AppointmentTrader FAQ - Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City Reviews from The Last Year
Great food, atmosphere and hospitality .
Everything is amazing . Will def be back. Highly recommend the lobster mac and cheese and brussel sprouts
It was recently renovated so everything inside is clean and
It was recently renovated so everything inside is clean and fairly new. The service is fantastic, even though a few guys have a bit of Jersey attitude, and while they occasionally sound snarky they are always on point. You never wait for a thing. The food, well it's not Bobby Flay, but it's consistently great for the price. We nearly always get the filet. We picked broccoli this time to go with and didn't get mashed potatoes since the steak comes on a huge hash brown soaked in all the steak goodness and sauce, and found it (the broccoli) a bit below par comparatively. {Broccoli Rant} (It's just "sautéed" broccoli, so if the broccoli isn't great you can't do much with it. I would have at least trimmed off the brownish stalk ends,) and when I asked for butter on it when I ordered, I got the "it's on the table" aforementioned attitude, even though he went ahead and asked the chef to put it on there anyway. You had to cut it with the steak knife and had no seasoning on it at all. It came plain or garlic/oil and that often means olive which the hubby doesn't tolerate well in large amounts.... Anyway at $16 I was disappointed since I love broccoli. {/end broccoli rant} Everything else was fantastic. The steak was cooked perfectly, the bread they serve is phenomenal, and I always get the crème brûlée, which is pretty great here.
The food and service is amazing every single time we eat
The food and service is amazing every single time we eat here. Ambiance relaxing. Definitely recommend!
Ate there last night 3/12.
It had been at least 20 years since I was in the place. The decor and style changed drastically. The bar looked completely different. I definitely liked the way it looked. Was seated immediately. I didn't need a menu because I had already looked at it outside. Glass of water was brought right away and refilled constantly without asking. Started off with the steakhouse salad. Could have easily just had that as my meal. Feeds 2 people very easily. Took about half of that with me. Decided to just go with a burger. It was enormously. Cooked perfectly to my specification of medium well. Accompanied with lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onions and giant onion rings. Really didn't need to order the fries. Took those back with me too. The only slip up is when the waiter asked if I wanted to see a dessert menu. I hadn't even gotten the burger yet. I thought that was funny anyway. I was too full and declined to have dessert. A very reasonable bill of $77. Just about a 25% tip. Left $100. All in all, a very good experience. Would not hesitate to go back again.
First time at Old Homestead and it won't be the last.
We're from Wyoming so have eaten many good steaks, but never any better than here. Henry's menu knowledge was impeccable, service was top notch, conversation was engaging and we were more friends than customers as we departed.
Where's the Beef? Old Homestead!!! :)
☆☆☆☆Omg! I'm a foody and appreciative of good food, service, and ambiance. Bing~bang, Old Homestead, covers all three, lol. The Prime Rib was a little well done but tasty. The broccoli rabbe was tough but garlicky flavorful. The spinach sautéed was quite delicious, and the warm walnut raisin complementary buns were nice. The star☆ of the experience was the strawberry shortcake 🍰. Pam, our server, was busy and attentive. Did an awesome job! Kudos, thank you. I will recommend and will be back to check out more delicious cuisine on the menu. 😊 2/26/2024
The most proper drink you will have in the borgata! They
The most proper drink you will have in the borgata! They mix the most delicious drinks! Attention to detail is not missed in the wonderfully flavorful drinks I had the most delicious steak and added a lobster tail! Delicious The kids were with us so we got a chicken parm with pasta! Omg wonderful The bread and butter is always good Sides are all better then the next! Love the Mottz and onion rings
The service is great here, the food is also very well.
I love the shrimp cocktail. It's a huge piece of shrimp for a good price.
Not our best Valentines Day dinner
My husband arranged a surprise trip to AC for Valentines Day which started with dinner at the Old Homestead. The food and service were beyond great but… we were seated at the absolute worst table in the place. To my right and within my reach was the area where dirty dishes were placed for later pick-up. Also, the flatware drawer was right next to me and the traffic in and out of the area made for much distraction resulting in a terrible experience.
Located in the Borgata Casino ; where you can conveniently
Located in the Borgata Casino ; where you can conveniently self or valet park. A very large beautiful restaurant immaculately kept with wonderful menu. If you are looking for place to celebrate or have business meeting make this your place . Their signature rib steak was delicious perfectly prepared, caviar was set out and paired wonderfully with their fresh shucked oysters. Everything we tried was amazing and the staff was always willing to share an opinion when asked . The food ambiance and staff made it an enjoyable evening full of conversation and laughter. My gratitude and thanks.
Absolutely incredible steak.
Even better service. Thank you for such a great dinner experience
I have eaten here quite a few times.
Usually very good. Had dinner there last night, sat pretty much right away, took about 10 minutes for someone to come over to the table. Waiter introduced himself, and helper. Took drink order, about 10 minutes later we got our drinks. Had to stop him and ask if we could order appetizers. Ordered shrimp and clams casino. Shrimp was very good. Clams casino was DISGUSTING!!!! raw, only ate the breading. Nobody even asked if they were ok?? Poor service!!! Was going to get the calamari. Lady next to us had some, we asked her how it was, she said don't get it, it's like chewing on rubber bands!!! Dinner was good, salmon, potatoes and spinach. New couple came in next to us and SAME WAITER WE HAD, came over and told them all about the SPECIALS!!! He never said a word to us about any specials!! No one ever asked if everything was ok!!! Service was HORRIBLE!! Food was ok, definitely NOT how it used to be!! Bill was about $210 for both of us. Normally I would leave between $75 and $100 for a tip , the guy last Night got less than $40. And he wasn't worth that!!! Go to the Italian restaurant in the borgota!! Don't waste your $$ here!!! Will never go back to this restaurant!! There are plenty more at the borgota, that are much better! With better service!!
My boyfriend and I came down for the night to see a show at
My boyfriend and I came down for the night to see a show at Caesars and were spending the night at Borgata. My boyfriend has eaten at the Old Homestead in manhattan before, loved it so I made reservations for dinner here. Our waiter, Michael was fantastic. He made great suggestions on meal choice and also cocktails. We had an early reservation and were seated upstairs. The decor was very nice, atmosphere great and ambiance of the room and table setting was top notch. I did feel bad for the waiters as they had to keep going up and down the stairs for food and drinks. Now onto the menu. We started out with a choice of rolls (onion or cranberry nut roll) then into the apps. We chose the slab of bacon (2 slices) and it was excellent! Then we went onto the main meal. I ordered the 9oz filet mignon which came on top of a thick hash brown. Both were excellent. My boyfriend had the 16oz filet mignon and we got a side of lobster Mac and cheese. Everything was cooked to perfection and food was impeccable. A definite must.
Awesome service (sat at bar).
Veal Chop and Rack of Lamb outstanding - just perfect. Oysters eh at best; not really shelled well. Pieces of shell and ya had to dig at the meat to get it. Just what you would and should expect from Old Homestead. Like.
Old Homestead : Food and service was excellent
Food and service was excellent. Made reservation online which was very simple and efficient. Dinner was well worth the $$. Thursday in Jan still had a decent crowd.
Paul,you and your team are amazing!! thanks for a great
Paul,you and your team are amazing!! thanks for a great service! From Hudson Toyota team!
I REALLY miss Bobby Flays!
We have always had a good experience in the past coming to Old Homestead. Our last visit was a little disappointing as we had reservations well in advanced but had to wait over 30 minutes to be seated. Then we were seated in the hallway right next to the bar? It was obvious that there seats were added and left little room for anyone walking down the aisle. Service was fine and the food was OK... Going to try the new B Prime or one of the other AC Steak houses to find a new favorite!
Dinner before Sienfield
This old reliable restaurant did not disappoint. The special veal chop was cooked to perfection. The broccoli rabe was excellent. Our servers Micheal and Gladys were wonderful. They made our experience so much better. It was a fabulous way to celebrate
Awful experience
Awful experience my wife and I both got food poisoning and it is impossible to speak with anyone at the restaurant. Very disappointing
Not Good
Recently dined at Old Homestead for business and it was disappointing , especially since I have dined there before and always enjoyed it . The service was good and the drinks were good , the food was not , our porterhouse was overcooked and bland , the mashed potatoes didn't taste much better than boxed potatoes and the asparagus with hollandaise was nasty . For the price you pay , the kitchen needs to do a better job of making sure the food they send out is much better ... will not return .
Traditional Steakhouse Delivering What You Expect
The food was excellent and initially, our service was great. But after the food came, it was hard to get service or the attention we needed. For example, we asked for a sauce that never came. Also, their salads are massive and serve two people; we recommend you be aware of this - which we weren't and over-ordered as we each got our own salad.
Horrible experience
I have been coming here for years and last night was a complete disappointment from the host (Brian P) to the serving staff to the filets. We arrived at 8:25 for r 8:30 reservation. Wasn’t seated until around 8:50. Once seated in the “hall way” type area just off bar we had to wait another 10 minutes just to get a menu. The charger plates on the table were full of finger prints (do they clean these or just keep putting them on a new table??). Then it was waiting again just to order. Once the server came we ordered everything- drinks apps main course n sides because talking to the people on either side they said it is taking forever. They all left with not even ordering dessert because they were afraid how long it would take to get them. They also had to chase down Rene just get their bill. They were not happy. We finally received r food. Given Brussels sprouts when we never ordered them. Had to send back to get the mashed potatoes. 2 of us had filets that were mealy. It came with these has brown which were cold. The other person had a New York strip which he was happy w. The fries, calamari were very good. The mash potatoes had no flavor. I ate one small piece of the filet n one small piece of the hash browns n left the rest. Never once did the waiter or anyone come around to ask how the meal was. When asked for boxes n I didn’t want one for the basically non eaten filet no questions as to why. We got done r dinner around 10:30. No dessert for us either as no time left. In addition to what was mentioned we had 2 drinks n a glass of wine. That’s it. $311!!! For horrible service, lack of caring on anyone’s part and not great food. I felt horrible for my guests as we had been there 2 years ago n had a great time. Thank god I had comps to pay for it as if I had to this $300 I would have been really pissed off. Won’t b back there for a long time if ever. Save your money n go to the American grill. They seem to b the better place now.
Nice dinner.
Dinned here after a show couple of Sunday’s ago. I had the chicken parm and have to say that this could be the best chicken parmigiana in AC and I have tried many at different restaurants. The chicken cooked very nicely, juicy and good flavor and a nice portion. The side of linguini that accompanies the entree is almost like an entree itself. My gf had the sea bass and really enjoyed!! The shrimp scampi was also juicy and flavorful. Being s little pricy but that comes with casino restaurants so it was expected. Love the new bar area they have renovated. Highly recommend and I will be back when in AC!!
Atlantic City's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City
AppointmentTrader FAQ
Questions and Answers around the platform.
47,935 People following
893 Questions
585 Answers |
Ask a question about AT |
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits? |
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment |
I was waiting on the transfer for name but it hasn’t happened yet and my reservation is tonight , will it be an issue that is hasn’t changed into my name yet
Give the best answer
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ |
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee |
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil |
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it? |
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid? |
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted. |
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from? |
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered? |
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
I can’t find my purchase but my credit card has been charged - any ideas?
I can’t find my purchase but my credit card has been charged - any ideas ?
Give the best answerCan You Take Down a Listing
Can you take down a listing if it doesn't sell to avoid a late cancellation fee?
Give the best answerRestaurants canceling reservations
Will restaurants cancel reservations if they know you are using a bot or can you get banned on resy?
Give the best answerTransfer
How quick are transfers completed? I requested my transfer 2 days ago and my reservation is tonight. What if it’s not done in time?
Give the best answerVirtual Name & Email on reservation
Hi Community,
I am new to this site and just recently bought a reservation here. I noticed that on the reservation page, it is booked under a random name and a virtual email address.
I can't find any button to change either the name or the email for this reservation I bought. So, should I just say that random name when I arrived at the restaurant? Not really sure about the procedures.
Best
Can you book private clubs ?
I put a bid in for 5 Hertford street but wasnt sure if they work w Appointmemt trader...anyone know? thanks
Give the best answerHow do payouts work?
Once a reservation is bid on or taken - how is one paid out?
Give the best answerWhat does bid active time window mean
Is this what reservation times looking for ? Or when my bid can get filled?
Give the best answerDo any restaurants require ID for a reservation?
Do restaurants require ID for a reservation? What happens if someone purchases a reservation and can’t get seated ?
Give the best answerBidding on reservations?
This is my second go around bidding on a reservation and it looks like it won’t be much of a success again. Has anyone on here ever bid on a reservation and successfully got it? It seems to me like the reservations I bid on don’t even exist
Give the best answerCanceling name change request?
How do I cancel a name change request
before a call has been made to restaurant?
Is there a way to see sold listings?
Looking to see which listings have sold
Give the best answerIf an establishment cancels..
If an establishment cancels a reservation for whatever reason, will the seller get penalized? If so, how?
Give the best answerTransfer request no response yet
I bought a reservation and posted a transfer request to my name this past Sunday and have had no one confirm for me as I also have a special request also. The reservation is soon and I am concerned
Give the best answer10%+ Refund Rate Medal Removal Question
Hi Teams,
I got the 10%+ Refund Rate Medal since RESY terminated my account last month.
Now my refund rate has returned to 10% which is lower than the 11% threshold.
But I can still see the 10%+ Refund Rate Medal in my profolio and my payout is still
be limited, When can I get rid of this metal?
Thank you so much for your help!
Best,
Do bids include deposits?
Do bids I would create include the $50 pp fee for restaurants like carbone torrisi etc?
Give the best answerPostpaid?
What does this mean?
Give the best answerWHERE ARE MY PAYOUTS?
My payouts keep being returned (four until now, I was never able to get a dime out) against your T&C. Customer service said payouts would be prioritized and they keep being returned! Please solve asap!!!! No one replies to messages!
Give the best answerWhere are my payouts?
My payouts keep being returned (four until now, I was never able to get a dime out) against your T&C. Customer service said payouts would be prioritized and they keep being returned! Please solve asap!!!! No one replies to messages!
Give the best answerWhere are my payouts?
My payouts keep being returned (four until now, I was never able to get a dime out) against your T&C. Customer service said payouts would be prioritized and they keep being returned! Please solve asap!!!!
Give the best answerTransfer
How do I change a purchase reservation to my name??
Give the best answerDelete account ?
How do I delete my account
Give the best answerWhy do they need such personal information.
Why do we have to give such personal information to get a refund from my trades? This makes me nervous.
Give the best answerWhy is this place such a scam?
Multiple times have been given false reservations and no way to get money back
Give the best answerDeposits credited to final bill
I have a reservation that includes $50 per person deposit that they add onto the end of the bill. How will I get that back?
Give the best answer