Pylos New York Yelp Reviews - Pylos New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Pylos New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Pylos New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Pylos New York
Pylos New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
23 Reviews
0 Replys |
Beautiful and cozy little place, the food was delicious and
Beautiful and cozy little place, the food was delicious and the service is impeccable. The place is not really big but the decor is done very interestingly with clay pots on the ceiling, which makes it interesting and lots and lots of Greek specialties to make your palate dance.
Be the first to ReplyFantastic authentic, high end Greek food.
The octopus is particularly good. And their white wines from Santorini are just divine.
Be the first to ReplyEverything tasted excellent, service was delightful.
Nice atmosphere, Highly recommended!
Be the first to ReplyAmazing salad! Fantastic lamb! Never have enough.
I enjoyed the atmosphere and great service. The waitress was so sweet and helpful... I enjoyed desert Greek wine and delicious Greek desert
Be the first to ReplyI had my birthday dinner here and it was everything I had
I had my birthday dinner here and it was everything I had hoped for and more. Starting now, the manager Dimitris was extremely accommodating when I emailed stating that I had a large party in October. He was able to accommodate us all and we received excellent service. I specifically chose this restaurant because of the photos I saw photos of the lamb shann here on yelp. The lamb shank won me over visually but when I got here, it blew my mind! The lamb shank was one of the best I've ever had in my entire life. The flavor, the texture, and the tenderness were stellar. The appetizers and dessert were wonderful. If you're looking for cocktails, they do not have them however, the wine and beer selection is beautiful. I highly recommend.
Be the first to ReplySolid food, lovely atmosphere, knowledgeable wait staff.
The wine list is wonderful. A little pricey for what it is but hey, it's NY. And the food never disappoints... except for the meatballs. Those weren't so great because there wasn't any sauce on them of any kind. But everything else we ordered was delicious. Especially the artichokes in bechamel sauce.
Be the first to ReplyThis place feels like a find.
It's unassuming on a side street on lower east side. But when you walk in it's transformed to Greece. They creatively display all of these clay pots in the ceiling. The service was also warm and friendly. Even after we long overstayed our welcome at the table, the owner offered to take care of us at the bar. Made us feel at home. Finally, the food is great. The fish was fresh. My only slight wish was that they offered wines besides just Green options.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing food, service and experience.
We were visiting NY for the first time and Pylos was highly recommended by friends that visit often. Will definitely be back!
Be the first to ReplyOnce again we ate here for a special occasion, and as every
Once again we ate here for a special occasion, and as every previous visit we left very happy.We went at 5:15 on a Wednesday evening and for the first time we so it pretty empty, it was great! Of course when we left at 7 it was full!First of all our waiter Alexander was such a nice guy, attentive, kind, cordial, efficient.The food was as always outstanding, from the delicious trio of Greek dips to the succulent lamb chops, the moussaka and a great braised pork shank.They recently redecorated the place, and perhaps this was also the reason why all prices went considerably up, as everything else in this world! It was the only not great surprise, but it was such a perfect dinner that we did not mind.Still one of my absolute favorite in NYC
Be the first to ReplyA 3 star "OK" review on Yelp isn't a bad review.
It just means that our experience wasn't quite what we were hoping for. The service was very good and though I prefer that my kalamarakia be only lightly breaded, what we tried was tasty. A couple comments:(1) It's my bad that I failed to confirm whether the restaurant served ouzo. Yeah, it's a silly thing, but I was hoping to sip on a nice, upscale ouzo while sampling mezes and chatting with my bride, maybe finishing the meal with some sort of obscure Greek brandy or other liqueur. The place does have an interesting wine list and a couple Greek beers, though when one has ouzo (or tsipouro or even a Turkish raki) on the mind, a glass of house red ain't gonna cut it.(2) On-line photos of the dining area indicated an interesting ceiling lined with terra cotta jugs. The jugs are definitely there, but below them are dark fine meshed "nets" that obscured the view and drastically muted the effect. It's almost as if the nets were installed as a safety measure in case one of the jug mounts failed. Weird.(3) The tables in the dining area as you enter are way too small. The meal service becomes a never-ending series of plate swapping and exercises in topological management in order to fit your food to the table surface. That gets old after a while. You'd probably be fine if you ordered a single appetizer and completely finished it off and had it removed before your salad, which you completely finished off and had it removed before the next course, etc. But if you are looking for a leisurely meal of mezes, it just wouldn't work without a lot of intervention and fussing about by the waiters.(4) The spacing between you and your neighbors is way too tight. I get it. NY is an expensive place to operate a restaurant and like airlines, packing folks in may be the only way to not go bankrupt. But we could listen to every word softly spoken by the people on either side of us and they could listen to us. It got claustrophobic after a while, and as a result we decided to leave early.I'd go back if the opportunity presented itself, but I'd now know what to expect and what not to expect. Nick in Palm Springs
Be the first to Replydecor on point.
their food took me to a flavor town that even the greek gods would come down for...and the service was bomb!!! the only constructive feedback i'd leave would be around giving me n the strangers next door to my table some more elbow room but as u can see that didn't subtract any stars se efcharisto!
Be the first to ReplyWow!!! What a pleasant surprise this restaurant
Wow!!! What a pleasant surprise this restaurant was!Fantastic red wine!Great service! Perfectly seasoned and sized lamb chops!!! Excellent Greek salad and perfect portions!!My only issue was was the tables were a lil too close for my comfort, but I'll certainly be back!
Be the first to ReplyVery quaint greek cuisine.
The octopus was to die for. The lighting is soft. This would be a great date night place. There was also a group next to us enjoying themselves. It was the queens 51st bday my wife. I would def recommend if you are un The NY
Be the first to ReplyThe food was insane, probably in top 3 dining experiences I
The food was insane, probably in top 3 dining experiences I had in NYC so you have to check it out if you like GreekAppetizers: - Octopus - again, this was recommended by Yelp reviewers: they know what they're talking about - 9.3/10- Three Dips - tzatziki, roe dip, eggplant - I'm not sure if it's bc I never had tzatziki at an established restaurant but it blew me away, also the roe dip was wild, both so creamy, left nothing - 9.6/10- Meatballs - very solid, soft and they were large balls -8.8/10- Lamb Chops - can't not get lamb, delicious and the eggplant side was $ - 9.2/10- Pistachio Crusted Stripe w filled w Sheep Cheese - this was the show stopper, I was mind blown, idk what my tastebuds did to deserve this but 10/10
Be the first to ReplyMade me wait outside while my table was ready for seating.
That is a failure of decency and accommodation.Food was fine. Good Greek food. Nothing exceptional. Waiting service was notably thoughtful and charismatic. Decent ambiance. Not in a rush to come back, but don't regret going either.
Be the first to ReplyPylos was a pleasant surprise! It is actually one of the
Pylos was a pleasant surprise! It is actually one of the best authentic upscale Greek restaurants in New York City but it is still under the radar. They have a very interesting selection of Greek dishes that you don't easily find in other restaurants in the city including pistachio in meat and fish dishes. Their lavraki was excellent and everyone in my party loved their food! We have come in multiple times and the quality of food and service are always memorable! Staff was very polite and the crowd was fun. Highly recommend this place!
Be the first to ReplyWow, what a find! We arrived at this restaurant at about
Wow, what a find! We arrived at this restaurant at about 9pm on a Monday night. The host informed us that the kitchen closed at 9:30pm but they would be more than happy to seat us. The restaurant was nearly empty. The ambience was fantastic. Beautiful interior with dim lights, perfect for a date night! Our server greeted us right away and explained the menu and offered suggestions. We ordered the appetizer trio dip, the green village salad, lemon potatoes, and the Branzino. The trio dip arrived quickly. The portion of dip/pita bread was enough to feed about 6 people. This was the one thing that we ordered that we thought was just okay. Pro tip: ask for sliced cucumbers to dip instead of bread if you are trying to save room for your entree! The Greek village salad was incredible. The contents were so fresh and the dressing was to die for! The Branzino arrived with a side of olive oil/lemon sauce for dipping. We found that we didn't even need to use this dipping sauce because the fish was delicious on its own. It was tender and cooked to perfection. The lemon potatoes are a must. They are flavorful yet still crispy. The service was 5 star. They repeatedly refilled our waters without having to ask. The server was diligent and polite. All in all, this place was a fabulous find and I would highly recommend it to anyone!
Be the first to ReplyThis was one of the nicest places I've been to in a while.
The food was great. The service perfection. Definitely will I'm go back. And when your Greek boss recommends it you listen!! And man am I glad I did. The pictures done explain how cute this place is.
Be the first to Replyservice greatdecor tables a bit tight togethermeatballs
service greatdecor tables a bit tight togethermeatballs very good probably the best I have had very light zucchini chips very nice thin and crispysoup very good lamb chops goodsteak good but expensive at 40 dollarssalmon would not order again. It was poached and rolled up on a heap of spinach riceanytime they have something rolled up usually it's not freshly made but heatedit was not a filet - did not finish the dish and it was 28 dollarsnot sure I will be back price may not justify what you getI think the appetizers were the bestremember don't get the salmon . the lady at the next table also ordered the salmon and did not finish it
Be the first to ReplyI don't think I've ever had Greek food like this- Wow,
I don't think I've ever had Greek food like this- Wow, everything was so delicious. Authentic in a high end, well presented way. The restaurant is classy and very warm. The service is stellar. The menu is a bit hard to navigate if you are unfamiliar with Greek food but it's hard to go wrong with your order. The Greek wine list was fun to explore. This is not the kind of food I would have all the time (there is a ton of cheese and fried dough and it was delightful but also heavy) but as far as unique experiences and delicious fun, this is a must try in the city.
Be the first to ReplyWow! This place is great.
Came here for dinner on a Friday evening and was very pleasantly surprised. Ambiance (5/5): Looks like you're entering a Mediterranean villa. Decor is all on point and quite spacious. Love the layout. Ceiling has a cool collection of what appears to be terracotta vases. Food (5/5): Food was excellent. Try the houloumi! Was really taken by how good this was. The grapes were a great accompaniment. We also ordered the fish which was nicely cooked though could've used some saltService (5/5): The waitstaff were all excellent and answered all questions. They were very knowledgeable about the menu and provided excellent suggestions. Overall, this place lives up to the hype. Had a great experience and will be back!
Be the first to ReplyUpscale Greek restaurant great for dates with a romantic
Upscale Greek restaurant great for dates with a romantic and classy ambience, extensive wine list, excellent service, and well-prepared and delicious dishes.I went to Pylos for a Saturday lunch with a friend and was sat down immediately with no reservation. The menu features lighter egg-based dishes for brunch on the weekends, but I opted for the shrimp appetizer (garides ouzo; high teens price range) and the braised lamb shank (low 30s price range) as my entree in addition to the free warmed pita bread that is given to every table. All of the food was really well presented and well prepared. I could not ask for more on the service - our server constantly checked in on us, had great knowledge of the wine list, switched out our plates regularly, and recommended an alternative lamb dish on the dinner menu during lunchtime when they were out of a different dish. The decor is as beautiful as their food - rustic, clean, charming and classy.If you want a more upscale restaurant with great Greek cuisine to show someone or a group of people a good time, Pylos is the way to go!
Be the first to ReplyWow what a world.
Our table of five split five appetizers and three lamb plates. Arthur was extremely helpful in picking out a wine that would compliment the meal perfectly. The food was amazing and flavorful and the service was spectacular. Even the busboy was super attentive and always topping off our waters. Much love and appreciation.
Be the first to Reply