Calissa Water Mill - Buy Reservations

1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA

Getting a reservation at Calissa Water Mill for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!

Buy a verified reservation at Calissa Water Mill from someone who doens't need theirs anymore.

If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.

We only list verified Reservations! All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.

Read Less

Calissa Water Mill Reviews from The Last 180 Days

Yelp: 😒 (9) Tripadvisor: 🤮 (1)

🤮

This place is an absolute overpriced DUMP.

1/5 by Rob C. on 08/06/2022

After seeing this building turn many different names after years of coming here, this management is the worst. The branzino (which was frozen from the Canary Islands) was dry as cardboard, the drinks were sub par, and the service .. well the wait staff was great .but after a bunch of kids started smoking weed and a manger gave us the go ahead for cigars (mind u away from all and outside ... we're good neighbors), security just had to be a little asshole and tell us to go fuck ourselves. Embarresment after a $700 check is not something I stand for, so Fuck these assholes. Good luck getting my money again.

🤮

I came here recently and had a terrible experience.

1/5 by T S. on 07/28/2022

The apps were good but the entrees were overcooked and dry. Literally all of them. The alcohol pitchers are $100 each and have no alcohol in them. The servers are nice but very pushy and tried rushing us out. Don't get me started on management. The manager gave us the wrong check and tried charging us for more people. Then after spending almost 2k for dinner they tried telling us that we need to spend another $100 per person to stick around for some dj they got. He was so rude to us and we will not be back and will be telling everyone we know to STAY AWAY

😒

It's fine.

3/5 by Shannon G. on 07/28/2022

The service is quite slow and the food is wayyy overpriced. It was tasty but nothing I couldn't get anywhere else on Long Island. I will say the atmosphere would make me come back.

🤮

Worst meal I’ve ever had in the Hamptons

1/5 by ajk404 on 07/26/2022

We went to Calissa after our friend’s teenage daughter recommended it. It’s a very cool space, but the food and service were AWFUL. We were there on a Wednesday night, when half of the tables were empty. Still, it took 20 minutes to get a waiter to come over to our table - and only after we had tried to flag him down repeatedly. They include an 18% gratuity so our waiter just didn’t care. They force you to buy $12 bottles of water, saying that there is a problem with their tap water. The watermelon salad was good, but the rest of the food was mediocre at best. The $28 chicken skewer was inedible. We definitely will NOT return.

🙂

Rodolfo was a pleasure to us.

4/5 by Sara M. on 07/19/2022

He was very helpful with our questions. In my reservation I wrote to please sing for my husband birthday and they did . Thank you so much ! We enjoyed all.

🤢

My family and I LOVE Greek food but Calissa has to be the

2/5 by Elena S. on 07/17/2022

My family and I LOVE Greek food but Calissa has to be the worst Greek food we have ever tasted!! We gave it a try twice and It's almost like diner food but with higher prices! If you have a reservation but you go with kids they always seat you inside and tell you theres nothing available outside when half the outside seating area stays empty! The portions are extremely small,bland and tasteless! Really disappointing!The only reason I gave it two stars and not one was because our waitress was really kind!

🤮

Bad food and slow service.

1/5 by Jori G. on 07/08/2022

Consider ordering bottled water since tap water here smells like swamp water. The pricing is not related to quality of ingredients nor cooking. This place should be called the highway robbery.

🙂

I've dined at Calissa twice, and it has not disappointed.

4/5 by Wendy L. on 06/26/2022

They have a pretty extensive menu of appetizers, kebobs, fish dishes, etc. At our table, we shared the Pikilia platter (all six dips with pita), leek rice and Greek fries, and I shared the branzino for two with a friend. The standout was the branzino which was so delicious - the fish was flaky and moist and had tons of flavor. We ended up having to share it with the rest of the table because everybody enjoyed it so much. The Pikilia platter was also very tasty and also provided a lot of variety with the various dips (some more popular than others); it was too much for us four adults to eat along with our main dishes. As for our side dishes, the Greek fries were disappointing; they were fries with Feta cheese, raisins and olives. Next time, we're going to order the lemon potatoes.Calissa has an extensive wine menu, and we were able to get assistance from the sommelier who found us a bottle of wine at the right price point. The outdoor dining setup - which was in place before Covid - is lovely and a definite treat for those wonderful summer nights.

😍

Calissa was literally my favorite restaurant in the

5/5 by Jess C. on 06/01/2022

Calissa was literally my favorite restaurant in the Hamptons this Memorial Day weekend! My friends actually went twice lol it's probably my favorite Mediterranean restaurant right now. The ambiance was chic and modern, and I believe a DJ plays house music later in the evening. The restaurant was pretty crowded, so we could tell it was the start of the Memorial Day rush. We order some really good appetizers - my favorite being the watermelon salad! It was tasty and refreshing! I need to add it to my fitness diet lol my friend and I had the lamb chops, and they were so flavorful. Our AirBNB host recommend the restaurant to us, and told us he knew the owner. Midway through our dinner, we met the owner and showed him a picture of our host. He gave us a complimentary bottle of champagne! It was awesome! I was then trying to decide how I was going to finish the 2 watermelon mojitos I ordered, and the champagne! Calissa will be my go-to in the Hamptons! Until then, happy eating!!

😍

Exceeded my expectations!!! Beautiful decor, friendly &

5/5 by Melissa H. on 04/30/2022

Exceeded my expectations!!! Beautiful decor, friendly & polite staff, and absolutely delicious food! Loved the moussaka & baklava! Plus, we each got a complementary glass of champagne for our anniversary! Will definitely be back.

Videos & Internet Profiles of Calissa Water Mill

Instagram Facebook Yelp TripAdvisor Resy OpenTable

Other Popular Restaurants in Water Mill

Scarpetta Beach Montauk

Le Bilboquet Sag Harbor

Kissaki Sushi Water Mill

The Crow's Nest Montauk

Tutto il Giorno Sag

Best Posts

Discussions

Reviews

Delilah

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (07/11/2022 3:04 pm)

Had another wonderful evening at Delilah. Thanks AP for making this happen:)

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Go to place for reservations

🙂 4/5 Review by GutsySalt20 (06/21/2022 8:35 am)

Great app for hard to get reservations. Stumbled across it looking for a hard to get reservation in NYC. Started selling reservations myself after seeing how the site worked.

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Carbone NYC

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (07/04/2022 12:26 pm)

Exceeded my expectations!! Spicy Vodka pasta and Caesar salad are great but try the stuffed clams and pork chop, you won’t be disappointed!

1 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Nobu Malibu

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (07/05/2022 3:43 pm)

Got my reservation and had a wonderful lunch overlooking the ocean at Nobu Malibu!

0 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Excellent Idea!

🙂 4/5 Review by FamousStation67 (05/19/2022 8:11 pm)

This app is filling a void - there's a real market to tap into here. It's just annoying to see some reservations getting sold out here that end up in a no show - the restaurants aren't benefiting in such cases unless they charge a no-show fee. Besides this issue, I'm looking forward to the app community growing and would love to continue to contribute towards it's growth in any way that I can!

1 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Love!!!

😍 5/5 Review by FunctionalFact14 (03/29/2022 9:12 pm)

First time using the app and I was a little hesitant. Great experience from start to finish. They answered all the questions I had almost immediately. Will definitely use again and recommend it to all my friends

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (03/30/2022 5:42 pm)

8 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Appointment Trader

😍 5/5 Review by AcceptableParcel20 (03/24/2022 9:35 am)

Wow! First time using this website/app. It was almost hard to believe the quality of customer service I received as soon as I posted my offer. A private chat forum with me and the person helping me find the best option. Constant communication and a wonderful experience using Appointment Trader. I'm surprised it took me this long to find AT but this will now be my GO TO for hard to get restaurant reservations. It was like having my own private concierge.

Last Reply by GutsyNumber53 (07/03/2022 11:00 am)

6 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Great customer service

😍 5/5 Review by CohesiveBody50 (02/17/2022 6:13 am)

Was able to get a last-minute reservation for Valentine's Day with AT. The customer service team was incredibly responsive and helpful throughout the process!

5 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Just great !

😍 5/5 Review by SeemlyLook49 (02/16/2022 1:51 pm)

It was transferred fast and it worked !

Last Reply by CohesiveIndustry35 (04/27/2022 7:36 am)

4 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Last minute Pujol rezo in Mexico City

😍 5/5 Review by DistinctFront80 (02/16/2022 5:41 pm)

Last minute trip to Mexico City for Art Week. Busiest weekend in CDMX and AT came through and got us into Pujol. On Friday night … for four people! Amazing. I couldn’t believe it. Highly recommend this app.

3 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Seamless!😍 Appointmenttrader rocks!

😍 5/5 Review by BangingSmoke22 (02/22/2022 1:05 pm)

Appointmenttrader Rocks!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (03/12/2022 9:34 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Miami Beach Hot Spot Success!

😍 5/5 Review by CosmicLinen30 (02/24/2022 11:59 am)

My first experience using AT was awesome and the AT support saved the day! When my booking transfer initiated two days earlier but didn't complete by the day of the reservation, AT was able to expedite the transfer and confirm a table at Call Me Gaby in Miami Beach. Boss confirmed an excellent experience when he arrived and no issues to report. Thanks, AT! I will definitely be back and thank you very much for your prompt assistance!

2 Thumbs Up

0 Replys, 0 comments

Made our trip to NYC

😍 5/5 Review by CloseFiction30 (11/10/2021 8:40 am)

There was one restaurant we really wanted to visit in NYC and AppointmentTrader made that possible. Then when we had issues with the reservation transfer they were so quick to respond and fix the problem. We’ll definitely be using this again in the future.

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (11/10/2021 9:26 am)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

love this APP

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (11/02/2021 5:50 pm)

Just this week I scored two “hard to get” reservations! Friday at Delilah and tonight at Cafe Elote in Sedona! I am impressed!

Last Reply by GutsySalt20 (06/21/2022 8:53 am)

4 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 1 comment

Transfer was easy and fast!

😍 5/5 Review by StimulatingBlow43 (11/03/2021 6:43 pm)

Got a reservation transfer fast and easy to our favorite (and everyone else’s favorite 😉) Mexican Restaurant in Sedona!

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (11/03/2021 9:12 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Amazing!

😍 5/5 Review by GlitteringSwim77 (10/22/2021 8:01 pm)

This app is incredible!! I got a last minute rsvp for 7 people at Delilah’s on a busy Friday night…a mission we thought was impossible. I will always rely on this app when open table fails me!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (10/22/2021 8:40 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Lunch at GIRAFE

😍 5/5 Review by GlossyLevel60 (10/04/2021 5:37 am)

We had a great lunch spot at GIRAFE in Paris. And got a very very good and friendly support from the team of this great App. We definitely will book a table again here.

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (10/04/2021 11:04 am)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

Hottest michelin star restaurant in DC

😍 5/5 Review by AstoundingRay77 (09/27/2021 12:06 pm)

I highly recommend this service. Reservations sell out in minutes as they become available at this restaurant. I was able to get a table at the exact time we wanted, on a peak weekend night. Amazing!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (09/27/2021 12:12 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

AT extremely useful and lightning fast

😍 5/5 Review by ArdentGrass37 (09/17/2021 10:21 am)

Fast and painless process. Amazing experience

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (10/12/2021 9:15 am)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Amazing Experience

😍 5/5 Review by ArdentGrass37 (09/15/2021 8:35 am)

Got a reservation that not even the concierge for some Roman-like black card was able to. Excellent app!

Last Reply by CunningChange19 (09/15/2021 11:22 am)

4 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Perfect experience from start to finish

😍 5/5 Review by GainfulAdvertisement61 (08/29/2021 11:21 am)

The AT team and user experience is second to none. The team is attentive, proactive and responsive. Very satisfied with everything.

Last Reply by ColorfulRod45 (08/29/2021 2:50 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Reply, 0 comments

What a brilliant app! Landed an impossible to get table at Delilah!

😍 5/5 Review by ConfirmableRoof27 (08/24/2021 12:32 pm)

I just stumbled upon this site and within 24 hours of posting a bid for an impossible to get table at Delilah (on a holiday weekend no less), my reservation was confirmed! So easy to use and it worked flawlessly. Brilliant!

Last Reply by EvocativeFold67 (09/17/2021 3:42 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 3 comments

Amazing

😍 5/5 Review by AppreciativeSociety68 (07/16/2021 9:11 am)

Got our reservation at TAO on the busiest night of the week in 10 minutes. Amazing app!!

Last Reply by FluffyStar64 (07/18/2021 9:23 am)

2 Thumbs Up

2 Replys, 0 comments

Whose name will my reservation be under when I arrive at the venue?

Question by FluffyStar64 (07/09/2021 5:10 pm)

Best Answer It can be under your name or a name you choose! Some reservation offers already include the AppointmentTrader Transfer Service which will transfer the reservation in to your name. If its not included you can add it on after buying the reservation for a small fee. One thing on that though: As many reservations become available at last minute, taking a reservation in someone else name is quick and great for privacy. Most reservations on AT are listed with a virtual phone number, so all you need to do is present the phone number at the hostess stand and you are good to go!

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (07/09/2021 5:17 pm)

1 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 0 comments

Working on your bid?

Question by DemurePain59 (10/01/2021 1:24 pm)

Best Answer Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.

Best answer by EvocativeFold67 (10/02/2021 4:37 pm)

1 Thumbs Up

2 Answers, 0 comments

Process after bid is accepted.

Question by EvocativeFold67 (09/17/2021 8:11 pm)

Best Answer Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (09/17/2021 10:07 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

1 Answer, 2 comments

Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?

Question by ColorfulRod45 (07/13/2021 3:55 pm)

Best Answer Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.

Best answer by FluffyStar64 (07/13/2021 6:05 pm)

3 Thumbs Up

3 Answers, 1 comment

What happens if my bid expires unanswered?

Question by FluffyStar64 (07/08/2021 5:55 pm)

Best Answer Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.

Best answer by ColorfulRod45 (07/08/2021 6:28 pm)

2 Thumbs Up

3 Answers, 3 comments

Ask a Question

Calissa Water Mill User Reviews & Question Forums

Calissa Water Mill Yelp Reviews

Latest Reviews On Yelp

🙂3.7/5 from 10 reviews

Last review : Had dinner here last night and really enjoyed.
By Damian R. (03/12/2022 12:00 am)

See all reviews

Calissa Water Mill Tripadvisor Reviews

Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor

🙂4.1/5 from 10 reviews

Last review : Exquisite!
By ney1309 (01/01/2022 12:00 am)

See all reviews

AppointmentTrader Platform Reviews

Reviews from real people using AT!

😍4.9/5 from 30 reviews

Last review reply: RE: Carbone Vegas
By FluffyStar64 (07/12/2022 12:15 pm)

See all reviews

Create a Question in "Calissa Water Mill FAQ"

You will earn 25 Traderpoints for your Question.

Question Title

Question Context

Cancel

Create a Post in "Must try dishes at Calissa Water Mill"

Post Title

Post Context

Cancel

Create a Post in "Best Tables in Calissa Water Mill"

Post Title

Post Context

Cancel

Create a Post in "Staff to Know at Calissa Water Mill"

Post Title

Post Context

Cancel

Restaurant Transfers FAQ

Questions around how AppointmentTrader works for Restaurant Reservations

5 questions

Last question : Can I change my time before someone accepts my bid?
By EncouragingNeck25 (06/30/2022 12:47 pm)

See all questions

AppointmentTrader FAQ

Questions and Answers around the platform.

119 questions

Last question : Appointment Transfers
By CurativeBoat24 (07/15/2022 10:46 am)

See all questions