Back ButtonBack
The Surf Lodge Montauk Trade Reservations
Share Button
Important Information

Cancel
Important Information

OK
AppointmentTrader Logo Large
Twitter Logo
Instagram Follow Icon
Contact, Partners & Developers
📈 Marketplace Data
Volume: $12,985 👥 Online: 807 (24h)
Volume: $2,276,000 👥 Online: 15,316 (12mo)
Buy Icon
Buy
Navigation Icon
Sell Icon
Sell
Partner Icon
Money Network
Partner Icon
Partner
Signin Icon
Sign In
Back ButtonBack
Remove Searchtext Icon
Trade-In A Reservation You Have
Notification IconFollow

The Surf Lodge Montauk - Trade Reservations

Location Address Icon 183 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
More on The Surf Lodge MontaukRead More Action Icon
Loading Animation
Claim The Surf Lodge Montauk Ownership Update The Surf Lodge Montauk Opening Times
Hide The Surf Lodge Montauk Detail Data Read Less Action Icon
😎

Save up to 30% at The Surf Lodge Montauk!

Have someone use their loyalty points to book your stay or buy a reservation from someone who can't make it to theirs.

What if nothing fits my schedule? Read More Action Icon

If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.

We only list verified Reservations! All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.

Read Less Read Less Action Icon
We are getting this hotel ready for trading.

Hotels need at least 10 monthly views or must have a market price of more than $300/night to be listed.


You will receive a message once The Surf Lodge Montauk is ready.

Arrow Pointing Down
  • Any Room Type
  • Any Deluxe Room
  • Deluxe Ocean View King. Ocean View. Private Terrace. Newly
  • Deluxe Ocean Front King. Closest Rooms To The Beach. Floor (To)
  • Deluxe Ocean Front 2 Queens. Closest Rooms To The Beach. Floor ()
  • Dlx 2 Bdrm Ocean Front Cottage.ocean Front Fireplace.private
  • Deluxe Oceanfront 3 Bedroom Cottage.
  • Dlx One Bedroom Oceanfront Cottage. Fireplace. Kitchen. Private
  • Any Superior Room
  • Superior Ocean View King. Ocean View. Private Terrace. Queen
  • Any Family Room
  • Std Ocean View Jr Suite Bi (Level Living Space King Bed And A)
  • Any Suite
  • Deluxe Ocean View Junior Suite Bi (Level Private Terrace Ocean)
  • Superior Ocean View One Bedroom Suite. Ocean View. King Bed.
  • Our Superior Jr Suite Has A Partial Ocean View. Superior Ocean
  • Standard Ocean View One Bedroom Suite. Partial Ocean View King
  • Deluxe Oceanfront 1 Bedrm Suite. King Bed. Two Terraces. Queen
  • Deluxe Oceanfront Two Bedroom Suite. Steps From The Beach. Two
  • Superior Ocean View 2 Bedroom Suite Views Of Our Private White
  • Deluxe Oceanfront 1 Bedrm Suite. King Bed. Queen Sofa Bed Views
  • Any Standard Room
  • One Bedroom Residence Ocean View 1181 Sq Ft (Full Kitchen Terrace)
  • Standard Ocean View King. Partial Ocean View Terrace. Newly
  • Two Bedroom Residence Has Ocean Views 1305 Sq Ft (Full Kitchen)
  • Our 2 Bed Plus Den Residence Is A Private Custom Designed
  • Ocean View Three Bedroom Cottage. Ocean View Fireplace. Full
Arrow Pointing Down
Info icon Any available room type for
Tap here to return to calendar
Info icon Any available room type for
AppointmentTrader Location Calendar Icon
Arrow Pointing Right
AppointmentTrader Location Calendar Icon
Your Bid
You will receive a Sign-Up Bonus of 0 Traderpoints after you placed your first Bid.
Bid $835 to Get Someone's Reservation High, Fair Priced Bid: Your offer will also be sent to the sales team of The Surf Lodge Montauk anonymously. 16 sellers watching. Bid price covers taxes & most fees.
Important Information

We will send your bid 100% anonymously to everyone watching The Surf Lodge Montauk.

Your name will never be revealed publicly. Once we found a seller who has a Reservation that matches your bid the transfer will happen automatically and you will receive a confirmation email.
Bid Risk Free: If your bid does not get answered in time or you cancel your bid you will receive a refund.

Cancel Bid
🔨

Important Information

There is no Reservation available between

Don't worry! Place a bid for this exact Reservation request.

Place a Bid
⚡

Immediately Available Reservations

Don't like the offers? Tap here to place a Bid.
Low: $Loading Animation AppointmentTrader Icon Fair Price: $Loading Animation High: $Loading Animation
💰
Popularity Score ™ Tier of The Surf Lodge Montauk
Between on :
Average for March 2023
Events that Influenced the Popularity Score
 
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
See Tier DetailsRead More Action Icon

Hide Tier Details Read Less Action Icon
Comparable Transactions
Important Information

Approximate Results

There are not enough comparable transactions for Reservations. The suggested bid price is based on the average of the transactions below, multiplied with a Factor of due to the higher demand for Reservations.

Loading Animation at Loading Animation
Loading Animation Loading Animation Loading Animation Loading Animation

The Surf Lodge Montauk Reviews from The Last Year

Yelp: 🤢 (18) Tripadvisor: 😍 (12)
🤮

The Surf Lodge is really cool if you're visiting from a

1/5 by Zachary L. on 12/10/2022

The Surf Lodge is really cool if you're visiting from a really boring place like Cincinnati.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤮

Have never had a pleasant experience.

1/5 by Reilly W. on 10/13/2022

Staff treats me like I'm poor and don't belong.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

A September weekend in Montauk

5/5 by Pina on 09/26/2022

We had a wonderful time at Surfer‘s Lodge in Montauk, what a discovery! Beautiful rooms decorated with love and attention to detail, view on the pond, calm but lively! The staff is super friendly and adds to an entirely relaxing atmosphere. We loved it and would recommend it for a relaxed and fun weekend getaway.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Beautiful hotel with breath taking views all around the property.

5/5 by Fatimah A on 09/26/2022

This is the third time I’ve stayed at the surf lodge over the past years and I must admit it was my best experience during pre fashion week. Jayma is so attentive to the needs of all her guests. I traveled with my ESA service dog and he enjoyed the walks around the gorgeous property. Having a restaurant, live music, and outdoor bars are a plus. We definitely will be back soon.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Best trip ever

5/5 by Matt J on 09/21/2022

The hotel is a beautiful boutique type that is a must see in while in the Hamptons. Not only is the hotel great (Reese was the best in helping us during our stay), but the restaurant is amazing as well as the deck at night during the parties. This is a great place to come if you want to spot a celebrity while also having the time of your life. Cant wait to go back next summer.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Okay this place is absolutely INCREDIBLE.

5/5 by Dorothea P. on 09/20/2022

I would say there is a reason why it is legendary. I came to the Hamptons for one of my best friends bachelorette party and this was the location of our last hoorah. It could not have been anymore perfect. When we got there we were really surprised because you cannot actually part at the surf lodge and there is no valet. You have to part at the train station that is right down the street and walk over. We didn't have a problem doing that but we definitely wondered if it was safe. Once we made it there we walked up to the ropes and got our ID checked we had already reserved a table. When we got there it was around 5:30 and it was the perfect time to arrive. The place was not too crowded and we got to our table right away. The waitress mentioned that we had the best seat in the house. We were seated to the right of the stage if you are looking at it. We didn't know what to expect so we ordered a 6L bottle of Rose and go the party started. Before we knew it, there were security guards by the stage and Wyclef got on stage. Let me tell you, what a party. There was something magical about being tipsy watching the sun go down with your best friends listening to live music. If you are in the Hamptons don't miss out and experience for yourself.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😒

Ohh the legendary Surf Lodge.

3/5 by Kathryn T. on 09/17/2022

I just hopped off a plane and made it to Montauk when my friends took me to dinner here with zero warning of what I was getting into. Here's what you should know:1. Make a reservation if you can. Otherwise, it can be harder to get a table.2. Crispy tuna rice is delicious. The rest of the food is okay... typical things you would find over the summer in the Hamptons and at that higher price point.3. Be prepared to pay up... you're paying for the vibes4. Music and party game can be wild... but the crowd can be younger depending on the day so check the set list before you head over.5. Staff is nice overall.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

Wonderful Stay - Will Return In 2023

5/5 by Andrew C on 09/15/2022

I've been coming to Montauk for several years and to say I've never been to the Surf Lodge would be a fallacy - I've spent countless hours at the Surf Lodge watching sunsets over Fort Pond Bay, enjoying dinner with friends, and watching live shows on weekends. This year, however, was the first year I stayed at the hotel and was impressed. It's no surprise that Surf Lodge's location is perfect to accessing the town and related beaches and the marina & Gosman's dock at the northern end of Edgemere (notable restaurants like Duryea's, Montauket, Navy Beach are all a 15-20 min walk). The availability of cars and bikes to use however was a great perk. The rooms are minimalist, but elegant and in line with the overall vibe of Montauk. I also appreciate the team's efforts in working with new and local brands to promote sustainable products - the fridge was fully stocked new-to-market drinks (alcoholic and non-alcoholic). Despite being next to a venue with live music, the rooms were surprisingly quiet. Guest are treated to a light breakfast (think croissant, yogurt, granola), which was perfect before getting the day going. A couple reviews point out mosquitos - the hotel is situated on the banks of a fresh water pond, so in July and August, the mosquitos can be a nuisance at night if relaxing on the balcony or back deck (for ground floor rooms). Nothing a citronella candle (provided) and spray can't solve, and for he sunset views, worth it!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
🤢

Appalling

2/5 by Hannah on 09/12/2022

I booked Surf Lodge under the impression myself and my 3 girlfriends would be guaranteed entry to the parties. However, we weren’t allowed in to Surf Lodge on Saturday evening, which felt like a complete cop-out given that’s why we stayed there. Flies in the cramped, tiny hotel room. Constant buzzing in my ear. Be prepared for spiders, bugs, flies. No customer service. We called the front desk numerous times for toilet paper, clean towels. No one answered the phone. Even before our visit, we called with questions. The calls were never picked up or returned. Housekeeping cleaned the room once during our 3-night stay. We requested cleans each day. On Saturday, we asked the housekeeper to please clean our room and provide us with toilet paper and clean towels and she was rude to us. Would not recommend.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Just might stay forever.

5/5 by Jordan P on 09/12/2022

My friend and I had the most lovely stay to close out the Summer. Upon arriving we realized that one of our favorite artists had adorned the walls with intricate murals that instantly transported us to a serene dream. The staff were more than welcoming, offering us early check-in. We had a drink from the patio bar overlooking the water and went to see our room. The COMPLIMENTARY mini bar of high-end curated luxury skincare and tonics was too good to be true... no seriously. $1000 worth of the best of the best- organic vitamins, non toxic suncare products, cbd lolli pops and more. A true surprise and stand-out gesture we will never forget. The hotel went on to offer live music, divine dining, a complimentary mini cooper to cruise around & all around great vibes. Very curious to check out their snow location in Aspen. Truly amazing experience, would move in if we could. xx

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

great experience

5/5 by Steven M. on 09/11/2022

Went to The Surf Lodge with my family and some friends and it was both relaxing and fun. The room was large and had stunning water views. The entire venue has always a great vibe and the staff makes you feel welcome and appreciated. The restaurant has a great menu. I loved the Cacio e Pepe and the lobster roll! We had dinner while sun set in front of us. It was incredible. The night was epic with great performances and just amazing music. My family and friends are definitely going back next Summer!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Surf Lodge - no place I’d rather be in the summer

5/5 by AndreaDB24 on 09/07/2022

Surf Lodge has a special place in my heart. By far the best party scene in the Hamptons. I’ve stayed at the hotel and have visited many times for the restaurant, events and outdoor bar. The food is great. The atmosphere perfect. The beach area is comfortable and relaxing. This summer they have drawn big names in music for live performances. The venue is small and intimate, yet lively. Exclusive and attractive crowd. I’ll never forget this summer because of The Surf Lodge. Rhys O’Connell went above and beyond to make our stay memorable. The rooms were in pristine condition and we had access to the grounds which came in handy for Zedd’s performance. Also the breakfast croissants are unbelievable and I loved the balcony outside of our room- great place to read. Thank you Rhys, thank you Surf Lodge!! Will be back again and again.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

My favorite destination in all of the Hamptons / Montauk!

5/5 by Joey G on 09/06/2022

The choice is simple. You want to stay at The Surf Lodge. Where to begin....for me it was the live music performances that I adored first. Due to the properties size your experience is an intimate and exclusive one. They attract top music talent which brings in a fun lively crowd. There's really no where else you can view top level music from their deck mere feet away from the stage. They have comfortable beach seating as well which allows you to look out at the water and admire nightly amazing sunsets. Speaking of the views my room had a balcony looking out at the water which was quiet and peaceful in between the fun. We ate 2 meals here during our stay and the menu is well balanced and delicious. Your reservation gives you full access of the property and it's events which is a huge plus and one less thing to worry about. This isn't a mega resort with only a handful of rooms here which is nice and makes it feel like a close knit family. Everyone seems to know everyone and gets along with the same main goal of having a great time. The location is just a mile or so away from town for easy access, yet removed for privacy. I can't wait to return! Thank you Surf!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
😍

Such a lovely stay!

5/5 by Silmara R on 09/05/2022

I had the best weekend with my friends. The rooms are spacious and the bed very comfortable, really good shower. Also has a very charming balcony where you can see the sunset. Also is very convenient for anyone who wants to have fun at The surf lodge!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
🤮

I was waiting in line with a few friends and the security

1/5 by Greg A. on 08/29/2022

I was waiting in line with a few friends and the security gentleman said we could not get in without getting a table. Again letting in 50 people ahead of my group to the bar area, again the gentleman refused to let me or my friends in without paying thousands of dollars for a table. There were plenty of people in the bar area getting drinks. He was judging me and my group, and let other people in, without letting my group in. I would never recommend this establishment to anyone. The gentleman was short and covered with tattoos. I would think being in customer service he would have learned how to interact appropriately with customers. This establishment really needs help with their cultural competencies.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🙂

Taylor our server was absolutely AMAZING.

4/5 by Kate O. on 08/23/2022

I have had tables at busy bars before but never have I noticed what a good job a server was doing, she was so sweet and fun and checked on us so often GIVE THIS GIRL A RAISE she genuinely made the night. The vibes are fun and music is good, honestly the food was also so freaking good like the chef did not have to go that hard but dang they really did so KUDOS!!! The music outside does end VERY early so if you're getting a table outside just be aware of that bc they will not let you stay outside bc of the noise. The only downer was how genuinely mean the bouncers were, I don't even want to say it bc I am sure they deal with the most entitled a-hole customers on the reg but being short and annoyed is one thing but this was a bit over the top, something may have happened recently that they were all on edge so idk. Taylor is my girl, that chef is amazing those tenders and fries were divine!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤮

No one informed us what time the kitchen closes, our order

1/5 by Anoush Y. on 08/15/2022

No one informed us what time the kitchen closes, our order was taken down wrong (food and drinks), we were very rushed, I asked the hostess for a candle as we were celebrating our friends birthday and she rudely answered they don't have candles and"you can try the market in town". We were then kicked out by security so they could set up for the concert. We waited on line for 2 hours only to be told at that point they will not let in patrons for GA. Really disappointed about this experience. We have been supporting Surf Lodge/Snow Lodge for years now but this left a terrible taste in our mouth and we will certainly reconsider going back.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤢

I don't recommendation The Surf Lodge for the following

2/5 by Lisa G. on 08/15/2022

I don't recommendation The Surf Lodge for the following reasons: Very expensive for a "motel-style" accommodations - they charged $1000/night! It's not on the ocean but on Montauk Lake. They did not provide ample towels, no wash cloths. Lights were out in the bathroom. They did provide beach towels however no beach chairs or umbrellas which we ended up purchasing. The TV was Roku - you couldn't get regular channels. There were no plastic cups in the bathroom to use. They did provide a simple continental breakfast, but it was the same everyday. The place is a hot scene on the weekends for a young crowd, so parking was limited - we had to remind staff to save us a parking spot. When we called to inform them on all these things, they didn't offer a partial refund or a "free night". We won't be back to the Surf Lodge.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤮

SHOCKING experience here.

1/5 by Jennie C. on 08/12/2022

If i could, I'd give this place negative stars. I've never been treated so poorly at a restaurant ever. Literally.My sister-in-law made reservations for four of us to have dinner on a Thursday night, which apparently cost $75pp just to hold the res? Once we arrived, we were quickly taken to a picnic table, where two other patrons were sitting - we sat on the other side of the table - community seating, no problem. Then, some vicious woman appeared and yelled at us to move down (closer to the two women seated at the end). She gave no context or reason but spoke to us like children who had been misbehaving. It was quite shocking. She then barked that two other people were going to sit on the OTHER side of us - that these tables seat 8 people. The picnic tables aren't huge and that would absolutely not be the most comfortable, but we're amenable people and would have gone along with being smooshed between two couples, but the outrageous tone and punitive instructions completely turned us off. I let her know how I felt, that she was rude and there was no reason for her to speak to us this way, at which point she scurried away to do something else in the restaurant and then swung back by to confront me and yell in my face that "Nobody has EVER called her rude before" (which was aggressively rude and childish - so meta) and then she stomped off. At this point, sticking around to be abused when we'd paid 300 just to walk through the door was not going to happen and we all decided to walk out. Fortunately, my SIL was able to get the deposit refunded and speak to a GM who was super nice and apologetic - we honestly appreciated him trying to make good by offering a free drink and other accommodations, but there was really no chance for any kind of redemption at that point. This place is a scene... and not a good one. If you have any sort of self-respect, you'd be better off dining someplace else; like Scarpetta, Harvest, Duryea's or the Gig Shack.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🙂

Amazing ambience but food is so over priced.

4/5 by Catherine F. on 08/03/2022

very average menu. chef does a great job but nothing to ride home about.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤢

This is not the place for an intimate dinner.

2/5 by Jack N. on 08/01/2022

It has a bar/party atmosphere you would find in Fort Lauderdale, don't expect to hear anyone talk unless you're screening across the table. It was just all-around an interesting experience. Also, imagine paying a premium price to be seated at a picnic table and share it with another party--just nuts.The atmosphere: was a party. You can't hear yourself think.The staff: was relatively friendly and tried to be helpful, but they couldn't hear anything.The food: average at a high mark up.Cleanliness: the table was fine; I don't know about the deck bar, though.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

Couldn't be more inviting

5/5 by John on 07/29/2022

The property and the staff were fantastic. They rolled out the red carpet for me and made me feel at home! I can't wait to come back again soon and would recommend The Surf Lodge to anyone looking to immerse themselves in Montauk. Loved Cristina and Eloise at the front desk!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
🤮

This place is THE WORST! I could go on and on but suffice

1/5 by Amanda W. on 07/25/2022

This place is THE WORST! I could go on and on but suffice it to say if you want to experience an utterly obnoxious attitude obviously set by the horrid trashy owners, do hang out there. I guess the success lies in its locale and the few options in Montauk. I've rarely had such an unpleasant experience at a venue.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

My MOH got a table for all 11 girls on my bachelorette

5/5 by Melissa C. on 07/09/2022

My MOH got a table for all 11 girls on my bachelorette weekend. We didn't have to wait long to be seated at all! Marc Jacobs had his pop up so we looked around until they walked us to our table. They did make me take off my sash but I didn't care/ wasn't surprised. We got the last dinner reservation possible so we could hang out for a bit after eating the DJ was great. Such good vibes! Food was BOMB. 10/10

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤮

Never been treated worse in my life.

1/5 by Jason M. on 06/26/2022

Was there on June 25. Ordered a drink for my wife and I around 4, which by the way was close to $50 in total with tip, and before I could sit back down staff was walking around telling everyone to leave immediately. Only explanation was they had to "clean" the area. There was no cleaning, they had already staged every table for bottle service for a band that we were told didn't start for 2 more hours. The place at the time was maybe 15% capacity. We tried to quickly finish our drinks that they gladly sold to us literally less than 5 min before and in a matter of minutes 3 bouncers were in my face telling us to leave. We weren't the only ones they treated like this, there were a handful of others. If I managed this place I'd be embarrassed.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

Great food, great atmosphere very fast service for the

5/5 by Julia N. on 06/24/2022

Great food, great atmosphere very fast service for the amount of people they gotten on a Saturday.. a little unorganized outside....but it's all worth it. Highly recommend

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

My Happy Place

5/5 by Ruby on 06/21/2022

I can't say enough amazing things about The Surf Lodge - it truly feels like going home every time I visit - the sweetest staff, coolest vibe, and the best view of the sunset! Counting down the days until I return!!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
🤮

Horrible food.

1/5 by Emilia M. on 06/19/2022

The brunch was so expensive and came out worse than diner food. My egg sandwich came out on a bun that looks like it came from Wendy's.

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
🤮

This place really sucked.

1/5 by Victoria A. on 06/18/2022

Definitely don't recommend the staff is rude and there are much better places to go in Montauk

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
😍

This is a vibey hot spot during the summer in Montauk.

5/5 by Jen R. on 05/28/2022

Get a table unless you want to be in the crowd and to avoid the lines at the bar. Great people watching. Crowd is beautiful. We had a live performance during our dinner and sat outdoors. Half restaurant half day/nightclub. The halibut was fantastic. We will be back!

The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews IconRead More in The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews

Videos & Internet Profiles of The Surf Lodge Montauk

play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
play
Instagram Facebook Yelp TripAdvisor OpenTable Resy

Other Popular Hotels in Montauk

Other Popularity Score ™
Hotel IconTopping Rose House Bridgehampton Hotel IconGurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Hotel IconRuschmeyer's Montauk Hotel IconGurney's Star Island Resort & Marina Montauk Hotel IconCastle Hill Inn Newport
How do you like The Surf Lodge Montauk?
You will earn 50 Traderpoints for your rating.
🤮 🤢 😒 🙂 😍
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Best Posts of Page Best Posts Discussions Reviews
Worked perfectly!
😍 5/5 Review by AcceptingVessel63 (03/09/2023 6:29 pm)

Got the reservation (that I couldn't get anywhere else) and was able to entertain a group of friends at the infamous Bern's Steakhouse.

Got into Nobu Malibu
😍 5/5 Review by EnamoredList61 (03/03/2023 8:41 am)

Wonderful! My parents are visiting and we have wanted to go to Nobu Malibu for years. I tried getting a reservation myself but it was next to impossible. So glad I was able to buy a reservation on appointment trader for a decent price!

Very easy
😍 5/5 Review by EnchantingMass27 (02/13/2023 6:57 am)

Was very hesitant going into this experience but am glad to say that it worked out very well ! will definitely use appointment trader in the future

Fabulous Lunch
😍 5/5 Review by FascinatedSnake33 (02/05/2023 3:09 pm)

I was veeeeeerry skeptical that this would work, particularly at a restaurant as hard to get into as Nobu Malibu, and it was perfect! We had lunch outside on the patio and it was fabulous!

Great reviewer team
😍 5/5 Review by ActualBoot15 (02/03/2023 11:03 pm)

Just wanted to take a second to shout out the reviewer team. Even though they probably review hundreds of listings and bids a day, they still take the time to leave great comments and respond relatively quickly. Thanks!

Thumbs Up Action Icon1 Thumbs Up
Incredible
😍 5/5 Review by ImmortalApple60 (02/02/2023 5:20 pm)

I got a reservation to Don Angie, which I've been trying to book for weeks! I am very happy with this service.

Best platform out there!
😍 5/5 Review by AwakeDecision53 (02/02/2023 12:23 pm)

Super simple, easy, and fast to secure reservations for hard-to-get restaurants and locations!

This app is life changing
😍 5/5 Review by AcclaimedWine28 (01/26/2023 7:45 pm)

This app has opened my world up to so many wonderful new experiences I would never have the chance to have without access to this awesome app! 10/10!

Thumbs Up Action Icon1 Thumbs Up
Worked perfectly
😍 5/5 Review by ExhaustiveDiscovery71 (01/05/2023 12:53 am)

Was a little nervous at first but was pleased to see that the booking went through flawlessly.
Highly recommended.

NOBU Atlanta
😍 5/5 Review by CorrespondingJewel46 (12/30/2022 8:23 pm)

Amazing and easy process

Success on Short Notice
😍 5/5 Review by EnforceableUmbrella69 (12/22/2022 11:59 am)

Was able to snag an indoor table at Don Angie through an absolutely seamless worry-free process.

Worked perfectly, thank you!
😍 5/5 Review by FabledChange61 (12/15/2022 7:24 pm)

This is a crazy holiday season in NYC and I was very pleasantly surprised to see that AppointmentTrader works! Will be using again!

Worked flawlessly!
😍 5/5 Review by ArtfulChange26 (12/05/2022 6:25 am)

Worked so well! I was a bit nervous, but everything went very smoothly. purchased the reservation, and got into the restaurant seamlessly.

Answer IconLast Reply by CelebratedStreet63 (03/15/2023 4:29 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon16 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon5 Replys, 2 comments
Love this app!
😍 5/5 Review by DeliberateScale19 (11/30/2022 11:45 am)

So glad I came across this app :)

Answer IconLast Reply by DecadentRoof69 (01/30/2023 2:54 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon7 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon2 Replys, 0 comments
Quick table in Miami
😍 5/5 Review by AppealingOpinion58 (11/29/2022 2:21 am)

I didn’t have my hopes high as it was a party of 4. In 24 hours I had a carbone reservation available! I was very happy as my family really wanted to come here

Answer IconLast Reply by DecadentRoof69 (01/30/2023 2:54 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon7 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Reply, 1 comment
Prime time, great meal
😍 5/5 Review by AvidUmbrella31 (11/25/2022 8:07 am)

So easy and had a prime time which I can never seem to get on normal res apps. So worth it

Answer IconLast Reply by DeliberateScale19 (02/01/2023 6:42 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon3 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Reply, 0 comments
Got impossible NYC res
😍 5/5 Review by DapperBasket31 (11/16/2022 11:13 am)

instead of waiting weeks I got my 4 charles reservation instantly

Answer IconLast Reply by FamousStation67 (01/10/2023 7:55 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon3 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Reply, 0 comments
Worked perfectly to get into Carbone. So delighted
😍 5/5 Review by ForeseeableInsect17 (11/13/2022 6:56 am)

perfect

Answer IconLast Reply by MaternalRecord73 (01/22/2023 3:32 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon2 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Reply, 0 comments
Worked well, got me into a restaurant with no availability
😍 5/5 Review by ExpressionisticSuggestion35 (10/29/2022 8:09 pm)

I was skeptical, and I still don't really know how they managed to find this hard-to-find reservation, but it was a win-win from my point of view, and I'll use this service again.

Answer IconLast Reply by AuthoritativeUmbrella71 (12/01/2022 9:40 am)
Thumbs Up Action Icon10 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon3 Replys, 1 comment
Last minute reservation for Delilah Las Vegas
😍 5/5 Review by InformedStretch72 (09/29/2022 1:00 pm)

Got a last minute reservation, dinner for 2 at Delilah Las Vegas: super impressed! The process was simple, transaction seamless. We had an amazing time! Couldn’t be happier! 😍

Answer IconLast Reply by AuthoritativeUmbrella71 (12/01/2022 9:41 am)
Thumbs Up Action Icon8 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon3 Replys, 2 comments
It works!
🙂 4/5 Review by ChattyPeace47 (09/04/2022 2:30 pm)

Ok at this point I've attended a reservation purchased on AT by a friend and sold a reservation personally. Both worked pretty smoothly, nothing sketchy about it. A few areas for improvement including a way to more directly communicate between buyers and sellers, but the app always seems to be in development. AT customer support is really(!) responsive and helpful too if you have questions!

Answer IconLast Reply by ZestfulSeed54 (11/29/2022 9:45 am)
Thumbs Up Action Icon4 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon2 Replys, 0 comments
Money transfer
🙂 4/5 Review by GutsySalt20 (09/02/2022 11:13 am)

As a seller, I like the fact i have the ability now to transfer money out of my AT account and into a bank account. Makes getting the money much easier then the process before.

Answer IconLast Reply by BraveHand53 (11/28/2022 4:49 am)
Thumbs Up Action Icon5 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Reply, 0 comments
Love this app
😍 5/5 Review by ImpassionedOffice37 (08/02/2022 5:38 pm)

Got to go to places otherwise unreachable

Thumbs Up Action Icon1 Thumbs Up
Easy Access
😍 5/5 Review by EthicalLetter14 (08/21/2022 9:10 pm)

Very easy to get into one of the hardest restaurants to reserve in New York.

Answer IconLast Reply by EnjoyableJelly34 (11/14/2022 9:34 am)
Thumbs Up Action Icon5 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon2 Replys, 0 comments
Worked like a charm
😍 5/5 Review by ExactMass18 (07/31/2022 11:24 am)

We were very pleased with our experience at Scarpetta. It made our anniversary very memorable. The reservation was seamlessly transferred into our name.

Thumbs Up Action Icon2 Thumbs Up
Working on your bid?
Question by DemurePain59 (10/01/2021 1:24 pm)

Best AnswerYour bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.

Answer IconBest answer by EvocativeFold67 (10/02/2021 4:37 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon2 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon8 Answers, 1 comment
Process after bid is accepted.
Question by EvocativeFold67 (09/17/2021 8:11 pm)

Best AnswerHey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.

Answer IconBest answer by ColorfulRod45 (09/17/2021 10:07 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon3 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon1 Answer, 2 comments
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?
Question by ColorfulRod45 (07/13/2021 3:55 pm)

Best AnswerMostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.

Answer IconBest answer by FluffyStar64 (07/13/2021 6:05 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon3 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon10 Answers, 1 comment
What happens if my bid expires unanswered?
Question by FluffyStar64 (07/08/2021 5:55 pm)

Best AnswerHey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.

Answer IconBest answer by ColorfulRod45 (07/08/2021 6:28 pm)
Thumbs Up Action Icon2 Thumbs Up
Comment Icon4 Answers, 3 comments
Ask a Question

The Surf Lodge Montauk User Reviews & Question Forums

Create a Review in "The Surf Lodge Montauk Reviews"
You will earn 50 Traderpoints for your Review.
🤮 🤢 😒 🙂 😍
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
The Surf Lodge Montauk Yelp Reviews
Important Information

Latest Reviews On Yelp

😒2.5/5 from 19 reviews
Last review : Amazing ambience but food is so over priced.
By Catherine F. (08/03/2022 12:00 am)
See all reviews
The Surf Lodge Montauk Tripadvisor Reviews
Important Information

Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor

😒2.6/5 from 11 reviews
Last review : Couldn't be more inviting
By John (07/29/2022 12:00 am)
See all reviews
AppointmentTrader Platform Reviews
Important Information

Reviews from real people using AT!

🙂4.4/5 from 173 reviews
Last review : What a Restaurant!
By ExpansiveTop42 (03/16/2023 7:25 am)
See all reviews
Create a Question in "The Surf Lodge Montauk FAQ"
You will earn 25 Traderpoints for your Question.
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Create a Question in "The Surf Lodge Montauk FAQ"
You will earn 25 Traderpoints for your Question.
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Create a Post in "Must try dishes at The Surf Lodge Montauk"
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Create a Post in "Best Rooms in The Surf Lodge Montauk"
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Create a Post in "Best Tables in The Surf Lodge Montauk"
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
Create a Post in "Staff to Know at The Surf Lodge Montauk"
Upload Images
Sign In to Publish Post
Cancel
AppointmentTrader FAQ
Important Information

Questions and Answers around the platform.

Comment Icon416 questions
Last question : Where can I find my reservation detail
By EnduringWeather21 (03/15/2023 2:39 pm)
See all questions
Place a Bid to Get Someones Reservation
Bid $35 to Get Someone's Reservation 16 sellers watching
Get a Reservation at The Surf Lodge Montauk
⚡ See Immediately Available Reservations
Increase your Bid. This amount is below the trading average and will probably not be successful.
You are getting a great deal. There are no competing bids.
$100 is the next highest bid, you can narrow your search to get lower results.
See all bids for Any Table Size on 06/15/2021 10 AM - 11PM
$100 is the next heighest bid for Any Table Size on June 15th between 10 AM - 11PM.
See all bids