Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from? - Mama's Fish House Paia - Buy Reservations

799 Poho Pl, Paia, HI 96779, USA

Low: $10

Average Price: $80 High: $170

Getting a Reservation at Mama's Fish House Paia for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!

Buy a verified reservation at Mama's Fish House Paia from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.

What if nothing fits my schedule?

If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.

We only list verified Reservations! All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.

Read Less

Mama's Fish House Paia Reviews from The Last Year

AT: 😍 (1) Yelp: 😍 (30) Tripadvisor: 😍 (26)

😍

Incredible every time

5/5 by 🥩 @DecadentRoof69 on 05/22/2023

Delicious, sustainable, seafood. Unassuming but the cuisine was second to none.

😍

Exceptional

5/5 by 🥩 @DecadentRoof69 on 05/20/2023

Best fish I’ve ever had!

😍

Great value seafood restaurant

5/5 by 🐶 @DogmaticWave16 on 05/16/2023

I had the most wonderful seafood in Maui at MaMa's Fish House, the only downside is that it is a little bit pricey compared to other local restaurants.

😍

Complimentary valet parking.

5/5 by 👻 @Elaine D. on 03/25/2023

Beautiful place and interesting decoration. The service was great and accommodating. Went here for lunch, reserved for 4 people and did it 5 months in advance. Got the oysters and lobster tail. It was delicious! I enjoyed the food. The dessert was aesthetically pleasing and interested flavored. Would highly recommend coming here for the food!

😒

I recently dined at Mama's Fish House during my visit to

3/5 by 👻 @Rainie L. on 03/24/2023

I recently dined at Mama's Fish House during my visit to Maui, and although I had high expectations, I was left with mixed feelings about my experience. The restaurant itself offers a beautiful ocean view, which was a definite plus. However, the food didn't quite live up to the hype.The seafood was fresh, which is always appreciated, but the dishes were just okay. Nothing really stood out as exceptional or memorable, which was a bit disappointing considering the restaurant's reputation. I've had better seafood elsewhere on the island.Surprisingly, the highlight of my meal was the smoothie. It was delicious, refreshing, and perfectly balanced in terms of flavor and consistency. It's a bit ironic that my favorite part of the dining experience wasn't even the main focus of the menu.Overall, Mama's Fish House offers a decent meal with a nice view, but it didn't leave a lasting impression on me. The smoothie was the standout item, which is quite telling about the rest of the food. If you're looking for a more remarkable dining experience in Maui, you might want to consider trying other options.

😍

We heard so many positive reports about Mama's Seafood that

5/5 by 👻 @Nick N. on 03/23/2023

We heard so many positive reports about Mama's Seafood that we wanted to try it, but then, reservations were reportedly very difficult too, so we weren't that optimistic. However, a time came available and we booked it.When we arrived (2:30pm) I was a little pessimistic due to all the hype, but that all disappeared very quickly as each attendant unapologetically was super-attentive and helpful, including the valet, host, greeter, second host, and busser. Our server was warm and friendly, knowledgeable and meek, yet subtle and confident. The food was outstanding, and memorable. It is very expensive but the experience well worth it. Whether we will be back is another story, but we will recommend it to everyone without hesitation. A great dining experience for sure!Thank you Mama!

😍

Where to begin.

5/5 by 👻 @Andy N. on 03/23/2023

..Mama's was the highlight of my family's recent Hawaii trip! The location, the service and the food!! Karen was perfection, explaining each dish, the fish and the cocktails...what the famous dishes and drinks were and the house favorites. All of us loved all the food, but each of us preferred the dish we ordered for ourself. Great service!! And when all of that is said and done, you are sitting on the most beautiful piece of coastline, enjoying the natural ocean breezes as they blow through the dining room!! We are already planning our trip back to Maui just for another dining experience at Mama's. Mahalo Mama's!!

😍

North shore lunch

5/5 by 👻 @Brad D on 03/23/2023

Try to book reservations ahead. Or get there right when they open. Had an amazing meal. Beautiful location, their beach area is picture perfect! The short rib was the best I have ever had. Sea Turtles on the beach.

😍

Just insane how good everything was….

5/5 by 👻 @Jel4754 on 03/23/2023

The food was just out of this world good. It’s impossible to describe in words how delicious it was. Yes it’s expensive. Some places this price are worth it and this was one of them. When places are booked for three months out don’t call it overpriced.

😍

First time eating at Mama's Fish House and it exceeded our

5/5 by 👻 @Kenneth R. on 03/22/2023

First time eating at Mama's Fish House and it exceeded our expectations! The meal was outstanding and amazing customer service.As our appetizer we had the Maui Octopus and was cooked perfect and tasted amazing.I had the Mahi-Mahi with Lobster and Crab in Macadamia Nut Crust and my Wife had the Beef Short Rib "Pulehu" and Tristan Lobster Tail. Both cooked perfect and very flavourful! Highly recommend both of them!For dessert we enjoyed the Polynesian Black Pearl. Visually beautiful and tasted great!

😍

Amazing! While it can be hard to get a table here it's

5/5 by 👻 @Shawn D. on 03/22/2023

Amazing! While it can be hard to get a table here it's worth the effort. You can set alerts on opentable to find a spot when someone cancels but they go fast. If you can book ahead do so. From the location, the decor, the service but most importantly the cuisine MAMA's exceeds the hype. Several times guests along with myself have commented that it has been the best meal they ever had. Even coming from those who don't really enjoy seafood. That's saying something. I typically enjoy dining on the locally caught fish often on fish I've only seen on their menu. It truly is a gem do yourself a favor and just listen to all the excellent reviews and try for yourself. Prices are comparable to other locations on the island yet service ambiance and most importantly cuisine are outstanding and exceed the others. It's always a unforgettable memory having the pleasure to dine there if you are on the fence just go make and make your own memories there. You won't regret it!

😍

Lunch

5/5 by 👻 @Sheila on 03/22/2023

Fabulous meal with amazing views of the ocean!!! Was very expensive meal and small portions which we expected.

😍

Mama’s for lunch

5/5 by 👻 @Stonehouse foodie on 03/22/2023

The only reservation available for my wife’s birthday was 11:30 am. Thinking that it might make for a less Happy Birthday we went anyway. It couldn’t have been better. Going in the daylight allowed a wonderful view of the water. The menu is the same and the service was still the finest in Maui. The food was its usual superb along with great service. While very expensive it is a treat that you should give yourself. And don’t worry the time of your reservation it will still be world class.

😒

From Stellar to Average

3/5 by 👻 @Paradise06505503420 on 03/22/2023

We have been traveling to Maui for 40+ years and each visit requires at least one lunch at Mama’s Fish House. However, we think this visit was our last. In 2021 we noticed the service was not as it was prior to the pandemic, but the food and ambiance was still stellar. Prices had increased significantly, but that was true everywhere. Our 2023 visit was not a good experience either. Therefore based on the still increasing prices, we will search for other options. Our server was not very pleasant, it was an inconvenience to elaborate on the fish and the preparation. She asked four times if we we were ready for more iced tea without refilling the glasses. Stop interrupting our conversation and either bring more tea or refill the glasses. The server had an assistant, who did not assist with our table at all. I sat with a dirty plate in front of me for 15 minutes. I waited for a lengthy time to order dessert. All in all, it is a beautiful setting and the food is excellent, but extreme cost and average service will force us to other restaurants.

😍

Another amazing meal here! The location is stunning, they

5/5 by 👻 @Kathy B. on 03/21/2023

Another amazing meal here! The location is stunning, they make the best Mai Tai, and the food, presentation and service are excellent.We had the Sashimi of Ahi and Ono, whiskey barrel aged soy sauce & wasabi with Kiawe salt and Waihee Tomato and Maui Onion with Point Reyes blue cheese and pine nuts which were great.We both loved the Ono with Hamakua mushrooms, garlic, white wine and capers and Mahi-Mahi with Lobster and Crab in a Macadamia nut crust.We were stuffed but decided on dessert: Banana Macadamia Nut Crisp and Chocolate Martini.If you have never been, you must try!

😍

The food here was phenomenal! We ordered the crab cakes as

5/5 by 👻 @Parisa M. on 03/21/2023

The food here was phenomenal! We ordered the crab cakes as an appetizer and they were delicious! The cakes were fluffy and light. The complimentary bisque was delicious. The fish special (can't remember what type of fish it was) was so good! I'd highly recommend the surf and turf too. Worth every penny

😍

30 years on Maui but still my most treasured place on Maui.

5/5 by 👻 @Diane N. on 03/20/2023

It's got it all...best ambiance, service and food! Cost is high, but you'll never regret it.

😒

Always at the top of the list when it comes to restaurants

3/5 by 👻 @John C. on 03/20/2023

Always at the top of the list when it comes to restaurants to try on Maui, we were very excited to visit this restaurant. When you arrive, the view does not disappoint, the perfect beach front scenery looks surreal. The staff was very friendly. However, at this price point, we didn't think the experience was worth it. The food was good, especially the fresh seafood, but the value just wasnt justified. If you're on Maui and you have the time, Mama's still provides a great experience, but it's not a must-try.

😍

Must Do!

5/5 by 👻 @Devlin M on 03/20/2023

This is a must do! Book early - it is worth it. A wonderful dinner and awesome experience. Totally worth all of the hype!

😍

Incredible food! Incredible service! Overall an incredible

5/5 by 👻 @Jason T. on 03/18/2023

Incredible food! Incredible service! Overall an incredible experience. Well worth the wait and price!

😍

Always special, always delicious!

5/5 by 👻 @ValerieJo18 on 03/18/2023

Mama's is a special place for special occasions or just because you are in Hawaii! We have gone 4+ times already over the years & will return as the food and service is just so wonderful. Fish is so fresh. I am hooked on the fish curry so it is what I get each time-but others I have dined with order other items and love them all. They have some lovely desserts, if you love chocolate then the Black Pearl is for you. They also have a comprehensive wine list. We were able to take home the half bottle we did not finish. Service is quite fast so if you want to linger tell your waiter to pace the meal or you will be in and out in less than an hour. Reservations a must and yes, it is quite pricey but as the meal is so delish / special it's ok. Also go before dark so you can get the pictures as it is a lovely spot!

😍

Absolutely theee Best

5/5 by 👻 @Havasupai on 03/17/2023

Mama's was absolutely thee best dining experience ever! The food itself was unbeatable. The environment both inside the restaurant as well as the grounds outside were superb. It is a must go - the best meal we ever had!

😍

Wonderful Birthday lunch!

5/5 by 👻 @Formans on 03/17/2023

Without question- the best meal of the trip! We were skeptical the food/service could be as good as advertised, but Mama's did an incredible job. The Kanpachi was absolutely incredible! We also really enjoyed the Macidenia Mahi Mahi. The waiter(young gentleman from West Texas) was very friendly and had great recommendations for our group. Finally the deserts were fantastic. Thanks for a great meal!

🤮

Bad Attitude

1/5 by 👻 @Larry J on 03/17/2023

Looks like their success has gone to their heads - stopped by last Friday mid-afternoon for a drink at the bar and the "guards" ran us out of the parking lot - "NO ROOM HERE" they said - you can leave and try later....I guess you have to give them Kudos for popularity - but their attitude sucks big-time. It looks like the lady "Gatekeeper" at the front desk takes quite the pleasure out of sending potential customers away....We won't be back.

😍

Bathroom was absolutely beautiful.

5/5 by 👻 @Bathroom R. on 03/17/2023

Used facilities after my meal and was very pleased! The decor reminded me my childhood growing up on the country side and coming down to Hawaii with my momma and pa. The only complaint I have is that the stalls were a wee bit tight for my liking. Other than that, it was extremely cleanly and very cute Onto the food. My meal was delicious! I got some sort of white fish called Kanpachi, with rice and it was to die for! Absolutely loved it, and I'm a picky eater.Service was perfect! Waitress came over to the table perfect amount of times and she was so very kind. Love this place and I will definitely come back. Amazing fish house.

😍

The food was out of this world! The waiter was amazing!

5/5 by 👻 @Dino M. on 03/17/2023

The food was out of this world! The waiter was amazing! Knowledgeable, humble and earnest. Came here for my 50th birthday... seems everyone was having a birthday! Drink selection, wine selection and fish were excellent and well curated. You'll drop a dime, but you'll remember the time.

😍

Make reservations EARLY.

5/5 by 👻 @Michelle L. on 03/16/2023

This place never disappoints. Everything is good

😍

An absolutely wonderful experience.

5/5 by 👻 @Randy M. on 03/15/2023

The food was to die for, the wait staff were excellent and the atmosphere superb. Be ready to fork out over at least $100 for two, but the dining experience was well worth it. All diners get valet parking, no self parking there.

😍

Special place

5/5 by 👻 @Lisa P on 03/14/2023

We loved everything about Mama’s Fish House. The food was delicious. The restaurant was beautiful Hawaiian style. The location was on a beautiful beach view. The service was wonderful.

😍

Food to Die For

5/5 by 👻 @Randy L on 03/14/2023

Location is a little out of the way but well worth the drive. Food is pricy but again well worth it. Ampshere was amazing. The wood works in the place are beautiful. Book way in advance of your trip.

😍

It is worth the hype! We finally got in this trip.

5/5 by 👻 @Deborah K. on 03/14/2023

It is a special place and almost an event. I'm so happy we were able to experience it!

😍

The most fantastic place to eat on Maui! Food, service,

5/5 by 👻 @Lee B. on 03/14/2023

The most fantastic place to eat on Maui! Food, service, ambiance! When we were there it was raining so hard that they had to use their umbrellas for everyone coming in and going out but they made it a fantastic experience anyway. Will always go back!

😍

MFH never disappoints!!! The service, the view and the food

5/5 by 👻 @Edwyna B. on 03/14/2023

MFH never disappoints!!! The service, the view and the food get 10/10! The crab stuffed Mahi Mahi was fantastic and paired well with the asparagus and yellow long beans.

🙂

Been there, went there, done it.

4/5 by 👻 @Erin M. on 03/13/2023

Was good for the hype and one time visit, had a few things which were overlooked like a birthday celebration which didn't get acknowledged. We also had the very last reservation of the evening and it seemed to our group that the waiter really just wanted to get home, wasn't as attentive as we expected for this type of establishment. Food was very good but the cost was really high for a 5 star restaurant in general. Won't be back next time we visit Maui but can say we visited. Really loved the decor and artwork. The pie was the best order on the menu. Heard from locals the pearl dessert is overhyped and the flavor of the chocolate pie was incredible. It was true! Would recommend this place for a first time visit if you're able to get reservations, otherwise you're ok if you miss it. They could use a couple more non-fish entree options and perhaps another kids option as well.

😍

Make your reservations early

5/5 by 👻 @Linda K on 03/12/2023

One restaurant you’ll be glad you didn’t miss! You will need to make your reservations now if you plan to visit 6 months to a year from now! The food, the service, and the view is awesome! Worth every penny!

😍

Loved it

5/5 by 👻 @RMR64 on 03/12/2023

We had read a lot about the restaurant before booking, we booked 7 months before coming as we were on a cruise with NCL, it has to be one of the best meals I have had not only the food was great but the location is to die for.

😍

I wish I could give this a 10 star rating.

5/5 by 👻 @karen m on 03/12/2023

This was by far my favorite day on Maui, and we had a whole lot of great experiences. It was magic from the first moment. After the initial checkin, we walked down to the beach and the restaurant, seeing from the outside Mamas Fish House. Charming is enough of a word, perfection comes close. I loved that the restaurant isn't massive, but busy and hopping. the decor was perfect, just right for a beach restaurant, but with unusual and lovely touches, like the carved wood benches, and canvas roof in one room. And the food? Ive been throwing around a lot of perfects, but starting with a ginger cocktail, to the fish, to the desert, everything just seemed to be in sync. fresh beautiful, but not fussy flower arrangements complimented everything, and yes, the music was just right. a delightful combination of Hawaiian traditional music, and fun 60 and 70s jazz. I would go back to Maui just for this experience

😍

Go before 11am opening time if you don't have reservations,

5/5 by 👻 @Melly E. on 03/12/2023

Go before 11am opening time if you don't have reservations, since they're booked 4+ months in advance. Drive to valet your car, then ask valet if there is availability. They will tell you if there is. They'll give you a ticket for your car. Give that to the hostess. They'll have openings at the bar area, and you'll be seated and ready for a truly incredible culinary experience. From the drinks to the appetizers, to the main courses, dessert and French pressed coffee, it is something to behold. Do yourself a favor & just go here without a reservation around10:30-10:45am for a once in a lifetime experience. Afterwards you can walk the grounds to the beach and soak in your morning. Pricey but worth it!!

😍

Mama's Fish House

5/5 by 👻 @Excursion597007 on 03/10/2023

Excellent food and a great experience. Its expensive but, definitely worth the costs. Meals are delicious and service is great. Very relaxing atmosphere and the flower arrangements are beautiful along with the grounds outside the restaurant. Exceptional food and service.

😍

Absolutely highly recommend!!!

5/5 by 👻 @Brianyfs on 03/09/2023

Great (and I mean absolutely great) meal - Crème Brûlée one of the best I have ever had! If you can get in for lunch or dinner - GO!!

😍

Absolutely loving it!

5/5 by 🐶 @DogmaticWave16 on 03/05/2023

Hard to make reservation but foods are wonderful!

😍

Mama Fish House has the best seafood!

5/5 by 👻 @CorrespondingDegree78 on 02/06/2023

Best seafood ever!

😍

The Best!!

5/5 by 👻 @ConfidentialOven12 on 09/21/2022

I love to go to Mama's Fish House Paia. A hidden gem! Absolute must for anyone traveling or local!

😍

Best food in Maui

5/5 by 👻 @KentuckyOnthego on 08/06/2022

This was truly the most amazing dinner we had while in Maui. The restaurant is beautiful, the grounds are breathtaking, food is delicious, and their staff are delightful. From the moment our car was parked until we left was an A+ experience.

😍

This place is awesome probably the best restaurant

5/5 by 👻 @Brandon G. on 08/05/2022

This place is awesome probably the best restaurant experience I've ever had in my life the food is incredible the view is beautiful and you will not be disappointed we go back to Maui every year from the mainland and we make sure to always have a reservation at mamas fish house make sure to make your reservation six months in advance otherwise you will definitely have a hard time getting a table this place is considered one of the top 10 restaurants in the world and I agree with that and this place is a very expensive restaurant and well worth it it's an experience you will never forget enjoy

😍

Mama's Fish House lives up to the hype! You are not just

5/5 by 👻 @Tana T. on 08/05/2022

Mama's Fish House lives up to the hype! You are not just here to eat, you are here to eat it all up- the scene, the service and the food. We got here an hr and a half before sunset so aloha beautiful ocean view and island ambiance. Appetizer, mushroom bisque, house bread, fish entrees and dessert were all delicious. My only change is more liquor to our adult drinks. They were a bit watered down and I'm not a fan of paying for overpriced ice.

😍

Anniversary dinner properly celebrated

5/5 by 👻 @Heather L on 08/05/2022

Fine dining with island comfort. View, service, food were all terrific. One of our best meals on Maui for sure. Our server was very attentive but we did not feel rushed. Our dinners were beautiful and well-prepared. I would definitely go back. The grounds alone are beautiful enough to see again. A Maui tradition for a reason!

😍

The best meal of my entire life

5/5 by 👻 @Ali on 08/04/2022

I balked at the price, but everything I ate was absolutely incredible. The setting is gorgeous too and was a wonderful destination in and of itself. In the end, it was worth every penny, it’s a very special place.

😍

Fantastic experience.

5/5 by 👻 @Bruce S. on 08/02/2022

Food was awesome. Service was awesome. Was it pricey? Sure you could say that, but we have no regrets at all. We'd go here again. Can't say enough good things about our dinner tonight. If you're considering going here, go. Thank you Mama for an excellent evening!

😍

Let's start from the beginning, it is extremely difficult

5/5 by 👻 @Tan B. on 08/02/2022

Let's start from the beginning, it is extremely difficult to get a reservation here but if you do manage to it's well worth it! Typically they say they are booked out 6 months in advance but we were lucky enough to call 1 week prior to see if there was any cancellations and we managed to get a table.The entrance requires valet parking which is complimentary. The restaurant is in a very scenic location so be sure to take many pictures.The menu changes day to day and also the fish is caught fresh so the type of fish varies. We ordered the Mahi Mahi in a Macadamia nut crust with lobster, it also came with asparagus and mash potatoes. We also ordered the Grand Banks Scallops which came with a Mushroom risotto. Both dishes were excellent and extremely delicious - as you would expect! Prior to our mains we received complimentary bread and a small soup.For dessert we ordered the Black Pearl which not only is aesthetically pleasing to the eye but extremely tasty!All in all an amazing experience when visiting Maui.

Videos & Internet Profiles of Mama's Fish House Paia

Instagram Facebook Yelp TripAdvisor OpenTable

Other Popular Restaurants in Paia

Monkeypod Kitchen by Merriman - Wailea Kihei

Star Noodle Lahaina

Old Lahaina Luau

Spago Kihei

Koiso Sushi Bar Kihei

Lineage Wailea-Makena

Lahaina Grill Lahaina

Fleetwood's on Front St. Lahaina

Pailolo Bar & Grill Lahaina

Leoda's Kitchen and Pie Shop Lahaina

Best Posts

Discussions

Reviews

AppointmentTrader FAQ

Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?

By 🥷🏻 @ColorfulRod45, 07/13/2021 6:55 pm

Are you affiliated with restaurants / or any of the other venues which are listed?

3 Thumbs Up

Answer question "Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?"

Cancel

12 Answers

2 Comments

Don't like the Answer?
Add another one.

Answer from 🦩 @FluffyStar64 (07/13/2021 9:05 pm)

Best Answer Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.

9 Thumbs Up

1 Comment

Comment

By 🥷🏻 @ColorfulRod45 (07/13/2021 9:06 pm)

Thanks :)

2 Thumbs Up

Answer from 👻 @DemureKettle15 (05/04/2022 10:51 am)

Can come from a lot of places, people who don't want to get charged their cancellation fee or people who just have them and cant go.

5 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👻 @ColloquialPosition80 (06/03/2022 2:39 pm)

alot are work dinners that are cancelled

2 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 🥩 @FamousStation67 (09/17/2022 6:38 pm)

Party promotors

2 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 🤠 @DeliberateScale19 (11/20/2022 8:59 am)

Users who have reservations they can no longer use

2 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👹 @GuiltlessNose33 (12/06/2022 7:05 pm)

Some people have connections, some can't make their own reservations and are giving it up, others...

2 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👻 @AffectionateRegret15 (11/15/2022 12:56 am)

I mean.... it is web scrapers. Is this a serious question?

1 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👻 @ConnectedExistence32 (01/14/2023 12:18 pm)

Ppl waiting in line at the DMV…

1 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👻 @NaughtyBread30 (05/12/2023 7:14 pm)

almost all restaurants aren't affiliated with AT and I'm guessing it's mostly people wanting to not pay cancellation fees.

1 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 👻 @GoldenAmusement60 (05/21/2023 11:33 am)

Reservation Storks

1 Thumbs Up

1 Comment

Comment

By 🥷🏻 @ColorfulRod45 (06/01/2023 9:22 pm)

🤣

0 Thumbs Up

Answer from 🐧 @AwakeDecision53 (12/11/2022 10:40 am)

They are from people who made the reservation and can/do not want to attend.

0 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

Answer from 🥩 @DecadentRoof69 (01/30/2023 4:45 pm)

Unusable reservations, bots, users sourcing their own, etc.

0 Thumbs Up

0 Comments

Comment

24hr:	$11,295	👥 Online: 944
12mo:	$3,054,837	👥 Online: 20,488