Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York Yelp Reviews - Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York
Uncle Paul's Pizza NY New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
26 Reviews
0 Replys |
Great spot for authentic pizza by the slice.
Crispy crust that is still doughy inside and lots of toppings. Sauce was savory with a hint of sweet. Pizza perfection.
Be the first to ReplyThe pizza I had was a Sicilian corner.
Just too good. They were polite and the pizza made me greedy for another one. Here I go order one again ......
Be the first to ReplyThe pizza pies are huge and classic.
It's a hole in the wall with few tables. I think they must do a brisk takeout business. I was in town on a field trip with a few students. We had the pepperoni pizza, the lasagna pizza, a plain one, and a mushroom sausage pie. We had dinner there on a Tuesday and returned for lunch on Wednesday. I'm knocking off a star because out of five pizza pies I thought two had underdone crusts and the bathroom looked good but wasn't very clean. Also it would have been great to have the option of a pitcher of water for our large group rather than only individual bottled drinks. Table service was not available but we ordered at the counter and they did deliver the pizzas to our table. They seemed very busy. Three of the pizzas were very good. I would return.
Be the first to ReplyEaten here four times now (every time I come to New York),
Eaten here four times now (every time I come to New York), and literally the best pizza I have had. Staff is friendly. Good location. Amazing pizza.
Be the first to ReplyThis is by far the BEST pizza in Midtown! And I gotta say,
This is by far the BEST pizza in Midtown! And I gotta say, I'm a Foodie and I LOVE pizza more than any other food group! The crust is thin.... and crispy on the bottom. The sauce is ON POINT. WHAT ELSE IS THERE??? Oh! The staff is super friendly and fun! This is a great NYC experience! Anyone who's around the area Must Must MUST stop in here to enjoy a slice. All the other options they have - like the chicken ranch pizza? INSANE. Why? Because the crust is thin and crispy on the bottom....everything else on top is a tastebud bonanza Hey - You know if you know.... Pleeease Make this a destination my pizza loving people!!
Be the first to ReplyI didn't think the pizza was amazing but they did give us
I didn't think the pizza was amazing but they did give us this entire box for free as we left because they were closing for the night so that was awesome
Be the first to ReplyThey completely messed up my order.
I ordered margarita and mushroom/ onion and they sent me cheese and a veggie slice. I called and they refused to fix my order because I "live too far." Atrocious customer service. Also the cheese was only half hanging on the cheese slice and it arrived in very poor condition.
Be the first to ReplyFast, great service and food was up to NY standards.
Will return. Called it in. Was ready on time.
Be the first to ReplyOne of the beauties about New York is its local pizza.
I took my sister here on her first trip to New York and we enjoyed the pizza. There was a long line when we walked in but the staff was quick and efficient with getting everyone's orders out. The Pizza had the right amount of cheese and sauce where the sauce wasn't dripping out of the pizza and the cheese had a perfect cheese pull when it came out of the oven. Another thing to note was that there wasn't much excess oil from the cheese which prevents messes too. Overall, if you're looking for the taste of New York, definitely check out Uncle Paul's!
Be the first to ReplyI'm so happy to have discovered Uncle Paul's! NY pizza at
I'm so happy to have discovered Uncle Paul's! NY pizza at it's best and such a convenient location next to Grand Central! Nice staff, and a cozy interior on a wintery day. Uncle Paul's is now on my favorites list!
Be the first to ReplyClassic cheese slice.
We'll balanced sauce to cheese ratio. Not aggressively seasoned with oregano, which I don't personally care for. Thin, crispy crust with a satisfying chewiness.
Be the first to ReplyBeing deprived from great east coast pizza living in the
Being deprived from great east coast pizza living in the West Coast, Uncle Paul delivers. From the simplest cheese to meat lovers to margarita, crust is thin and firm a flavor galore! Well done . Staff is awesome!
Be the first to ReplyI tried the pepperoni slice and the buffalo chicken slice
I tried the pepperoni slice and the buffalo chicken slice from here - service was very friendly and my order was ready for pick up once I arrived. There are a number of tables in both the indoor and outdoor dining area, with several groups sitting down and enjoying their slices. The pizza was really good here! The buffalo chicken slice had a good amount of not-too-spicy buffalo sauce, and the chicken was not breaded, which I really liked. The pepperoni slice was not bad either.
Be the first to ReplyA place to hang out and get something quick to eat.
Pizza is not great but it's okay. However, it's pricey.
Be the first to ReplyJust got intown and looking for a beer and a slice.
WOW!!!! Uncle Paul's knocked it out of the park. There is a reason we waited for the counter was packed. So many choices of pizza by the slice it was ridiculous. The flavor was superior! Would recommend to all.
Be the first to ReplySweet little spot In NYC for pizza! Service was good and
Sweet little spot In NYC for pizza! Service was good and place was clean. We ordered pizza and pizza rolls. Pizza was a bit grease y but it hit the spot nonetheless.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing pizza!!!! Quaint place made fresh and hot!
Amazing pizza!!!! Quaint place made fresh and hot! Recommend if you're looking for a good slice of New York pizza!
Be the first to ReplySeating: low top and high top tables Service: walk up to
Seating: low top and high top tables Service: walk up to the counter to pay and orderVibe: the perfect quaint nyc pizza joint. Italian music playing and pizzas made fresh. I'm from the Midwest, but it seemed like an authentic nyc pizza joint to me! Food: soooo good! Pizza was warm, cheesy, and the bottom was crisp and didn't flop over limp when you hold it. Very good! They also serve alcohol, beer and wine, I believe.
Be the first to ReplyWhere to start.
They were super fast and the pizza was amazing. I live in Kentucky and would definitely drive to New york to get a slice of this pizza.* A Slice of heaven*
Be the first to ReplyCame here on a visit to the Big NYC.
Starved all day and made it a point to come here for a meal. Got Grandma's pizza and Pepperoni. Phenomenal. Sauce so fresh you can taste the air the tomatoes were just pulled from. The pepperoni was not like any sliced meat I have ever had. It was tantalizing. Environment was warm and clean. Staff was helpful and made sure everyone followed the rules for covid. Excellent representation of what a NYC pizzeria should be.
Be the first to ReplyPicture this- 5 girls, hungry, cold, in a big city, and
Picture this- 5 girls, hungry, cold, in a big city, and desperately wanting pizza. Uncle Paul's solved all of our problems. Cozy environment, nice employees, (the blonde one held the door open and took his hat off for us) , and of course AMAZING pizza. No longer cold or hungry I'm now warm and happy and hoping to stumble across this place again someday.
Be the first to ReplyReally good nyc pizza! And the people are so nice! Gave my
Really good nyc pizza! And the people are so nice! Gave my son a free pizza just because he loved it's so much! Will be coming back
Be the first to ReplyA few tables and a walk up counter and some of the finest
A few tables and a walk up counter and some of the finest slices you'll find in the city. Hot and fresh with great flavors. They also have calzones. Lots to choose from. I had a slice of mushroom and one with pepperoni. Awesome! Service is friendly and fast. Great place for a quick lunch.
Be the first to ReplyVery good Italian style pizzeria.
The staff is friendly and caring. I recommend trying a crispy corener of Grandma!!
Be the first to ReplyI was on vacation with my teenage kids and we stumbled on
I was on vacation with my teenage kids and we stumbled on this gem. It was the only place we went to twice When we were there. The kids loved the pizza and I loved that I could get a fantastic salad. The staff is friendly and great. Highly recommend!
Be the first to Reply