Scarpetta Beach Montauk Yelp Reviews - Scarpetta Beach Montauk - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Scarpetta Beach Montauk for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Scarpetta Beach Montauk from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Montauk's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Scarpetta Beach Montauk
Ranked #18 in Montauk's Best Restaurants.
Scarpetta Beach Montauk Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
40 Reviews
0 Replys |
What a fantastic restaurant with great ambiance, food, and
What a fantastic restaurant with great ambiance, food, and service. If you're staying at Gurney's, you must have dinner here. It's just complements the romantic weekend. I highly suggest starting with the Scallops appertizer and the Lobster Tagliolini. These were my favorites, although everything we had was delicious. My only disappointment is not being able to try some of the other pasta dishes.
Be the first to ReplyVery pricey; only real dine in dinner restaurant option if
Very pricey; only real dine in dinner restaurant option if you are staying overnight at Gurneys. 2 scallops for $30 and 1 large tentacle grilled octopus for $30.....only thing to note was it's very pretty inside with a dull elegant decor and ocean back drop. The cauliflower and the desserts are the only things I would recommend. The tagliatelle was good but too salty; the black cod was just ok. The branzino was good. The grape escape cocktail is good but $21. But service is amazing - they pace you slow and are very courteous.
Be the first to ReplyThe restaurant is located in the lobby at the famous
The restaurant is located in the lobby at the famous gerneys resort and I definitely wanted to like this place more. I mean, the food was decent, and the service was good, but overall, it was not great for the price. For dinner, I got the blackened cod, which was rather tasty and cooked well. Portion size was a little small, but overall, I'd recommend it. My wife got a pasta dish, which was nicely homemade. However, it was also on the smaller side, especially for pasta. The atmosphere was nice. The outdoor area was very nice and had a bunch of igloos and outdoor firepits.
Be the first to ReplyIf you're looking for a restaurant to facilitate a romantic
If you're looking for a restaurant to facilitate a romantic dinner date, Scarletta Beach checks all the right boxes! To begin with, the location is awesome; the restaurant overlooks a lovely beach. The atmosphere is very well suited to a romantic tete-a-tete, the service is 1st tier, and the food is nothing short of exceptional :-) Tip: If you're a fan of well-crafted cocktails, I highly recommend their hibiscus margarita We shared our dinner family style; each of the dishes we tried was delicious and beautifully presented. The yellowtail crudi was sophisticated and delicately flavored, and the halibut was tasty and tender. We also both very much enjoyed the cod, but it seemed to be a bit too salty for my taste. We throughly enjoyed the entire dining experience, and I wouldn't hesitate to either return or to recommend this venue very highly!
Be the first to ReplyExcelente servicio.
Lovely people loveeee the outside fireplace. Food is dinamite. Great service
Be the first to ReplyThis was the best meal we had entire trip visiting.
The cacio e pepe ravioli was amazing. Olive oil cake for dessert is a must. And the cod was perfectly cooked. Not fishy at all. Can't wait to come back.
Be the first to Reply07 July 2023 we are here with Dr.
Schmidt Hank .......................................................... definitely................................................................ ..................... coming ........................................... ..................... back
Be the first to ReplyFood was on point.
Narrow focus but they did it well. Service was awesome. Perhaps the best we saw.
Be the first to ReplyLets start with the positive.
..which is the views wow, best in town for sure. Views are immaculate and the ambiance definitely emulates the Hampton bougie-ness and gives luxury. The parking is a bit tough so highly recommend uber-ing/carpooling or valet and it took us weeks to get a reservation confirmation so definitely work on that early! We were seated right away with a party of 10 so thats great service and the server was very nice but for some reason montauk servers are not fans of birthdays and singing happy birthday with a cake so if you're traveling for a birthday, definitely keep that in mind. Now onto the food, very average is what I have to deem this place unfortunately. The pasta was sticky and the short rib didnt necessarily fall off the fork and it was mostly fat. The halibut was good but for the price tag, I expected quite a bit more especially a carb? Like a mashed potato? Each dish just felt ok considering the price tag but the real star of the show was the short rib agnolotti! That was delicious!! It had the perfectly medley of the bone marrow taste and it wasnt overwhelming at all so if you go here, definitely recommend that dish! Gurneys Lobster Pasta Short Rib Agnolotti Braised Short Ribs
Be the first to ReplyI love the environment, the food everything is great.
After dinner at Scatpet you can enjoy a nice bar with the band dowstars in Seville.
Be the first to ReplyThe food here is good, but for the price, the service was
The food here is good, but for the price, the service was pretty poor. I'm not sure if it was an under-staffing problem, or what was going on, but for these prices it really isn't acceptable. Also, we had a late reservation (9:30), and still felt an extreme lag in service. It seemed as if the waitstaff just didn't care.Unless you are sitting facing the windows while it is light out, there are definitely restaurants in the area with much prettier ambiance inside.
Be the first to ReplyMy husband and I had an amazing night.
The food was absolutely delicious. The great sommelier recommended the perfect wine pairing for us within our price range. The service the best service we have had in a very long time. I would recommend Scarpetta Beach to anyone asking about a great restaurant in Montauk.
Be the first to ReplyStaff, across the board: professional.
Lester, Edwin, the entire team- just perfect. Impeccable service and an easy rapport with delicious pairings. We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experiences over several evenings.
Be the first to ReplyThis place is incredible! They will accommodate all
This place is incredible! They will accommodate all requests and the food is amazing! I had the blackened cod and paired it with a lemon Tini to die for! Beautiful setting
Be the first to ReplyThis restaurant is completely overrated! We had an 8:30
This restaurant is completely overrated! We had an 8:30 reservation and without notification they pushed us to 9:00! We were finally seated and the cushion was soaked? My husband's jeans were wet from who knows what!! The portions are sooo small that it was not worth the wait!
Be the first to ReplyGreat fall dinner! Delicious roast chicken entree and
Great fall dinner! Delicious roast chicken entree and polenta with mushrooms. The Burrata was also fantastic. Atmosphere was relaxing and inviting.
Be the first to ReplyAhmazing!!!! It's like your normal scarpetta meets a very
Ahmazing!!!! It's like your normal scarpetta meets a very elegant beach/ beach hotel. The vibes here are everything!! With Scarpetta food to match.Came here last week during my Montauk/ East Hampton stay! Such a nice, relaxing meal. Patio is gorgeous with individual heat lamps. But I stayed inside because it was gorgeous. Less crowded. A little cold out too. Our server was amazing! He lived in New Orleans, Florida and now Montauk. Such a fun/ cool dude. The crowd was the Hampton crowd: so much bling, snobbiness, Jersey blings! Total mix pot. Service was great. The short rib agnolotti is mind blowing! As well as their spaghetti, bread basket, black cod and then some. Bread basket is amazing!! Like AHMAZING!! I can just eat the whole thing by myself and call it a day. Beet salad was good. Scallop appetizer was Yumm! Cocktails were pretty on points too. Compared to the manhattan Scarpetta, this was almost double in prices. Hampton prices! But food is delicious regardless.We had the most amazing time catching up with family, sipping, tasting and just fun! Totally a relaxing meal. Beach might have something to do with it. Or not! Definitely not cheap but totally worth it. The dessert being the BEST part!! Love love!!!
Be the first to ReplyThe food is good but the price seems a bit high for what
The food is good but the price seems a bit high for what you get. The service is EXTREMELY SLOW. My girlfriend and I came for breakfast a couple of times and also came for dinner a couple of times. Each time, the service was slow. At one of our dinners, we were convinced that our waiter was coked up
Be the first to ReplyCame here for dinner last night before going to the fire
Came here for dinner last night before going to the fire pit at gurneys and had a great time. We started with pretty much every appetizer- I liked the octopus, beet salad, and polenta the best. For the entres I split the tenderloin and the halibut- the pasta was pretty good with the exception of the black lobster pasta which everyone felt didn't have much flavor. Overall a great spot - worth coming back to!
Be the first to ReplyGreat experience! We arrived at Gurney's early and sat
Great experience! We arrived at Gurney's early and sat outside by the bar and had drinks and an appetizer. Service was great - drinks and food perfect! We were seated for dinner right on time! Service was impeccable! Friendly and professional. Food was amazing - and yes the portions are very small - but I knew this going in. The scallop appetizer had 2 scallops. But everything was delicious. The view is amazing. All in all it was a memorable experience.
Be the first to ReplyThe vibe there is pretty great but the food was mediocre
The vibe there is pretty great but the food was mediocre and the drinks were pretty bad. Service was spectacular!
Be the first to ReplyGreat view.
Amazing service. Too bad the food is just not good
Be the first to ReplyWorst dining experience I can remember having.
We waited to talk to the host for 30 min even though we had a reservation. After the wait we got a terible table. Horrible slow service and overly salty and buttery food. I will never come back.
Be the first to ReplyCame to Scarpetta Beach with a friend who had never been
Came to Scarpetta Beach with a friend who had never been out east. We didn't stay at Gurney's, so this is strictly for the dining experience. The ambiance is top notch. We chose to wait an extra 20 minutes for a table to open up outside. We were seated and given menus/water. We started with burrata and cauliflower appetizer. They were both SO good! I had a the tagliatelle pasta and it was top 5 pasta dishes I've ever eaten. It was so fresh and wasn't overly sauced. I also liked that the portion sizes were not over the top - more aligned with Europe than the US.My best friend had the lobster pasta and she loved her dish too!We shared the chocolate cake. Truth be told, it was absolutely delicious, but we just couldn't finish it.I will certainly be back!
Be the first to ReplyWhere to start.
..We did a lot of research to find the right restaurant in Montauk for our 25th wedding anniversary. We had been celebrating all week, but this was the big night and we wanted it to be nice.In the end, we went with Scarpetta Beach because of the views...It was a tough call because the reviews were not always favorable. But the pictures were nice, so...We put in a reservation, with a note explaining that we were celebrating our 25th and requesting a good table with a nice view.We got to the resort early, and had a nice cocktail on the patio, over looking the sea, and went to see the hostess at the appropriate time. Unfortunately, we were informed that there were only tables available inside (a dark, empty and dreary place at 6:30pm). We were told it would be at least 40 minutes before a table on the patio would open up. We opted to wait and headed back out to the patio for a second $20 cocktail (ea. of course).When we finally got a table, we started with the salmon crudi and a couple of glasses of wine. The salmon was alright but lacked that unctuous, buttery mouthfeel and flavor that I love about salmon, and the 'pesto' was only saved by the sun dried tomatoes. For dinner, my wife had the short rib & risotto appetizer, which consisted of three silver dollar size pieces of beef with gravy, and 1/2 cup risotto. The meat was tender, but tasteless. She commented to waiter that it was pedestrian and flavorless, but he wasn't listening or didn't understand.I had the black bass with pistachio salsa verde. Salsa verde? That's what they called it, but not what I would call it - maybe a chimichurri. The fish was mild and polite (almost not there), and the flavors of the accompaniments didn't really do anything to kick it in to gear.At this point, our waiter made one of his rare appearances to offer desert menus, but we were so tired of being disappointed, we opted to head back to our own resort, and decided we don't need to go to Gurney's again.
Be the first to Reply