" as you hear in many other hotels even this class. The team had an incredible positive and inspiring spirit. We just stayed one night and we loved it, although the spa was closed for renovation. The room (ocean front queen) was big with a big terrace with daybed, the food and service in the restaurants was great, best cappuccino at the lobby bar! The resort is high priced but was worth every cent!
Be the first to ReplyThe perfect getaway!
From check in to check out our entire stay was perfect. The room was great with amazing views. The restaurant had a nice ambiance and the food was delicious. The indoor bar was a nice place to relax for drinks, the outdoor fire pits were also a great spot to sit & get cozy and have a drink! Definitely one of our favorite spots to sit and unwind! The spa, I can't forget to mention the spa! Simply put, it's amazing! The various heated and chilled baths, steam room and sauna, hot rock table and the main pool, again all amazing and just extremely relaxing. The staff, Belen and Cynthia at the front desk were super friendly and extremely knowledgeable about the area and gave us lots of great ideas on things to do both on and off the property. Belen was kind enough to acknowledge our anniversary and sent us a nice gift to our room, thank you again Belen and thank you for all the great information you provided us with, you made our stay perfect! We hope to see you again soon! The entire staff was so attentive, it's actually nice and quite rare service like this still exists! Everyone we encountered was respectful friendly and very down to earth! Unfortunately I can't recall everyones name but Belen, Cynthia, Virginia, Michael and to all the others, thank you for making our stay perfect!
Be the first to ReplyIncredible Customer Service. Incredible View.
My unfortunately short, one night stay exceeded all expectations. From the moment we arrived, Belen the wonderful employee at the front desk, made me feel like a VIP. The room was fantastic with a large balcony right on the beach. I think people really miss out on the magic that is Montauk in the winter. Scarpetta was incredible food with service that matched. Then Courtni this morning at check-out was the cherry on top of a wonderful night. I will definitely be back to enjoy the spa which was closed for a few days during my stay.
Be the first to Replyloved it
As a visitor, we had a great day at Gurney’s. We booked spa appointments weeks ago just to make sure we could get in during our vacation. The hotel and property are gorgeous. The staff was attentive and efficient. The food and drinks were amazing. Spa services were impressive. We would definitely come back.
Be the first to ReplyWe hosted our daughter's wedding at Gurney's - it was awesome!!
We hosted a Welcome Reception the night before the wedding, hosted the wedding and After Party, all on property. From the moment we arrived, our experience was first class. My wife and kids have been coming to Gurney's for 30 years and we were so honored and excited to have our daughter's wedding here. Jonathan, Jessica, Chef Chris and their teams were excellent and so accommodating. We knew we had first class vendors, including the band, florist, photographer, car service, tent rental and wedding planners and the Gurney's team worked seamlessly with each of them. Ginny, Brenda and crew were simply outstanding!! . The love and care and attention to every detail they showed to our daughter Morgan- the bride, and my wife as the mother of the bride- and to every single guest who attended, was beyond our expectations. We felt like we were part of their families. Our guests had the time of their lives and have not stopped raving about how great the wedding weekend was. It didn't hurt that the weather for the wedding day was perfect and you cannot overstate how spectacular the venue is- the views are breathtaking and you know you are at a world class resort. We are very partial to the east end of Long Island, live out here and consider it paradise but anyone who is blessed to be able to consider having a wedding at Gurney's should book it now- it was worth every dollar spent. Gurney's created the most memorable wedding for our daughter, son in law and families and friends and we can't thank them enough !!
Be the first to ReplyCome here and take something off your bucket list.
Luxury beachfront accommodations at a luxury price. Beautiful resort located directly on the beach. Staff are kind and helpful Get a deluxe oceanfront king room. They are all fantastic and have your own private deck with a beach bed. The only slight disappointment was room service. It was expensive and presented like cheap Chinese takeout.
Be the first to ReplyCall to confirm what room you are getting. It’s expensive but it’s Montauk and if you can afford it go for it
I am surprised people do not read reviews about this resort. There are many positives about this place as well as negatives. The negatives are worse because of the price. I can go to the Caribbean for same price as staying here. But this is Montauk. A very special place I’ve been visiting since I was a kid. And we stayed in a water view room. It was not 4 seasons at all but it was fine. We used the pool and spa. My friends paid more for the room than I did because they are great friends and know my situation. I think calling and being specific about the room your are getting will lessen stress. You can also eat at other restaurants in the area. You can go to Gosmands Dock and Lunch. Get some Left Coffee. I would come yearly if I could afford it. It’s not perfect at all. But it’s Montauk and it will forever be special in my heart
Be the first to ReplyWorst service ever!!! Save your money!!
This hotel is location in a beautiful location! The beach is amazing but the food leaves a lot to desire and the service is awful!!!! For the kind of money that you pay to stay here you should get a 5 star service, or a least the bare minimum of decency and respect. Instead you get treated like crap while dropping over a thousand dollars a night to be there! Save your money and go somewhere where you’ll be treated with respect and decency!
Be the first to ReplyGreat Beach/Property. Awful service and misleading marketing & overpriced
For three years in a row my girlfriend and I have gone to Gurneys (once star island accidentally, and twice the original one) Every year we complain that it’s overpriced and service subpar, but justify coming back because there isn’t much competition and Montauk in itself is fun. It looks like this year will be our final year. First off we paid 1900 a night after taxes and fees for a jr suite with “deluxe ocean view…” little did we know that Gurneys defines ocean view as a view of the parking lot and tent with a slight glimpse of the ocean if you stand on the couch of the living room and jump Secondary, the service at the actual beach is awful. We paid $18 for guacamole which was three bites of guac and a bunch of chips and $45 for a tasteless lobster roll without much meat. Additionally, upon ordering a sparking water we were told ice buckets were only available for bottle service and after it warmed we had to ask for additional ice 5 times before giving up and not getting any. Finally, the room while actually nice had very thin walls and We could hear every time the person above us moved and our neighbors had a conversation. Ultimately, Gurneys location is great and I’m ok with overpaying based off of supply and demand , but upon staying here it’s obvious they skimp on every detail snd you’re paying 2k for a motel with parking lot views and service that is inattentive and terrible. One nice note, after sleeping poorly and not enjoying our first two nights, Gurney's did let us out of our final night and waive the resort fee.
Be the first to Reply