Mama's Fish House Paia Yelp Reviews - Mama's Fish House Paia - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Mama's Fish House Paia for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Mama's Fish House Paia from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Paia's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mama's Fish House Paia
Booked 4 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #10 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #2 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #5 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #11 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #3 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #6 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #9 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #15 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #25 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #22 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #18 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mama's Fish House Paia customers.
Ranked #26 in Paia's Best Restaurants.
Mama's Fish House Paia Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
77 Reviews
0 Replys |
Amazing food as others have stated.
You enter into the restaurant and it's like taking a step into a whole new Hawaiian experience. Reservations were inconvenient to plan ahead of time. The food was amazing. We really enjoyed the curry and the fish. Service and ambiance was perfect!
Be the first to ReplyWe missed getting a reservation the first time we were on
We missed getting a reservation the first time we were on Maui, so we made sure to book months in advance before our last trip - even three months out, all the prime dinner spots were booked, but we were able to get a 2:30 reservation which ended up working out perfectly for our 7:55 flight. If you are looking for a speedy, inexpensive meal, definitely don't come here because this is not the place to get in and out in under an hour. But if you are looking for an experience with good food to celebrate something special while you're visiting Maui, this place will suit your needs! Driving into the gorgeous property, the first thing you notice is a busy parking lot. Luckily everything is valet parking only with no ability to self-park, so you join the queue and get greeted by an attendant decently quickly upon your arrival. The hostess took the name for our reservation and told us to sit until our table was available. For our 2:30 reservation we were seated around 2:37, so pretty much on time. We were taken to our table which had a personalized card with our names and a "happy anniversary" note on it, which is a nice touch. I will say, it took a while for our waiter to come around, but this was an anomaly as I would say the beginning was the only time we had to wait for service. Prior to our waiter coming, we were brought waters from another waitstaff almost immediately. When our waiter finally came around, he introduced himself, welcomed us to the restaurant, and wished us a happy anniversary. Then he listed off the specials and asked if we wanted any appetizers or drinks. As two non-drinkers, we both ordered POG juice (not on the menu) and my partner ordered the Ahi Poisson Cru. We were shortly after brought freshly baked bread, which was delicious, a small dish of pickles for me, the vegetarian, and a small cup of broccolini bisque for the non-vegetarian. As a vegetarian I had checked reviews about vege options ahead of time and was just expecting to be able to eat the curry, but was pleasantly surprised when our waiter said I could get the first five things on the menu made vege with tofu. I did, however, settle for the banana curry. It was delicious and very filling, and I especially loved the mango chutney, apple bananas, mac nuts, and sambal that accompanied my dish. Mama's definitely has it nailed in terms of the presentation of their dishes - everything was beautiful! My partner got the mahi-mahi sauteed with waihe'e tomato, capers, and olena risotto and thought it was very tasty. He did note that the mahi mahi portion he got at Paia Fish Market earlier in the trip was bigger, but said they were both tasty. We couldn't leave Mama's without also trying their banana macadamia nut crisp with vanilla ice cream. The crisp was delicious. They also brought us some kind of fruit jelly dessert for our anniversary on the house, which was also tasty. Prior to receiving our bill, we were brought almond scented warm towels to wash our hands. They smelled lovely. Even as non-drinkers and one non-seafood eater (my vege dish cost ~ $20 less than the dishes listed on the menu), our bill was still around $200. We were expecting it, but just want to call it out. We were very happy we checked this place out, but given the price and the overall hassle of having to plan ahead months in advance, it's probably not a place we need to come back to. My only gripe is that for the business of the restaurant and the number of customers they have, they have very limited restroom facilities which is a bit of a nuisance. TL;DR - If you're looking for a lovely place to eat delicious food while you're on Maui, check out Mama's. The property is beautiful with a gorgeous protected cove/beach.
Be the first to ReplyThe view is beautiful! Well worth the visit.
I have been before and it was as good as I remembered it to be.
Be the first to ReplyThis seaside restaurant is lovely and romantic.
The service was excellent and the meals were great. I feel like for special occasions this is the perfect place to try at least once.
Be the first to ReplyWhere do I start.
.. Tried to get online reservations about 3 months out. That didn't work so I called and got a reservation for my wife's birthday on our honeymoon very easily Card's congratulating both were waiting on our table My wife got the lobster tails and I got the Hawaiian Kanpache with crab and lobster The food and the service were absolutely amazing from appetizers to dessert Which I had the pearl mouse and coffee martini We sat right in the front corner and watched the beach and waves and enjoyed one of the best meals I ever had From the cards on the table to the front corner seating to the valet parking it was just an epic experience and I hope others may enjoy this like we did Yeah it was pricey but to celebrate something in Hawaii well...it's going to be pricey I have absolutely no complaints and will happily bring my Visa card next time I come to Maui Mahalo
Be the first to ReplyWhat can I say about mamas fish House? Beautiful view ,
What can I say about mamas fish House? Beautiful view , perfect ambience, gracious servers, knowledgeable staff. My girlfriend managed to snag us two seats at the bar. Keep in mind this restaurant is booked out like 6 months. I always like to ask the staff what should I order get the local recommendations? Our nice bartenders answer " you really cannot go wrong with any dish" He was so right!!!!!! Wow wow wow, everything so fresh, so tender I don't have any bad words to say about this establishment. This is a must stop on every Maui trip!!
Be the first to ReplyAlways a place to take our out of town family when they
Always a place to take our out of town family when they visit. Seafood selection is always fresh and delicious.
Be the first to ReplyMax was a fantastic waiter.
Everyone was welcoming and friendly. The food was delicious, Thank you for making our evening so special.
Be the first to ReplyWhat a treat! I spoiled myself for my birthday as this is a
What a treat! I spoiled myself for my birthday as this is a pricey restaurant, but the service and food all exceeded my expectations! I had the curry which featured ahi, mahi mahi, and salmon with locally sourced veggies.
Be the first to ReplyAlthough pricey and difficult to get reservations (unless
Although pricey and difficult to get reservations (unless you're a planner, think 6-12 months in advance) it's DEFINITELY worth every penny. Food is amazing, service is attentive without being invasive. The macadamia nut crusted stuffed fish with crab plus a lobster tail is my favorite. My only regret is that usually I'm the driver and can't enjoy the wonderful cocktails! I'd call this one of my "happy places".
Be the first to ReplyI recently dined at Mama's Fish House a few nights back.
The service at Mama's Fish House is truly 5-star. The staff were attentive, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to ensure our dining experience was memorable. This oceanfront restaurant offers stunning views, making it the perfect backdrop for a romantic dinner or special occasion. Gazing out at the ocean while enjoying our meal added an extra layer of magic to the evening. Speaking of the meal, every dish we tried was outstanding. The Haleakala beef is my favorite standout pupu, bursting with flavor and beautifully presented in a papaya. For dessert, the coconut chiffon cake stole the show with its light and airy texture that left me craving more. I'm not a huge cake person usually, so that cake was unbelievably delicious. The Prawns with Tahitian vanilla were another highlight, what a unique use of ingredients and flavors! And let's not forget the cocktails - the pau hana drink is my favorite here. Overall, my dinner experience at Mama's Fish House was nothing short of spectacular. Whether you're a resident or visiting Maui, I highly recommend treating yourself to a meal at this gem of a restaurant. I can't wait to return for another unforgettable dining experience sometime in the future. Note: there is valet parking when you arrive onto the property.
Be the first to ReplyComplimentary valet parking.
Beautiful place and interesting decoration. The service was great and accommodating. Went here for lunch, reserved for 4 people and did it 5 months in advance. Got the oysters and lobster tail. It was delicious! I enjoyed the food. The dessert was aesthetically pleasing and interested flavored. Would highly recommend coming here for the food!
Be the first to ReplyI recently dined at Mama's Fish House during my visit to
I recently dined at Mama's Fish House during my visit to Maui, and although I had high expectations, I was left with mixed feelings about my experience. The restaurant itself offers a beautiful ocean view, which was a definite plus. However, the food didn't quite live up to the hype.The seafood was fresh, which is always appreciated, but the dishes were just okay. Nothing really stood out as exceptional or memorable, which was a bit disappointing considering the restaurant's reputation. I've had better seafood elsewhere on the island.Surprisingly, the highlight of my meal was the smoothie. It was delicious, refreshing, and perfectly balanced in terms of flavor and consistency. It's a bit ironic that my favorite part of the dining experience wasn't even the main focus of the menu.Overall, Mama's Fish House offers a decent meal with a nice view, but it didn't leave a lasting impression on me. The smoothie was the standout item, which is quite telling about the rest of the food. If you're looking for a more remarkable dining experience in Maui, you might want to consider trying other options.
Be the first to ReplyWhere to begin.
..Mama's was the highlight of my family's recent Hawaii trip! The location, the service and the food!! Karen was perfection, explaining each dish, the fish and the cocktails...what the famous dishes and drinks were and the house favorites. All of us loved all the food, but each of us preferred the dish we ordered for ourself. Great service!! And when all of that is said and done, you are sitting on the most beautiful piece of coastline, enjoying the natural ocean breezes as they blow through the dining room!! We are already planning our trip back to Maui just for another dining experience at Mama's. Mahalo Mama's!!
Be the first to ReplyWe heard so many positive reports about Mama's Seafood that
We heard so many positive reports about Mama's Seafood that we wanted to try it, but then, reservations were reportedly very difficult too, so we weren't that optimistic. However, a time came available and we booked it.When we arrived (2:30pm) I was a little pessimistic due to all the hype, but that all disappeared very quickly as each attendant unapologetically was super-attentive and helpful, including the valet, host, greeter, second host, and busser. Our server was warm and friendly, knowledgeable and meek, yet subtle and confident. The food was outstanding, and memorable. It is very expensive but the experience well worth it. Whether we will be back is another story, but we will recommend it to everyone without hesitation. A great dining experience for sure!Thank you Mama!
Be the first to ReplyAmazing! While it can be hard to get a table here it's
Amazing! While it can be hard to get a table here it's worth the effort. You can set alerts on opentable to find a spot when someone cancels but they go fast. If you can book ahead do so. From the location, the decor, the service but most importantly the cuisine MAMA's exceeds the hype. Several times guests along with myself have commented that it has been the best meal they ever had. Even coming from those who don't really enjoy seafood. That's saying something. I typically enjoy dining on the locally caught fish often on fish I've only seen on their menu. It truly is a gem do yourself a favor and just listen to all the excellent reviews and try for yourself. Prices are comparable to other locations on the island yet service ambiance and most importantly cuisine are outstanding and exceed the others. It's always a unforgettable memory having the pleasure to dine there if you are on the fence just go make and make your own memories there. You won't regret it!
Be the first to ReplyFirst time eating at Mama's Fish House and it exceeded our
First time eating at Mama's Fish House and it exceeded our expectations! The meal was outstanding and amazing customer service.As our appetizer we had the Maui Octopus and was cooked perfect and tasted amazing.I had the Mahi-Mahi with Lobster and Crab in Macadamia Nut Crust and my Wife had the Beef Short Rib "Pulehu" and Tristan Lobster Tail. Both cooked perfect and very flavourful! Highly recommend both of them!For dessert we enjoyed the Polynesian Black Pearl. Visually beautiful and tasted great!
Be the first to ReplyThe food here was phenomenal! We ordered the crab cakes as
The food here was phenomenal! We ordered the crab cakes as an appetizer and they were delicious! The cakes were fluffy and light. The complimentary bisque was delicious. The fish special (can't remember what type of fish it was) was so good! I'd highly recommend the surf and turf too. Worth every penny
Be the first to ReplyAnother amazing meal here! The location is stunning, they
Another amazing meal here! The location is stunning, they make the best Mai Tai, and the food, presentation and service are excellent.We had the Sashimi of Ahi and Ono, whiskey barrel aged soy sauce & wasabi with Kiawe salt and Waihee Tomato and Maui Onion with Point Reyes blue cheese and pine nuts which were great.We both loved the Ono with Hamakua mushrooms, garlic, white wine and capers and Mahi-Mahi with Lobster and Crab in a Macadamia nut crust.We were stuffed but decided on dessert: Banana Macadamia Nut Crisp and Chocolate Martini.If you have never been, you must try!
Be the first to ReplyAlways at the top of the list when it comes to restaurants
Always at the top of the list when it comes to restaurants to try on Maui, we were very excited to visit this restaurant. When you arrive, the view does not disappoint, the perfect beach front scenery looks surreal. The staff was very friendly. However, at this price point, we didn't think the experience was worth it. The food was good, especially the fresh seafood, but the value just wasnt justified. If you're on Maui and you have the time, Mama's still provides a great experience, but it's not a must-try.
Be the first to Reply30 years on Maui but still my most treasured place on Maui.
It's got it all...best ambiance, service and food! Cost is high, but you'll never regret it.
Be the first to ReplyIncredible food! Incredible service! Overall an incredible
Incredible food! Incredible service! Overall an incredible experience. Well worth the wait and price!
Be the first to ReplyThe food was out of this world! The waiter was amazing!
The food was out of this world! The waiter was amazing! Knowledgeable, humble and earnest. Came here for my 50th birthday... seems everyone was having a birthday! Drink selection, wine selection and fish were excellent and well curated. You'll drop a dime, but you'll remember the time.
Be the first to ReplyBathroom was absolutely beautiful.
Used facilities after my meal and was very pleased! The decor reminded me my childhood growing up on the country side and coming down to Hawaii with my momma and pa. The only complaint I have is that the stalls were a wee bit tight for my liking. Other than that, it was extremely cleanly and very cute Onto the food. My meal was delicious! I got some sort of white fish called Kanpachi, with rice and it was to die for! Absolutely loved it, and I'm a picky eater.Service was perfect! Waitress came over to the table perfect amount of times and she was so very kind. Love this place and I will definitely come back. Amazing fish house.
Be the first to ReplyMake reservations EARLY.
This place never disappoints. Everything is good
Be the first to Reply