Periyali New York Yelp Reviews - Periyali New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Periyali New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Periyali New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Periyali New York
Periyali New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
23 Reviews
0 Replys |
Excellent food, service and ambience.
Octopus was excellent and the lamb chops sublime.
Be the first to Replyafter hearing about this restaurant my friend and i decided
after hearing about this restaurant my friend and i decided to go for lunch the other day and i have to say if there was a place to leave 6 stars i would add one. the food is super fresh and so well prepared and was one of the better restaurants we both had gone to. just amazing delicious food. besides the food we were also so impressed with the customer service we got from the wait staff. Mack and his 2 man team were on top of everything. you never had to look for them as they never missed a beat with serving you with top notch service. we were both so impressed and felt like vip's eating there. super friendly and now i know why this place has been in business for i believe over 30 years! i can't say enough about this SIX star restaurant and highly recommend it to anyone, we both look forward to going back there soon.
Be the first to ReplyVery nice small authentic Greek bistro, great quality and
Very nice small authentic Greek bistro, great quality and reasonable prices. Friendly, low key service. Would definitely return.
Be the first to ReplyThe fired octopus was a big hit and the lamb chops were
The fired octopus was a big hit and the lamb chops were outstanding. The salmon was sensational. Went there for a Birthday celebration and the service was great! Staff was professional and attentive.
Be the first to ReplyPeriyali has been our "go to" Greek restaurant for the last
Periyali has been our "go to" Greek restaurant for the last 30 years. Last night we had an assortment of appetizers including giant beans and a hummes type dish. I had lamb chops. No surprise here as it's what we always do. Service was excellent. Think of it this way, we take a $20 taxi ride each way from east 60th street to get here.
Be the first to ReplyI attended a work dinner for 7 people on a Wednesday night
I attended a work dinner for 7 people on a Wednesday night at Periyali. The restaurant was dimly lit and very quite when we arrived. There were a handful of diners already eating (we had a 6:30 reservation), but the restaurant quickly filled during the course of our time there. We were seated promptly and given the option of bottled vs. tap water. The decor was simplistic but elegant and really gave me Mediterranean vibes. Our waitress was very attentive throughout the meal and came to our table on the perfect cadence. 3 of our party ordered the snapper (one of the nightly specials), but after 5 minutes, the waitress came back and informed us that there were only 2 snappers left. I found it odd that we were there well before the nightly rush but that we took the last two snapper "specials". Others in our party ordered salmon and bronzino dishes while myself and one other person ordered the Mousakas. Most appetizers were priced $10-$20 and most main dishes were priced at $30-$50. We also ordered a few cocktails and a couple of glasses of Greek wine.I really enjoyed the Mousakas, and the ground lamb in it was so tasty. My only gripe was that it came out a bit lukewarm (almost like it had been sitting on the counter waiting for the fish dishes to be ready). Everyone who ordered a fish dish seemed to enjoy it.Periyali has excellent service in an awesome setting, and it truly has an authentic Greek feel. However, my dish left a little to be desired, particularly for the price. I would consider giving this restaurant another shot and maybe trying one of the fish or beef entrees.
Be the first to ReplyCame for lunch and had a good experience.
A friend and I shared:+ taramasalata+ tzatziki+ melitzanosalata+ Oktapodi sharas+ Horiatiki salata+ SpanakopitaThe taramasalata was amazing, but the other dishes were nothing special. There's much better greek food in this city but this is a solid option for the area (I'll admit Flatiron is kind of a desert when it comes to Greek food). 3.5 stars.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing service.
Felt so welcome, octopus was delicious as was the branzino. Greek wine was also lovely. Will come again!
Be the first to ReplyI've been coming here for years and it has never, not once,
I've been coming here for years and it has never, not once, disappointed. I would go as far to say that it is the best Greek food fine dining experience in New York. The salmon is my favorite thing on the menu, but everything is superb. I'm literally sitting in the restaurant right now and so happy that I'm here.
Be the first to ReplyI went for a dinner to Periyali and had an amazing time.
The service is very attentive and we had their signature grilled octopus( highly recommend) and moussaka.
Be the first to ReplyWe had dinner at the restaurant during the restaurant week.
we ordered from the restaurant week menu. the portions were small. the food was mediocre, but the prices were very high. service was great. the place is nice. i willnever go back there.
Be the first to ReplyWow!!!! What an amazing chance experience during Restaurant
Wow!!!! What an amazing chance experience during Restaurant Week. If I lived next to Periyali I'd never state how stunningly amazing it was as I'd love to keep it all to myself. It's beautifully and delicately appointed down to the fragrant fresh roses arranged in every nook. Our server, Denise, was in training and yet extremely knowledgeable and excited about the menu options. The menu was simple and classic, but their interpretations of the classics were extraordinary beyond their descriptions. Generous portions of decadent deliciousness we are now trying to figure out how we can make it back for more. A++
Be the first to ReplyFood was good.
My friends and I were enjoying ourselves until we got rudely told to leave. This man threatened us after paying $500+ at his establishment. I'm horrified I spent hard earned money here. What a waste.
Be the first to ReplyMy friends and I went for restaurant week.
The service wasn't great and the restaurant week deal wasn't a deal. The portion sizes for food were smaller than regular and the food wasn't as flavorful. We had a problem with the bill and resolving it was an ordeal. I wouldn't go back again or recommend it.
Be the first to ReplyPeriyali is one the best restaurants for authentic Greek
Periyali is one the best restaurants for authentic Greek cuisine in New York City! They make delicious lavraki fish and their side dishes are also excellent. We have dined here on multiple occasions and the food was always great. They recently started having a $35 3 course dinner menu for Friday night which is a great value! The only con is that the environment is a bit dull / boring. Food is excellent but the ambience could be improved.
Be the first to ReplyHappened to walk by this place tonight and looked cute and
Happened to walk by this place tonight and looked cute and quaint so we stopped in. Ordered drinks and a bunch of appetizers. It was DELICIOUS!! Our server was a sweet girl named Eleni. She was attentive, knowledgeable and very friendly. The food was outstanding but it was her service that would make us come back! Spot on Greek food. Be sure to check it out if you're in the area. The octopus is a must have!!!
Be the first to ReplyPeriyali is an all-time classic NYC spot.
They were the first Greek fine dining restaurant in all of Manhattan when they opened in 1987 and they have done a phenomenal job of preserving the quaint, old-fashioned feel.My boyfriend and I went for dinner and it was so romantic. They had fresh flowers on every table, perfectly polite servers, and the food was incredible. Our waiter was Mack, who has been there since they first opened!! He was very kind and full of wisdom. We ordered the Saganaki to start and decided it's literally a fancy mozzarella stick... but better. If you're a mozz stick fam, 10/10 would recommend!! So delicious. We also got the beets, which we loved. For our mains, we shared the classic octopus (yes, it was the best I've ever had) and the lamb chops, which you certainly cannot go wrong with. I am obsessed with both their baklava and their walnut cake. The walnut cake is soo moist and just overall perfect. We also had "Mastika" - a greek dessert wine to cap off the night and we both loved it! Similar to Sambuca if you're into that. I'm already looking forward to my next visit to Periyali!
Be the first to ReplyHad dinner there this past Friday nite and the experience
Had dinner there this past Friday nite and the experience was first-rate from the second we walked in. Service and especially the waiter's attentive service was superb. My kids recommended that we start with the octopus and bean dip and both apps were crazy good. Actually ordered a 2nd octupus it was that good. Main course was branzino and lamb chops and again, superbly cooked. Our friends main courses were equally delicious. I never write reviews at all but my friend mentioned that usually only people that are not happy write reviews. Well this customer was extremely happy and I will recommend this restaurant to anyone that enjoys good greek style food with great service.
Be the first to ReplyDisappointing.
Periyali was a favorite prior to Covid and I've gone many times. However, during Covid and post-vaccine I do not eat indoors so we sat outside -- an unpleasant experience due to the heat lamps and attitude of management.The heat lamps were pointed into the face/body of my two seatmates making it feel like they were sunbathing. There were 3 heat lamps -- but the one in middle was directly on our table. The lamps should be overhead or the restaurant needs a way to have 2 of the 3 lamps on.The manager did not appear upset that we were really upset and made no attempt to make the situation better, or acknowledge our issue(s). Maybe an ice tea or dessert on the house? Or an apology? There are many great greek spots in NYC and sadly, I will not go to Periyali next time.
Be the first to ReplySuch a wonderful place to go for fresh tasting
Such a wonderful place to go for fresh tasting Mediterranean cuisine. Their wild catches are great, their octopus lives up to the hype, and I always have great experiences with the waitstaff.
Be the first to ReplyWe went to a special restaurant after a death in the family.
Periyali has been one of our favorites but not anymore. We had a 6 30 reservation and the restaurant was not yet crowded. The maitre d' took us through the restaurant to a small side room. I said "Siberia " ,he said "it's romantic". Soon a family of five who had just arrived in New York by air were seated next to us and we could not hear each other speak. The food was fine as always but we were so unhappy we asked for it to be packed up. The waiter was very pleasant but said nothing when I told her why we were leaving. I know I should have complained to the manager.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing food, service, and atmosphere.
Will definitely visit again when in town. The calamari and the mushroom appetizers were amazing. For entree I had the salmon in a pastry and was not disappointed. Desserts are delicious and fresh, especially with some of the best coffee I've ever had. Highly recommend you visit if you love fresh and flavorful food.
Be the first to ReplyRemains outstanding! Delicious dinner with friends.
Great wine selection and service. Appreciated not being rushed, yet our food was timed perfectly. The octopus was excellent for flavor and texture - a frequent go-to for us. The branzino was also perfectly done and presented. Great choice of side dishes. So glad we can visit in-person again! Thanks for a lovely, and delicious, evening !
Be the first to Reply