Melba's New York Yelp Reviews - Melba's New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Melba's New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Melba's New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Melba's New York
Melba's New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
38 Reviews
0 Replys |
I really wanted to like this restaurant but the lack of
I really wanted to like this restaurant but the lack of service, disorganization and mediocre food would not allow me to give Melba's past a 1 star rating.Story time, we got here past our reservation time so I will take that on the chin but to wait over an hour and a half while there were empty seats approximately 5 tables open, is out of control.Melba HERSELF was there and saw us waiting with open seats in HER restaurant and did nothing about it. SMH she even spoke to us but didn't challenge the hostess who was rude and clearly not properly trained to do her job.Cons:-sweet potato's came from a can-our drinks came out when our meal did -the waitress was friendly but not very attentive (they were not busy)-mac and cheese; more cheese than anything elsePros:-strawberry Hennessy So much potential, poor execution.
Be the first to ReplyVisited NY for a special occasion.
Being from the south I was looking for soul food. The group selected Melba's. I don't know how or who thought this was a great choice for soul food. The food was horrible! HORRIBLE. The potato salad had no flavor, no seasonings. It was potato and mayo. Living in Maryland we asked about the lump crab cakes. The biggest disappointment. Small, flat and breaded. The collard greens full of vinegar - no flavor! Turkey meatloaf was a sliced loaf ordered from somewhere frozen. There were no signs of homemade. Disappointing. The desserts were not homemade and appeared to come from a box. Definitely it was store bought. My friends called it nursing home food for those with a restricted diet. The place was crowded and I didn't understand why. Then to top it off the food was nasty and the bill was $140. The best part of the place is the artwork. Do yourself a favor, save some money and skip this on your next trip to NY.
Be the first to ReplyFantastic soul food!! We got lucky with a last minute
Fantastic soul food!! We got lucky with a last minute reservation and was greeted with warm service and cozy atmosphere upon walking in. To start off, we ordered the Melba's Spring Rolls, which were bursting with flavor and paired well with the sauce on the side. For our mains, my favorite was the Chicken and Waffles. The chicken was perfectly crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, and the waffles were fluffy and sweet. We also got the BBQ Braised Short Ribs with our choice of collard greens and sweet yam as sides, and it did not disappoint. The meat was tender and falling off the bone, and the BBQ sauce was tangy and sweet. I especially enjoyed the collard greens, which were well-cooked and seasoned, and the sweet yam added a nice contrast to the savory ribs.Overall nice atmosphere and lovely Southern-style dishes!
Be the first to ReplyIt had been years since I'd last been to Melba's, so I was
It had been years since I'd last been to Melba's, so I was so pleasantly surprised to see they had expanded, making the space even larger. This may have been done a while ago, but because I hadn't been, I didn't know. Also, Melba was there, wonderfully greeting her guests and speaking about the restaurant to all who asked her questions.And then the food came (quickly too!). Although I recall her speaking about how she was making cleaner soul food (years ago), I wasn't prepared for HOW clean and HOW delicious it would be. So flavorful, but still soul food. It's proof positive that soul food doesn't need to be drowned in sugar or butter for it to taste exceptional. Masterful is the only word I can think of to describe what I experienced. I absolutely cannot wait to go back.
Be the first to ReplyGreeters were pleasant but not welcoming.
15 minutes to get a drink at a bar with only two other people????? Appetizers arrived lukewarm to cold. Still wondering the name of server since he did not introduce himself. Ambience was very cafeteria. Staff having more fun in the back of the dining area than the patrons. I was very disappointed. Two stars because my guest enjoyed the Oxtails.
Be the first to ReplyWarm, intimate, quality.
Inviting, home cooking with love. VISIT MELBASShe has obviously handled picked her partners. Everyone was welcoming.
Be the first to ReplyI wasn't expecting Melba's to be so good because I am from
I wasn't expecting Melba's to be so good because I am from the south and what northern city can do soul food like the south? I had to eat my words. The food was delicious. Melba's would have received 5 stars; however, if you are going to do soul food then you must have cornbread and Melba's doesn't serve cornbread. Ms. Melba, now you know better. Fly me to NYC and I will show you how to make gluten-free and regular cornbread that will make you dance. I had Salmon, candied yams, and collard greens. I also had a sangria. For dessert, we opted for the sweet potato pie which was delightful. Also, Bryan, our server was so friendly and helpful and he deserves an award for being one of the best servers ever. Please give this man a raise. He went above and beyond to make us happy and he definitely exceeded our expectations. Kudos to Bryan. Lastly, that hot sauce is amazing. I am waiting for it to be bottled and mass produced because I will definitely be ordering some.
Be the first to ReplyI had a great experience at Melba's.
Our party of 4 was able to walk in and get seated without a reservation. The ambiance and the food were great. I ordered the fried chicken, collard greens, and yams. The Southern Fried Chicken was super crispy and juicy. The collard greens were good, just wish it was in a separate bowl so the juices wouldn't flow into the yams and chicken. Other then that, great experience.
Be the first to ReplyMy husband and I were celebrating a wedding
My husband and I were celebrating a wedding anniversary/date weekend. The amazing staff accommodated our last-minute request to dine at the restaurant that morning. They went above and beyond to ensure that our first experience was more than we imagined. From the moment we sat down our server Olleigh B. cultivated an experience through all her suggestions; from beverages that complimented the "must try appetizers" like Melba's Spring Rolls that are not just eaten but as Olleigh said, "are inhaled." That's what we did with the rolls and the Country Catfish Strips. Her suggestions for our brunch selections were exquisitely tasteful. Hubby had the Honey-Ginger Baked Salmon with greens, peas and rice; I had Melba's Signature Chicken & Eggnog Waffles. And it didn't stop there because Olleigh B.'s recommendations for dessert were on point. Our experience was made that much more personable when we were able to meet the proprietor of the establishment herself, Melba. Wow! All around unforgettable! So glad we were able to see this black-owned restaurant featured on MSGs celebration of Black Excellence and Empowerment during Black History Month. Had we would not, we would have never discovered this staple in the community of Harlem. And don't forget to stop by the bar. Helen L. was working her magic as well. We will be back!
Be the first to ReplyMy best birthday party ever was hosted by Melba's.
The place is warm and friendly. My beloved, Jesus, alerted the owner that it was my birthday. When dessert arrived, the whole staff came out from the kitchen to serve me a luscious baked Alaska. They did not sing that depressing song "happy birthday " (which should only be played at funerals). No, they sang the Stevie Wonder version - a tribute to Dr. King. The whole restaurant chimed in- with ad-libbed harmonies. I was so happy that I cried tears of gratitude. Thank you, Melba's - the best, friendliest restaurant in NYC.
Be the first to ReplyMelba's has been a go to for our family for several years.
Friends in town, birthdays, no particular reason lol. (Even during the pandemic it was our go to) Today my honey and I went just the two of us in the middle the day and what a treat. Food was delicious as always (I switched up today,first time I had salmon and it was sooooo good) our server Kenny was amazing... so attentive, personable and added to our great date afternoon. He could have sat and joined us and fit right in. Then to top it off the beautiful Melba herselfcame in and she could have sat with us too. She Welcomed us, shared great upcoming stuff and we took pics. Such a pleasure to support establishments such as this. If you haven't been... what you waitin for.
Be the first to ReplyIn town on business.
Our group of 9 had a reservation and was seated right away. Waiter was attentive he gave good recommends and everyone really loved their food. Everyone accept me. I had the chicken and egg nog waffle and honestly it felt me cold. No hints of eggnog came through. The strawberry butter was equally, blah. The waffle and chicken wings were well executed, but flavorless. I'd come back, just recommend skipping this dish.
Be the first to ReplyAt first I was unsure of the prices here, but it turned out
At first I was unsure of the prices here, but it turned out to be one of my cheaper meals during my trip at the end of the day. Without reservations, we were able to get a seat indoors for a late lunch. The restaurant has beautiful artwork and great music taste (had me looking for a playlist!). The employees are very friendly when spoken to. I got the mushroom pot pie with the Mac and cheese and A$AP yams. I think I made a very good choice with this and recommend it to anyone else stopping by. The portions don't seem like a lot at first but are filling and I had left overs to take back. The mushrooms were cooked perfectly thought I didn't feel like the phyllo added much. My friend got the crispy catfish sandwich which was pretty much just a normal fish sandwich with better quality ingredients, nothing too special going on. They didn't like the fries which were thick but only had seasoning on the outside so the flavor didn't go through.
Be the first to ReplyThe host on Saturday night has an attitude.
Maybe she's overwhelmed, who knows. Our waitress was very nice and accommodating. She definitely got that 20% tip. The ambiance nice. Good upbeat music. The place had a at home dining room look. There was a line going into this place. Reservations is a must if you want to eat here. The collard greens was sweet and spicy 5/10. I've had better. The Mac and cheese was seasoned, gluey, and too a la dente as someone said 4/10. The fried chicken was partially cold, dry, not that flavorful. It was a breast with an attached wing but I've had juicier pieces of white meat before 0/10. To be honest I can't trust restaurants who always advertising their establishments on tv.
Be the first to ReplyThis place is amazing.
Came right when they opened on a Saturday for brunch with a friend, and the service was stellar. Our server recommended the crab cakes, which we got as an appetizer and were delicious.But the main event!! The chicken skin was so crispy and flavorful, and the meat itself was juicy. The waffle was real fluffy, and the strawberry butter was perfect.I'm from California, so I always just get chicken & waffles at Roscoe's. This was 100x better, can't even compare!
Be the first to ReplyAtmosphere was cozy and sort of family style.
Small place where everyone is kind of close together. They play good music. I had a margarita which I felt wasn't strong.... I also had the catfish with Mac n cheese and collard green. Everything tasted good and was seasoned well. The only complaint was my collard greens. They were slimy..... I told the waiter about it he reheated my collards and the slimy texture subsided.
Be the first to ReplyI get the hype but the food was disappointing.
Mac and cheese was like glue, crab cakes tasted canned, fried food was mid. Greens were pretty tasty and the music was on point.Skip the mimosas, tasted like 90% juice.
Be the first to ReplyOrdered from Uber eats .
.. Oxtails and potato salad was one of a kind. I would def recommend can't wait to sit down in this restaurant
Be the first to ReplyI ordered pick up and waited for over an hour.
They did not prepare my chicken as specified in my order, and my side of mac and cheese was only half full. Mac and cheese? More like cheese. I had multiple bites of just congealed cheese. The candied yams were nice and smoky, but a little too sweet. Overall, the food is alright but not worth the hype.
Be the first to ReplyWho is good chick it was nice and crispy and flavored
Who is good chick it was nice and crispy and flavored crabcakes is on point love the spring rolls
Be the first to ReplyI liked it, but I didn't love it.
Our group of 6 waited well over an hour for Sunday brunch and the food didn't really have that "wow factor" once we got it. The Mac and Cheese and eggnog waffle were excellent, but everything else was mediocre: catfish wasn't as well seasoned as I would've liked; the sweet potatoes were too sweet and the ox tails were just ok.
Be the first to ReplyPros: I was seated pretty quickly when the hostess actually
Pros: I was seated pretty quickly when the hostess actually spoke and made eye contact with me. The hostess seems incredibly "over" busy and it's a little chaotic when you walk in. Might be a relative. Surely a family vibe in there. Pros: The people bussing the tables WORK HARD! They are bringing you water fast, your drinks, clearing tables, they are the hardest working people! Always respect those cleaning your tables! I left them tips. Because they were BUSSIN BUSSIN! Melba should be thankful for them. Ok. Our server tried her best to be nice but you know the vibe lol. Frozen cat fish $18.99 shame shame shame. I can't even get into the frozen fried catfish. It tastes so fraudulent. I mean the breading is really tasty - but you know that frozen fish taste. Wow. I think they might save the fresh fish for the Celebs Bobby Flays and local congressmen . I guess when you're from L.A you are spoiled by the fresh fish markets. Anyway, I'll move on. My husband enjoyed his oxtails. The smothered chicken our other guest had was somewhat enjoyed. The Mac and cheese they gave me. Just look at the picture - it was a glob of cheese ball covered in noodles. This was kinda disrespectful. Laughable. The greens were kinda tasty, it's clear that sugar is added to them. I never put sugar in my greens - it might be a thing. But they were ok. If you're in Harlem and looking for a snack - this place is an option for soul food. I can't do the frozen fish ever again. But this is not a place to get your money's worth or get full. To be fair though - after the pandemic is anyone really giving 100% we do need a restructuring moment and once they start offering decent catfish - I might return.
Be the first to ReplyFried chicken with mac & cheese were marvelous! My friend
Fried chicken with mac & cheese were marvelous! My friend had ox tails which were also awesome! Only issue is that it was super crowded, it's a little bit hard to hear anybody speak but perhaps it was because I want during Saturday lunchtime. Will write another review With a dinner experience
Be the first to ReplyDecided to come here after a few drinks for some southern
Decided to come here after a few drinks for some southern comfort food and it did not disappoint! Ordered the chicken and waffles which apparently went up against Bobby Flay and it was a pretty solid choice! Chicken was fried/ cooked perfectly and the waffel with strawberry butter was a winner! Definitely recommend if you're in the area!
Be the first to ReplyThe food, the drinks, the service and the music all just
The food, the drinks, the service and the music all just perfect at this wonderful Harlem Soul Food restaurant. I highly recommend it !
Be the first to Reply