San Matteo New York Yelp Reviews - San Matteo New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at San Matteo New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at San Matteo New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of San Matteo New York
San Matteo New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
31 Reviews
0 Replys |
Dinner! Food and drinks were great.
The pizza of the day was tasty and baked in their brick pizza oven. The calamari and fried shrimp were crispy and flavorful. We especially enjoyed the added spice of the crushed red pepper oil! The restaurant is fairly roomy with positive vibes from the staff. Minus 1 Star for the TV behind the bar. It needs to be replaced ASAP! Please, head to Best Buy down the street. A new 55" is only $3-400. Your bar patrons will stay longer !
Be the first to ReplyWe were a party of 10 - and I thought the pizza was solid.
Appetizers were all tasty especially the prosciutto and mozzarella. Atmosphere was nice upstairs. Drinks were strong and had a nice wine list. I think this place is nicer than a traditional pizza joint. Would come back with a large group.
Be the first to ReplyI ordered delivery from San Matteo again and pizzas arrived
I ordered delivery from San Matteo again and pizzas arrived quickly and in perfect condition. One pizza is perfect portion for one person. I tried the PROSCIUTTO & BUFALA (pizze rose or pizza with tomato sauce) and the CENTENARIO (pizze bianche or no tomato sauce). They was soft and elastic with great flavor. Ingredients were high quality. I would just say the Centenario had very little nduja salami. I loved both of them, probably one of the best pizzerias in the neighborhood. ESPAรOL: Pedรญ a pizza a domicilio de San Matteo de nuevo y llegaron rรกpidamente y en perfecto estado. Una pizza es la porciรณn ideal para una persona. Probรฉ la PROSCIUTTO & BUFALA (pizze rose o pizza con salsa de tomate) y la CENTENARIO (pizze bianche o sin salsa de tomate). La masa era ligera y elรกstica con un increรญble sabor. Los ingredientes de alta calidad. Tan solo dirรญa que la CENTENARIO tenรญa poco ndula salami. Me encantaron ambas, probablemente una de las mejores pizzerias del barrio.
Be the first to ReplyI love their hamburger! Also can't go wrong with their
I love their hamburger! Also can't go wrong with their Panuozzos. Staff is always so friendly. Great for dine-in or takeout. A UES go-to for me!
Be the first to ReplyThis place absolutely blew us away! The pizza was delicious
This place absolutely blew us away! The pizza was delicious and it was definitely one of the best I ever had. The tiramisu was super flavorful and again, one of the best I ever had. The gelato dessert was unique and super delicious! The service was amazing and the waiters went out of their way to make us feel comfortable. Overall a really good place especially if you are spending the day at the Met or nearby!
Be the first to ReplyI got unnecessarily fat shamed by the manager and all he
I got unnecessarily fat shamed by the manager and all he could say was "mi scuzzi" ....
Be the first to ReplyOrdered delivery from a few blocks away, which kept very
Ordered delivery from a few blocks away, which kept very well. RATING: 7/10 PRO TIP: The pizza is actually not bad. PIZZA DIAVOLO It's hard to stand out these days given the amazing neapolitan pizza scene in NYC, and you may not have seen San Mateo pop up on any lists, but this UES stable with a few locations actually did a solid job on authenticity and flavor. The diavolo was nicely spicy, and had a savory red sauce and importantly, the curst was fluffy, chewy, soft. MEATBALLS - not bad, nice and salty, and hearty. Good addition if you're used to having meat with your meal and you're getting a meatless pie especially. BRUSSEL SPROUTS - was surprised by this. Another classic Italian dish and it had these crispy pieces of panchetta over it and cheese which added this salty richness. Not bad. FINAL CATEGORY: GOOD/GREAT (terrible / bad / ok / GOOD / GREAT / excellent)
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza hands down Margarita well done!!!!! I don't eat
Best pizza hands down Margarita well done!!!!! I don't eat slices from regular pizza shops anymore I'm boujee bc of San Matteo
Be the first to ReplyFood - Yum! Loved the regina pizza since it was so saucy
Food - Yum! Loved the regina pizza since it was so saucy and flavorful. Cacio y pepe is my favorite pasta so this in pizza form was elite. Dessert never disappoints of course and had all this to chase down with some classic Chardonnay. Service - The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating. Ambiance - The place was a vibe. Definitely a great place to come to and watch a sports game or go on date night. Great for large groups too! A lot of space, but definitely make reservations.
Be the first to ReplyThis place has figured it out.
Pizza. Wine. Salads. Appetizers. All delicious. They were quick with the food, the check, even the seating. Literally the only reason I'm removing a star is cause there were so many people trying to get in that our table by the door had a chill. And the waiters kept telling people to close the door. All three of them. That's how much people want to get in to this place. And now I know why :)
Be the first to ReplyFabulous food and service! We found this in the NYC
Fabulous food and service! We found this in the NYC Michelin guide. Four of us ate dinner on a Monday evening. We had the eggplant which was great. We also had a Cetara pizza, Fusilli Alragu, a calzone and a Matteo Burger. The food was delicious, one of the best pizzas that I have tasted. Even the burger was great, juicy tender and delicious We are definitely going back
Be the first to ReplyLast night I decided I wanted to try a new pizza joint.
After 30 years of Mezzaluna I just thought that maybe I should try something different. I sat down at 7 pm and ordered 4 pizzas for me, my wife and two friends. The pizzas arrived at 8 o'clock!!!!! 1 hour wait for a pizza! Never happened. Sure enough, I ordered anchovies and capers and the waiter (someone who should not be in the hospitality business as he was nothing but rude and inept) brought me a pizza with capers and black olives! After 1 hour wait the moron brought me the wrong pizza. I told him that there was a mistake. So he decided to bring me a bowl of anchovies to fix it. I explained that I did not want the black olives on my pizza. So with a visible annoyed face he proceeded to remove the pizza and told me he was going to cook the right one immediately. 15 minutes later he brought a pizza with anchovies, capers and...you guessed it, black olives again.It was by then almost 1 and a half hours after we sat down. At that point I just asked for the check, which on top of it was ridiculously expensive and left. Sure enough, I will never go back and suggest to anyone who wants to have a real good experience and the best pizza in manhattan, to go to Mezzaluna. There is reason why it has been the best for more then 30 years. Trust me. Terrible experience, terrible service, the place looks rundown and dirty. Stay away.
Be the first to ReplyThey accept walk ins, but offered us a high table because
They accept walk ins, but offered us a high table because we didn't have a reservation, not really comfy. Service was okay, not great, not bad. But food on the other hand.. was amazing! Everything tasteful, good portions, so so good!
Be the first to ReplyAlthough we were late, they held a table for the 4 of us.
Very friendly and accommodating. Meat and cheese charcuterie bots was delicious. We also had a bottle of Malbec, a pizza, and a pasta, which was perfectly al dente. Wait staff were attentive. Vibe was familiar.
Be the first to ReplyI ordered a contadina pizza with 4 extra ingredients at 4
I ordered a contadina pizza with 4 extra ingredients at 4 dollars each. That's a 38 dollar 12 inch pizza. There is hardly any squash or eggplant or provolone. I texted to complain but they responded the pie was perfect. Beware of this ripoff restaurant.
Be the first to ReplyDefinitely the best Napoletana pizza in the upper Eastside.
I literally order a whole pie and finish it by myself. If you didn't try, you must try to please.
Be the first to ReplyIt's a very slow place.
I had to wait for my order for 60 minutes, it's crazy. There were no people in the cafe at all, but the cooks to make one pizza for an hour. I'm disappointed and I really don't recommend this place if you don't want to spend the whole day waiting
Be the first to ReplyI ventured out to San Matteo after walking by this place on
I ventured out to San Matteo after walking by this place on numerous occasions, it is on the corner of a couple of busy streets on the UES and I wanted to give it a shot. The menu is quite extensive and they are good at what they do well.The pizza is made well and fits what I think is a somewhat Neapolitan style. The crust is very airy and the pizza was cooked well. I think San Matteo fits the neighborhood quite well but there are other spots in the neighborhood that I think slightly edge this place out. For the price of what you are paying here, I think there are some other spots that I would prefer.
Be the first to ReplyI absolutely love San Matteo! I come here often with
I absolutely love San Matteo! I come here often with friends, family, and coworkers. It's casual, has great food and drinks, and has a lovely and friendly wait staff. For a pizza place, the burger was fantastic - I recommend.
Be the first to ReplyThis place is under rated.
For a few exceptional reasons.mentioned after the obvious. Yes, there is very accommodating service. Yes, the food is worth every penny. Yes, the special are amazing. Yes there is a chance you can get a table during peak hours because there is also an upstairs. But did you know they have award winning burgers? Did you know the awards were hosted by food network? The pac-man shirts the staff are wearing are a clever attempt at letting you know. Unfortunately I was not able to put all that together prior to ordering. Besides it was my first time there with my family and had to go big. We were celebrating. Had the porterhouse steak for two and the grilled calamari. My wife and kids and myself left very very full. I can't wait to go back and try the award winning burgers. Sorry about the steak picture. I was hungry and had to have some before taking it.
Be the first to ReplyWow - I'm disappointed after hearing rave reviews about San
Wow - I'm disappointed after hearing rave reviews about San Matteo being one of the "best" pizza places on the UES. I did order delivery, so maybe I would have a better experience in person, but I don't think it's worth the hype. First, the toppings are minimal at best. We ordered the ย magherita and a regina magherita pizza. For one of the pizzas, there was a single basil leaf, which I have to admit was pretty comical, but left a lot to be desired. Second, there was barely any crust supporting the cheese. I could have slapped on the toppings on just cheese for a keto twist and I wouldn't have tasted a difference. The pizza actually tasted better once I put it in the air fryer because at least that gave it some texture. Overall, "best" pizza on the UES? Highly doubtful - makes me wondering if they are compensating IG food accounts to heavily advertise them because the food doesn't live up to the expectations.
Be the first to ReplyCame here specifically because of the award winning burger
Came here specifically because of the award winning burger (2019 NYC food and wine winning). For me the burger wasn't anything too special. Mozzarella cheese on a burger just doesn't pack enough flavor. The pizza dough bun was creative but ultimately got very soggy under all the juices. With that said, the environment in the restaurant is great and the pizzas looked amazing (I didn't try but our friends did and they loved it). I would come back and get a pizza next time (serves me right for ordering a burger at a pizzeria lol!)
Be the first to ReplyIf the pizza tastes as good as it looks, that explains why
If the pizza tastes as good as it looks, that explains why this place is so empty. This pizza is terrible! You can tell it's frozen. The pizza isn't the only thing that's bad. The customer service is too! I end up waiting ages just for the waiter to come and hand us our drinks, even when we're one of the only ones there! As soon as I walked in my appetite flew south for the winter. I'm never eating here again. I'd rather stop at a corner pizza shop and get a 1$ pizza than come here. Save your money
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza in your town.
They are always accommodating. We have been dining in San Matteo for years. Carmela is the best!.
Be the first to ReplyThis place has a huge rat problem.
We sat outside and had a rat not a mice run right underneath our table. Not safe at all. Not only do these rats carry so many diseases (during Covid times stuff like this make it more stressful) but these are fearless and huge possibly bigger than a possum.
Be the first to Reply