The Smith New York Yelp Reviews - The Smith New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at The Smith New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at The Smith New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of The Smith New York
The Smith New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
27 Reviews
0 Replys |
The bread was awful - no flavor and then the Rigatoni a la
The bread was awful - no flavor and then the Rigatoni a la Vodka was the weirdest flavor - sesame seeds in it??? Bizarre. The pasta itself was very chewy and the sauce extremely salty. I wouldn't eat here again. My son couldn't even finish his plain spaghetti with butter because it was so salty. Waste of 140$ the only good thing was our waiter who was super sweet and attentive.
Be the first to ReplyWe made a reservation for 4 on a Sunday afternoon and thank
We made a reservation for 4 on a Sunday afternoon and thank god we did because while the place had amble tables, it was packed! I got the buttermilk pancakes and it was so decadent but delicious!! It was just enough that I was very satisfied and full without feeling guilty afterwards. My 2 friends got the smith eggs Benedict and it was also delicious but they both complained about the home fries being a little salty but it might just have been unevenly tossed. Overall the food was great and we really enjoyed the time there. If there is one complaint, it would be the price being a little higher than other brunch places.
Be the first to ReplyEverything was good but at the end I asked for decaf coffee
Everything was good but at the end I asked for decaf coffee and they gave me regular coffee. I didn't know until I couldn't sleep at night.
Be the first to ReplyAnother brunch aka my fave meal! Super busy on the weekends
Another brunch aka my fave meal! Super busy on the weekends but staff manages to give excellent customer serivce. Mimosas are a great ratio. All food tried was excellent. The pancakes have an itlaian cookie flavor to them which I loved. I got the BLT E which is served in a crossiant. Classic NY brunch spot.
Be the first to ReplyGreat atmosphere and quality service, but the food was
Great atmosphere and quality service, but the food was underwhelming. I ordered the rigatoni and the sauce was too hot and the dish way too small. I had to get myself a second lunch somewhere else
Be the first to ReplyConsistency good food and service.
I enjoyed the Mac and cheese. The burger is solid. You can't go wrong with any of the dishes. It's nice and clean. If you are looking for a good restaurant in midtown area. Check it out. They have other locations in the city too.
Be the first to ReplyWe had just checked into our hotel and wanted a bite nearby
We had just checked into our hotel and wanted a bite nearby so we stopped at The Smith. We were sat immediately when we walked in and loved the atmosphere - the music is amazing! We highly recommend the Cucumber Ginger Beer, that is made in house, and the Shrimp and Grits. The appetizers portions were small but the entrees were large. The entire team was very attentive and checked in frequently. We highly recommend for brunch and will be returning for happy hour!
Be the first to ReplyI'm a word, Overrated.
I expected MUCH more. After reading the reviews and word of mouth, I was excited to eat here. For a restaurant with this volume of customers, the prices, location, etc. I should have had high expectations. I was let down. The food was ... Okay. Definitely not great. The service was good, better than the food. Sadly, after paya huge bill for 6 people, I left feeling quite unhappy. I gave them 3 Stars due to our Server and his diligence.
Be the first to ReplyI've visited the Smith a number of times and it never
I've visited the Smith a number of times and it never disappoints. I absolutely love the smith and enjoy their brunch the most. The food is so yummy and enjoyable. The French Vanilla French Toasts was delicious and for those who enjoy savory foods the eggs Benedict are *chefs kiss* amazing! It's never too loud but is frequently just so definitely make a resy!! If you're in Manhattan definitely go and try it out! It won't disappoint!
Be the first to ReplyOur office stopped by for a last minute lunch we had our
Our office stopped by for a last minute lunch we had our rsvp & were seated maybe 10 minutes after we arrived. Drinks to start Beer , wine & Sangria all decent. No appetizers, I Had the Ghonic pasta , it was ricotta ghonic w truffle oil it was very good only complain was it didn't have a lot of truffle taste. The Shrimp tartagelle pasta was very good, so were the Burger w fries , Chicken sรกndwich & Caesar salad w Salmon all decent choices. For desert we tried the Apple pie , nice & warm it was very good. Nice big place, service was good & prices are a bit on the high side but doable we had an enjoyable lunch.
Be the first to ReplyWe were seated for breakfast and ordered fairly quickly.
Our server did not come by very often to check on us. She never refilled my water for my tea and the food was not really hot. I was not impressed.
Be the first to Replyone of my favorite places in manhattan.
service was good, food was great. steak was done perfectly, the sides were all good. salmon & crispy rice highly recommended!
Be the first to ReplyI've been here several times, mostly with my wife or by
I've been here several times, mostly with my wife or by myself. ย This time with my wife and two teens; it was too loud for easy family convo. ย The service was lacking, but the food was super. Every bit of every dish tasted great: bibimbap, fries, rigatoni, short ribs, burrata (was was kinda like a caprese), brussel sprouts, kale quinoa salad. ย Our waiter was apologetic and comped the screw ups (got one order wrong and the fix came out very late in the meal, waited long for water refills).It costs a lot to eat out, the food here was great, as it should be. ย If they got the service right this time, as has been my past experiences, I'd give it 5 stars.
Be the first to ReplyWorst experience ever.
Our server was extremely rude. We arrived 5 min after bf ended and asked another server who walked by if they could accommodate breakfast and he was extremely nice and said let me check. Well our server comes and ask for our order. I reply with we just asked the sever who walked by if they would accommodate Breakfast, he got upset and said I already told you breakfast was over and walked away. He comes back and gives us a lecture about how if we want bf we need to come early in the morning. Then said we can do it but your food is going to be rushed and won't be that good. So i said that's fine we won't order bf and I order a grilled chicken sandwich with fries and everyone else orders. Well everyone else got their food and I'm waiting. He comes back and I let him know I'm still waiting on my food and he's like you didn't order food. I reminded him that I was the first one to place the order and he looks at me like I'm lying. I repeat my order and he leaves without saying anything. Im on vacation and really don't need the attitude from someone. Im a paying customer who wasn't asking for anything crazy.
Be the first to ReplyFirst of all this place is is awesome.
I was greeted with a smile. The food was delicious and the waitress couldn't do enough for me went a extra mile.She was awesome. Thank you
Be the first to ReplyCosy and nice atmosphere for dining.
Pasta was so delicious. Even though I don't like spicy food, I really enjoyed it. Staff was very nice and helpful.
Be the first to ReplyThis is my second time here and I still love it.
The server was super nice and I absolutely adored her! The food was great and super filling and the ambience of the place was really nice as well! I would definitely recommend this place for all types of occasions!!
Be the first to ReplySaturday brunch is busy! The staff was friendly and
Saturday brunch is busy! The staff was friendly and attentive. Loved the Apple Churro Waffles, totally crave worthy. The Benedict Johnny was a little dry, and not very pleasing to the eye. My companion's traditional Eggs Benedict was delicious, and the home fries were hot and crispy. ย Coffee was great. Will definitely be back again soon.
Be the first to ReplyWe have been to this location two times.
Each time we arrive, there is a long wait. The first time, we sat inside the bar as it was quicker to be seated. The second time, which was a few days ago, we were able to sit in the outdoor heated area. The service is good here and I appreciate the nice, heated outdoor space. We ordered the same thing the two times we have been here. Food is delicious here! There are other locations which we have yet to try. I ordered the benedict eggs and my husband ordered the burger. To drink, we both had their coffee which tasted fresh. I would recommend this place and would definitely visit again.
Be the first to ReplyI've been here twice and I can't wait to go back! The
I've been here twice and I can't wait to go back! The brunch menu here has such a wide variety of options that you'll probably want to order a tons. If you're going to The Smith really hungry, you'll most likely eat your whole plate, but if you're not, the plates sizes are good for Sharing ( at least I think so).The food tastes amazing and the staff are so friendly and attentive. It does get a little loud inside depending where you sit, however I would still describe the ambience as calm (Very NY lol). You don't have to go dressed super fancy, which makes it a great last minute restaurant to dine in if you're in the area. And if you're not in the area, make some time to go because it's just that great. Did I mention their brunch is great! Lol I would so recommend The Smith. Specifically the one located closest to Lincoln Center.
Be the first to ReplyI came here for brunch this past weekend with a group of
I came here for brunch this past weekend with a group of friends. Very Covid friendly with outdoor dining, dividers, and heaters!Everyone also enjoyed their food. I got the avocado toast and thought it was very good. It was lemony, not spicy, and came with a basic but good side salad. The fries I shared with my friend were also really good! The coffee was good as well. Just wish the waiters were a bit more attentive they never filled our water containers until they gave us the bill.
Be the first to ReplyUnenthusiastic and incomplete service accompanied by
Unenthusiastic and incomplete service accompanied by room-temperature to warm entrรฉes made for a dissatisfying experience. (Told our waiter. Declined an entree rerun because we were starving). Two stars are for the bussing staff who were attentive and for having a zero wait time. Foretelling? So disappointing to have this experience in a city known for great eating experiences.Out of Ingredients to a signature cocktail at 10:00 pm? Sat with empty drink glasses until finally able to flag down the waiter for either a dessert order, ย a drink order, ย and when we gave up on the above, the check. First time ever, ever, ever leaving no tip. Here for the weekend only. Gave the two-free cocktail coupon to dining neighbors since we're leaving Sunday. Sad to have wasted an NYC dining experience here.
Be the first to ReplyLots of space and the food was good.
Service was good.Noise was average. Good for big parties The bathrooms were interesting because it was one room with all unisex stalls which meant everyone washed their hands together in the sinks outside of the stalls. I've never seen that before, so it was interesting.
Be the first to ReplyClassic Egg Benedict and grapefruit juice were as good as
Classic Egg Benedict and grapefruit juice were as good as they were. Service was nice.
Be the first to ReplyMy company held a corporate event/delayed holiday party
My company held a corporate event/delayed holiday party there the other evening, and it was just awesome. We reserved the party room, and it's the perfect size for a small gathering - it has just the right feel for any event, honestly. The staff was so accommodating and friendly - we all felt so taken care of the entire night. And their food is great! I will continue to keep The Smith at the top of my list for future corporate and social events.
Be the first to Reply