The Maidstone East Hampton Yelp Reviews - The Maidstone East Hampton - Trade Reservations
Save up to 30% at The Maidstone East Hampton!
Have someone use their loyalty points to book your stay or buy a reservation from someone who can't make it to theirs.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
- Any Room Type
- Any Standard Room
- King Bed (Sofa Bed 600 Sq Ft Free Wifi Spacious Tv Adjoining Room)
- King Bed (220 Sq Ft Free Wifi Small Seating Area Curated Art Tv)
- King Bed (310 Sq Ft Free Wifi Adjoing Room Option Tv Small)
- King Bed Or 2 Twin Beds (270 Sq Ft Free Wifi Tv Minibar Storage)
- King Bed (200 Sq Ft Free Wifi Minibar Curated Art Desk)
- King Bed (Sofa Bed 330 Sq Ft Free Wifi Chaise Lounge Pet Friendly)
- King Bed Or 2 Twin Beds (395 Sq Ft Free Wifi Pet Friendly)
- King Bed (340 Sq Ft Free Wifi Seating Area Private Patio Pet)
- King Bed (Sofa Bed 385 Sq Ft Free Wifi Living Room Tv Spacious)
- Queen Bed (200 Sq Feet Free Wifi Pet Friendly Curated Art Minibar)
- King Bed (315 Sq Ft Free Wifi Pet Friendly Seating Area Minibar)
- Queen Bed (160 Sq Ft Free Wifi Minibar Tv Desk Minibar Corner)
- Queen Bed (190 Sq Ft Free Wifi Tv Pet Friendly Desk Minibar)
- King Bed (250 Sq Ft Free Wifi Seating Area Desk Tv Curated Art)
- Queen Bed (200 Sq Ft Free Wifi Pet Friendly Curated Art Minibar)
- King Bed (Day Bed 270 Sq Ft Free Wifi Adjoining Room Option)
- King Bed (Day Bed 225 Sq Ft Free Wifi Curated Art Minibar Seating)
- King Bed (230 Sq Ft Free Wifi Pet Friendly Desk Minibar Curaterd)
- Any Accessible Room
- King Bed (Sofa Bed 550 Sq Ft Free Wifi Spacious Ada Compliant)
East Hampton's Best Hotels that are most frequently booked by customers of The Maidstone East Hampton
Ranked #18 in East Hampton's Best Hotels.
The Maidstone East Hampton Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
12 Reviews
0 Replys |
I don't want to be mean, but the expectations were much
I don't want to be mean, but the expectations were much greater than the actual stay. It looks really good online, but the rooms are not very nice, the shower is nearly scary and the walls of the rooms are so thin you can hear EVERYTHING on the other side. (I don't want to go into what we heard.) Also, the restaurant seats guests very close to the hotel rooms and the combination of conversations and music is intrusive. And be prepared because the weekend can mean tables enjoying dinner and cocktails well after 10pm. The guy that checked us in was very good and earned the second of these two stars in this review. Honestly, it's the Hamptons...we were expecting much more. (Cracked tiles in the bathroom--waited for 15 minutes to get a drink in the bar, then left.)
Be the first to ReplyIt was absolutely delicious and a wonderful combination of
It was absolutely delicious and a wonderful combination of classic and modern cuisine.
Be the first to ReplyAbsolutely loved my stay at The Maidstone! Everything about
Absolutely loved my stay at The Maidstone! Everything about the hotel is just so cute and quaint, with a great location and impeccable service. First off, the overall property is gorgeous. It's a beautiful building, with a ton of outdoor space including tables and lounge chairs, and even a hammock + swing in the backyard. The front has plenty of seats as well, and they offer free bikes to take out for guests staying on property. The indoor decor is fabulous - each room is different, from the bar room with a cute fireplace to the millennial pink restaurant, to the eclectic and kitschy lounge next to the bar. I absolutely loved the attention to detail with all of the decor - it all just felt so unique and well put together. They sell cute jewelry in the front as well, and the bar is stocked with alcoholic seltzers, wines and beers, and a collection of cocktails.The room isn't huge, but it is big enough with unique decor in every room. It has a nice bathroom, decent sized closet, plenty of outlets for charging, and a very comfortable bed. Breakfast was included with our state, and it had a good assortment of pastries, bagels, yogurt, and more. The service was excellent from every single staff member I interacted with. I can't wait to come back!
Be the first to ReplyThis place has really gone downhill.
They used to have a nice full menu. Now they have a small tiny menu and take over an hour to bring you your food. Our server made us go on a treasure hunt just to find him. He took our appetizer order and then never returned. Our side plates were never taken away, our server never asked how the food was, and they never brought out all our food. Don't be deceived by their low prices. The portions match the prices... SMALL. The only thing that separates this from a one star review is that the food. The food was decent but definitely not worth coming back for.
Be the first to ReplyThis is my favorite restaurant in the Hamptons! AMAZING
This is my favorite restaurant in the Hamptons! AMAZING cuisine and atmosphere. Looking forward to what programs they may offer in the future. ;)
Be the first to ReplyDo not order from here for delivery.
They were on Door Dash this evening and we placed an order. It was scheduled to arrive 45 mins later, but never showed up. When we called the restaurant they said they didn't take any orders and would call us back. Instead of calling us back they took themselves off DoorDash and stopped answering their phones. My husband and I are both sick and unable to leave the house, we were relying on them for dinner. It's one thing to make a mistake and another thing to not even have the respect to call us back. DoorDash explained to us that they specifically have to take an action to confirm the order, meaning someone at the restaurant accepted our order and basically ghosted us. AVOID THEM FOR TAKEOUT.
Be the first to ReplyFrom the moment we arrived at the Maidstone until we left,
From the moment we arrived at the Maidstone until we left, it was a magical experience. Kyle greeted us for a seamless check in. This was our first holiday as a couple and it was perfect. The location on Main St is convenient and short drives to Montauk, Sag Harbor and Southampton. We sat by the fire and were just in the moment. I didn't even care what the wifi password was. Never checked! Breakfast was tasty and hit the spot. The staff is warm and very helpful offering suggestions for trips and restaurants. This is now our new holiday tradition!
Be the first to ReplyLoved the *inside* of this fabulous spot ! We ate at the
Loved the *inside* of this fabulous spot ! We ate at the large wooden table inside for brunch. I had the Berry Good Pancakes & the raspberries couldn't have been fresher ! Service was Amazing ! But seriously, the atmosphere took me to a far away moment of what every Summer holds...
Be the first to ReplyHello I am eating here during my best friend's bachelorette
Hello I am eating here during my best friend's bachelorette party. The squad loves it. We got rosé and white wine and everyone's meal was great except mine. I got the lobster ravioli and I think they accidentally broke the salt shaker and over salted the sauce. It's wild. You'd think you took a gulp of salt water from the Atlantic Ocean. Do not recommend. Aesthetic is so cutesy though. Prices reasonable. Not over the salt.
Be the first to ReplyThis is the best restaurant in the Hamptons, hands down.
Brunch, lunch, and dinner are all amazing! The chicken and waffles for brunch are out of this world... crunchy, sweet, savory explosion of taste. Every dish is incredibly beautiful and equally incredibly tasty. Everything about this place is noteworthy, from the food to the drinks to the dessert and don't forget the beautiful hotel rooms. Hands down the Maidstone Hotel is a must and a staple of East Hampton.
Be the first to ReplyPerhaps it was because our dinner took place in November
Perhaps it was because our dinner took place in November and not prime Summer season, but our experience left something to be desired. That something was easy to identify once our meal was completed and we piled into our Uber, reflecting thoughtfully on our evening. "Mindfulness" was the consensus; from the sommelier who failed to remove missing wines from the published list, from the sweet but distracted servers who disappeared for the duration of the meal and neglected simple tasks like silverware replacement and water pouring, from the kitchen that ran out of menu items and sent out lackluster food (save for the squash gnocchi). I suppose allowances must be made because it is off-season, but this less-than-stellar performance demanded on-season pricing and we paid it. On a positive note, the decor is interesting and inviting in the several lounge areas so I would return for cocktails.
Be the first to ReplyRestaurant review: if I could give zero I would.
we had a reservation, they made us wait, after over an hour they still didn't have the table ready. Said they would comp drinks and didn't. This happens, fine, but after we were finally forced to sit outside instead of our indoor resie, the wait staff and manager made this the worst overall service experience I have ever come across. Neglectful, unknowledgeable, terrible service. And the food was overpriced and not even close to worth the effort. I can't even list all the details of wrong that happened. Never will go back, so many other better restaurants on the area.
Be the first to Reply