Old John's Luncheonette New York - Buy Reservations

148 W 67th St, New York, NY 10023, USA

More on Old John's Luncheonette New York

Claim Old John's Luncheonette New York Ownership Update Old John's Luncheonette New York Opening Times

Hide Old John's Luncheonette New York Detail Data

Any reservation for a time that starts

😎

Getting a reservation at Old John's Luncheonette New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!

Buy a verified reservation from someone who doens't need theirs anymore.

What if nothing fits my schedule?

If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.

We only list verified Reservations! All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.

Read Less

Old John's Luncheonette New York Reviews from The Last 180 Days

Tripadvisor: 😍 (2) Yelp: 😒 (14)

😍

Old-fashioned delight

5/5 by NewYorker10458 on 04/01/2022

Having been to Old John's frequently for over ten years, on my return to the city after a five year absence, I was delighted to find the quality of this ordinary-seeming luncheonette up to my memories. While the menu is mostly comfort food, it is all well done. For example, the orange juice for breakfast is really fresh-squeezed. If one is looking for a reasonably priced meal in a "sit down" restaurant near Lincoln Center, one could not do better.

🙂

Update: Gluten free options EXTREMELY Limited.

4/5 by Claire T. on 03/30/2022

I really love this place, they are wonderful place to sit at the bar w a drink, but since been diagnosed with celiacs my options are now an omelette & fries or treating myself to a full $30 entree, when I normally just come for bar food. They do let me bring my own gluten free bread for things, which I appreciate, but I wish they carried options themselves, as it's hard to carry gluten-free bread in my purse on the off chance I need a drink and snack after work. Hopefully this changes!!

😍

I found this old fashioned little diner at West 67th Street

5/5 by Terrence D. on 03/29/2022

I found this old fashioned little diner at West 67th Street close to Lincoln Center. It is quite a gem amongst all the far more pricey Broadway fare. This place has a decent breakfast menu, so you can get a good hot breakfast, like maybe just before catching a show nearby or at the Met Opera, so I stopped in with some friends when we all had the urge for some fluffy pancakes and bacon/eggs and fresh squeezed OJ! The juice was great. We split some potatoes and shared the pancakes. My favorite kind are usually blueberry pancakes but my girlfriend and her sister did not want sweet stickiness on their teeth all day, so we got plain. Wait staff was very friendly as we split many plates and mixed & matched our orders a bit. We could stay and chat as long as we wanted; no rush to get us out of there. I'm thinking I'll come by for lunch sometime. The food was good/fresh and it filled us up.

😍

Good food at easy prices.

5/5 by Christine F. on 03/22/2022

Tip them well! Staff deserves your gratitude. Accommodated 5 of us easily. Efficient and friendly. Old diner decor made us smile (maybe because we are senior diners)

🤢

Went here for date night.

2/5 by Urie D. on 03/19/2022

Me and my partner chose the outdoor seating, because the outdoor seating setup was so cute and well done. I enjoyed the privacy of it quite a bit, and it made the experience so much better. The menu is short enough that you can actually read all of it, and the page design was really good. A very good looking menu. The prices weren't ideal, but for a good meal on the Upper West Side, we were expecting it would be on the more expensive side....If it had been a good meal. We ended up sharing the fish and chips and... meh, incredibly meh. The fries were good, I suppose, but the fried fish was very underwhelming. It was flavorless, weirdly damp inside, and greasy-but-not-in-the-good-way. I would not order again. If we had ordered two things, maybe there'd be a higher chance one of them was good, but since we split the fish and chips is was just very underwhelming.I was expecting a more elevated diner location. I feel like Old John's was more of a typical diner with elevated prices.

🙂

Would have done 4.

4/5 by Lou H. on 03/16/2022

5 stars, but the interface won't allow it.I've lived on the UWS for a long time, but never tried Old John's until last night. Pros: the Braised Short Rib was tasty and tender (although I really couldn't find the promised "crispy shallots"), with real mashed potatoes and a lovely sauce. The staff were pleasant and attentive and the restroom was clean - a big deal for NY. Cons: Not many. Got green beans instead of broccolini, but the portion was tiny, and, of course, the absent shallots. :)I'll be back.

😍

Went here today for breakfast, and as it's literally right

5/5 by James M. on 03/06/2022

Went here today for breakfast, and as it's literally right around the corner, it'll probably be my regular sit down breakfast spot. I had a latte and an omelet with spinach, caramelized onion, Gruyère, and added some well cooked bacon into the mix. That junk was good. Egg portion was plain and then the ingredients were wrapped inside of it. I'm getting used to it--maybe the mixing in of ingredients with the egg is a midwestern thing. Really liked the vibe of this place. It seems to have been recently remodeled. But still has a very nice classic look to it. Looked like it also had a full bar. And they serve egg creams. But the main thing to me was the omelette, which was killer. Also the music selection. Whoever is in charge of the music, at least today, was on point. Some of the reviews almost scared me off of this spot. I was pleasantly surprised.

🤮

Currently writing this review while waiting for my food,

1/5 by Sarah A. on 02/13/2022

Currently writing this review while waiting for my food, the service is terrible. I came here with 7 other friends, 8 in total. We split our table in two and four of us, including myself, we're seated in the front. But for some reason, the other table of my friends (who are all white/white passing) get better service and are allowed to order right away. They get served while at my table (all people of color) are still waiting to order. We ask kindly to order and a waitress answers in the most rude tone, especially considering we are all clearly teenagers. Business is business. There is no need to be rude to nice customers. We've been here for an hour, still haven't been served. Never coming back. Wish yelp would allow me to put 0 stars.

🤮

A disappointment.

1/5 by Kathleen G. on 02/09/2022

Hadn't been since the renovations. We were party of 4 for early dinner on Saturday. Were seated right away. Great! All downhill from there. Service was atrocious. Slow but also rude. As for food, it was half and half. Sandwiches were fine. French fries were cold. Burger was meh. Pancakes (child's order) were a bust. Luke warm at best and really had no taste. Should have stuck with Westside Restaurant on 69th. Always a sure thing.

🙂

A great local place if you're cruising the west side.

4/5 by Charles B. on 02/05/2022

Great burgers fantastic salads amazing service. A great NYC experience. Make sure you order dessert

🤮

It's bad food, overpriced, skimpy unbalanced portions.

1/5 by Georgia P. on 01/15/2022

Drinks and food are just not good.

😍

Recently renovated diner with a well stocked bar and great

5/5 by JP R. on 01/13/2022

Recently renovated diner with a well stocked bar and great service. It has a balanced menu of classics and contemporary dishes (including vegetarian options) at fair prices. Service was excellent.

😍

Friendly authentic NYC diner

5/5 by Davida A on 12/31/2021

From the weak coffee to the French toast and scrambled eggs, this is a classic NYC diner. Very friendly waitstaff and the food was ready in minutes.

😒

I really want to love this place.

3/5 by Ben G. on 12/27/2021

It's a cute neighborhood spot with the nicest people. It feels like an old school diner and has resurrected an old neighborhood favorite, but each time I've gone, the food has left something to be desired. From burgers that were undercooked and had soggy buns and crispless fries to apple pie with completely dry crust. Every once in a while, you'll get something solid, like the pictured blueberry pie that I definitely enjoyed. But overall, for the price, my experience just hasn't been worth it thus far. I'm sure I'll be back for another try, because it's still early on in their existence. I'm rooting for this place and hoping they do well!

🤢

Decent environment but unfortunately the omelette

2/5 by Jules S. on 12/08/2021

Decent environment but unfortunately the omelette potatoes,toast and hash browns lacked flavor. The food was very mediocre for $20. I wouldn't recommend this place

🤮

Please do yourself a favor and skip this restaurant.

1/5 by Melissa H. on 11/18/2021

The sweet potato mash was gritty and flavorless, worse than baby food. The pot pie lacked any speck of seasoning and had waaaaayyy too many shallots. It was honestly irredeemable. And my spouses salad dressing had an underlying bitterness. We've lived in NY for awhile and rarely had a bad meal. This, unfortunately, was the first.

Other Popular Restaurants near New York

4 Charles Prime Rib New York

Dhamaka New York

Don Angie New York

The Polo Bar New York

Best Posts

Discussions

Reviews

Love!!!

😍 5/5 Review by FunctionalFact14 (03/29/2022 9:12 pm)

First time using the app and I was a little hesitant. Great experience from start to finish. They answered all the questions I had almost immediately. Will definitely use again and recommend it to all my friends

1 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Appointment Trader

😍 5/5 Review by AcceptableParcel20 (03/24/2022 9:35 am)

Wow! First time using this website/app. It was almost hard to believe the quality of customer service I received as soon as I posted my offer. A private chat forum with me and the person helping me find the best option. Constant communication and a wonderful experience using Appointment Trader. I'm surprised it took me this long to find AT but this will now be my GO TO for hard to get restaurant reservations. It was like having my own private concierge.

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Great customer service

😍 5/5 Review by CohesiveBody50 (02/17/2022 6:13 am)

Was able to get a last-minute reservation for Valentine's Day with AT. The customer service team was incredibly responsive and helpful throughout the process!

3 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Just great !

😍 5/5 Review by SeemlyLook49 (02/16/2022 1:51 pm)

It was transferred fast and it worked !

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (02/21/2022 8:26 am)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Last minute Pujol rezo in Mexico City

😍 5/5 Review by DistinctFront80 (02/16/2022 5:41 pm)

Last minute trip to Mexico City for Art Week. Busiest weekend in CDMX and AT came through and got us into Pujol. On Friday night … for four people! Amazing. I couldn’t believe it. Highly recommend this app.

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Seamless!😍 Appointmenttrader rocks!

😍 5/5 Review by BangingSmoke22 (02/22/2022 1:05 pm)

Appointmenttrader Rocks!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (03/12/2022 9:34 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Miami Beach Hot Spot Success!

😍 5/5 Review by CosmicLinen30 (02/24/2022 11:59 am)

My first experience using AT was awesome and the AT support saved the day! When my booking transfer initiated two days earlier but didn't complete by the day of the reservation, AT was able to expedite the transfer and confirm a table at Call Me Gaby in Miami Beach. Boss confirmed an excellent experience when he arrived and no issues to report. Thanks, AT! I will definitely be back and thank you very much for your prompt assistance!

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Made our trip to NYC

😍 5/5 Review by CloseFiction30 (11/10/2021 8:40 am)

There was one restaurant we really wanted to visit in NYC and AppointmentTrader made that possible. Then when we had issues with the reservation transfer they were so quick to respond and fix the problem. We’ll definitely be using this again in the future.

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (11/10/2021 9:26 am)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

love this APP

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (11/02/2021 5:50 pm)

Just this week I scored two “hard to get” reservations! Friday at Delilah and tonight at Cafe Elote in Sedona! I am impressed!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (11/02/2021 6:07 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 1 comment

Transfer was easy and fast!

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (11/03/2021 6:43 pm)

Got a reservation transfer fast and easy to our favorite (and everyone else’s favorite 😉) Mexican Restaurant in Sedona!

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (11/03/2021 9:12 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Amazing!

😍 5/5 Review by GlitteringSwim77 (10/22/2021 8:01 pm)

This app is incredible!! I got a last minute rsvp for 7 people at Delilah’s on a busy Friday night…a mission we thought was impossible. I will always rely on this app when open table fails me!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (10/22/2021 8:40 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Lunch at GIRAFE

😍 5/5 Review by GlossyLevel60 (10/04/2021 5:37 am)

We had a great lunch spot at GIRAFE in Paris. And got a very very good and friendly support from the team of this great App. We definitely will book a table again here.

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (10/04/2021 11:04 am)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Hottest michelin star restaurant in DC

😍 5/5 Review by AstoundingRay77 (09/27/2021 12:06 pm)

I highly recommend this service. Reservations sell out in minutes as they become available at this restaurant. I was able to get a table at the exact time we wanted, on a peak weekend night. Amazing!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (09/27/2021 12:12 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

AT extremely useful and lightning fast

😍 5/5 Review by ArdentGrass37 (09/17/2021 10:21 am)

Fast and painless process. Amazing experience

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (10/12/2021 9:15 am)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Amazing Experience

😍 5/5 Review by ArdentGrass37 (09/15/2021 8:35 am)

Got a reservation that not even the concierge for some Roman-like black card was able to. Excellent app!

Last Reply by CunningChange19 (09/15/2021 11:22 am)

4 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Perfect experience from start to finish

😍 5/5 Review by GainfulAdvertisement61 (08/29/2021 11:21 am)

The AT team and user experience is second to none. The team is attentive, proactive and responsive. Very satisfied with everything.

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (08/29/2021 2:50 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

What a brilliant app! Landed an impossible to get table at Delilah!

😍 5/5 Review by ConfirmableRoof27 (08/24/2021 12:32 pm)

I just stumbled upon this site and within 24 hours of posting a bid for an impossible to get table at Delilah (on a holiday weekend no less), my reservation was confirmed! So easy to use and it worked flawlessly. Brilliant!

Last Reply by EvocativeFold67 (09/17/2021 3:42 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 3 comments

Amazing

😍 5/5 Review by AppreciativeSociety68 (07/16/2021 9:11 am)

Got our reservation at TAO on the busiest night of the week in 10 minutes. Amazing app!!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (07/18/2021 9:23 am)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Whose name will my reservation be under when I arrive at the venue?

Question by FluffyStar64 (07/09/2021 5:10 pm)

Best Answer It can be under your name or a name you choose! Some reservation offers already include the AppointmentTrader Transfer Service which will transfer the reservation in to your name. If its not included you can add it on after buying the reservation for a small fee. One thing on that though: As many reservations become available at last minute, taking a reservation in someone else name is quick and great for privacy. Most reservations on AT are listed with a virtual phone number, so all you need to do is present the phone number at the hostess stand and you are good to go!

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (07/09/2021 5:17 pm)

1 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 0 comments

Working on your bid?

Question by DemurePain59 (10/01/2021 1:24 pm)

Best Answer Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.

Best answer by EvocativeFold67 (10/02/2021 4:37 pm)

1 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 0 comments

Process after bid is accepted.

Question by EvocativeFold67 (09/17/2021 8:11 pm)

Best Answer Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (09/17/2021 10:07 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 2 comments

Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?

Question by ColorfulRod45 (07/13/2021 3:55 pm)

Best Answer Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.

Best answer by FluffyStar64 (07/13/2021 6:05 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 1 comment

What happens if my bid expires unanswered?

Question by FluffyStar64 (07/08/2021 5:55 pm)

Best Answer Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (07/08/2021 6:28 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 2 comments

Ask a Question

Old John's Luncheonette New York User Reviews & Question Forums

Old John's Luncheonette New York Yelp Reviews

Latest Reviews On Yelp

😒3.0/5 from 13 reviews

Last review : Good food at easy prices.
By Christine F. (03/22/2022 12:00 am)

See all reviews

Old John's Luncheonette New York Tripadvisor Reviews

Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor

🙂4.3/5 from 9 reviews

Last review : Friendly authentic NYC diner
By Davida A (12/31/2021 12:00 am)

See all reviews

AppointmentTrader Platform Reviews

Reviews from real people using AT!

😍5.0/5 from 22 reviews

Last review : Love!!!
By FunctionalFact14 (03/29/2022 9:12 pm)

See all reviews

Create a Question in "Old John's Luncheonette New York FAQ"

You will earn 25 Traderpoints for your Question.

Question Title

Question Context

Ask a question Cancel

Create a Post in "Must try dishes at Old John's Luncheonette New York"

Post Title

Post Context

Share your favorite dish Cancel

Create a Post in "Best Tables in Old John's Luncheonette New York"

Post Title

Post Context

Share your favorite table Cancel

Create a Post in "Staff to Know at Old John's Luncheonette New York"

Post Title

Post Context

Comment (nicely) on a staff member! Cancel

Restaurant Transfers FAQ

Questions around how AppointmentTrader works for Restaurant Reservations

4 questions

Last question answer: RE: About the deposit
By FluffyStar64 (10/04/2021 11:22 am)

See all questions

AppointmentTrader FAQ

Questions and Answers around the platform.

48 questions

Last question : Can I request my table to be inside?
By BouncyThroat14 (03/30/2022 10:50 am)

See all questions