Mastro's Steakhouse New York - Buy Reservations

1285 6th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

Getting a Reservation at Mastro's Steakhouse New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!

Buy a verified reservation at Mastro's Steakhouse New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.

If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.

We only list verified Reservations! All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.

Read Less

Mastro's Steakhouse New York Reviews from The Last Year

AT: 😍 (6) Yelp: 🙂 (13) Tripadvisor: 🙂 (7)

😍

Simply spectacular

5/5 by 👻 @BrawnyMouth17 on 10/13/2023

Wonderful

😍

Mind blowing

5/5 by 👻 @BrawnyMouth17 on 10/13/2023

Fantastic

😍

Awesome atmosphere and decorum

5/5 by 👻 @BrawnyMouth17 on 10/13/2023

Amazing

😍

Superb quality of Service

5/5 by 👻 @BrawnyMouth17 on 10/13/2023

Excellent

😍

💯

5/5 by 👻 @ExpressionisticHarbor75 on 10/02/2023

Nice place. The food was delicious, The drinks were well-crafted and complemented the meal perfectly, the staffs where attentive and friendly, providing excellent service throughout the evening

😍

Incredible ambience

5/5 by 👻 @BrawnyMouth17 on 09/21/2023

I was blown away. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with an awesome atmosphere and exquisite interiors that set the perfect tone for the evening. The attention to detail in the decor and ambiance was truly impressive.

🤢

I Had Reservations For My Birthday March 22.

2/5 by 👻 @Deirdra W. on 03/25/2023

My Party Was Missing 2 People But They Sat Us Anyway. The Host (Mely) Was Extremely Unprofessional. She Told Me Once It Hits 10pm My Friends Wouldn't Be Able To Enter The Restaurant I Said Okay I Thought That Was The End Of It . NOPE! She Proceeds To Walk Up To The Security At The Front Door And Starts Pointing At Me Which Made My Party And I Super Uncomfortable To The Point We Wanted To Just Leave. At 9:50pm I Went Out To Retrieve My Friend From The Front And Again She Reminded Me At 10pm NOBODY Would Be Able To Enter The Restaurant .10pm Comes Around And People Of A Different Demographic Then Us Are Still Entering The Restaurant Going To Tables And The Bar My Last Friend Enter Around 10:05pm And The Front Desk Stopped Him Saying He Couldn't Join Us. If It Wasn't For Mark My Server And The Security Guard For Letting My Friend In To At Least Sit With Us This Would've Been A 1 Star Review My Party And I Felt Really Targeted. The Host Definitely Almost Ruined My Birthday With Her Attitude. Overall MARK YOURE AMAZING KEEP DOING WHAT YOUR DOING! The Food Was Amazing The Service FROM MARK Was Great Couldn't Ask For Better Server. The Security At The Front Thank You And Mark For Making My Day .

🙂

Went here for dinner for a work dinner and was a

4/5 by 👻 @Jenna B. on 03/23/2023

Went here for dinner for a work dinner and was a sophisticated, old school yet modern steakhouse. As a vegetarian, I even found the food to be delicious. The butter cake is a must try!

😍

Succulent Steakhouse with painstaking prices but beef that

5/5 by 👻 @Vinay S. on 03/21/2023

Succulent Steakhouse with painstaking prices but beef that makes it worth the splurge. Rib Eye + Garlic Mash Potatoes combo is a winner. $60 a dish. 4.5/5 stars as a dinner spot.

😒

This was my first time dining at Mastro's.

3/5 by 👻 @Nia B. on 03/14/2023

I have mixed reviews on my experience. The service was amazing. Our waiter's name was Jason and he was great and very attentive. The ambience is really nice and comfortable. Honestly, I expected the food to be better. The Lobster Mash, Crab cake, asparagus, and spinach were all tasty. However, the herb roasted chicken was very bland. It came out really pale, no gravy, no type of glaze. Just bland light colored chicken, with poor presentation. I was also underwhelmed by The Mac & cheese. It seemed as if it was just plain noodles under a thick coat of cheese on top. The butter cake was ok. Even though it wasn't as soft as I expected. The drink Jason suggested was really really good. The other issue I had was that before the food was sat on the table, they started serving the side dishes. I didn't like that, being that I like to take pictures of the dishes for my Yelp reviews before I touch it.The highlight of the night was the pianist. I was very pleased with her performance. She sang a mixed variety of music. Once she started singing Anita Baker I was so surprised. I loved her.

🙂

BUTTER CAKE REIGNS SUPREME! Mastros kills it every time.

4/5 by 👻 @Blake B. on 03/11/2023

I will say, however, the sea bass wasn't as flavorful as it typically is but the pan seat was fantastic and the texture was buttery and amazing as normal. I opted for the truffle mushrooms to pair with the food and was actually disappointed by the lack of truffle flavor, might want to rethink the name for that and brand them as seasoned butter sautéed mushrooms to manage expectations. Our server was pleasant and kind and even brought cherries for a Manhattan that was ordered at the table because at the time it was made they were out. The grand finale that is always what I crave on my worst and best days AKA the butter cake was deeeelicious. The live music on the piano created an even better environment and we were able to make a request which was great.

😒

I think this place is not worth the hype.

3/5 by 👻 @Deina C. on 03/04/2023

The food is so over priced and is not even that good. The steak is good quality but has no seasoning. The mash potatoes is water down and the Mac and cheese is trash. There are places in New York with better views, astethics and food than this. Save your money

😍

Loved this steakhouse ! Staff was excellent and on top of

5/5 by 👻 @John D. on 02/25/2023

Loved this steakhouse ! Staff was excellent and on top of their service. Great ambience and piano singer was amazing. Let's get to the food!!! The steaks were very tasty and cooked perfectly, I been to all steakhouse in Dallas and this was just as good! My server George was one of the nicest and knowledgeable servers and my wife and I was completely satisfied! Would def return to spot of back in theatre district!

😍

Maestro is a steakhouse in midtown.

5/5 by 👻 @Karena M. on 02/22/2023

As soon as we walked in, there were about four or five hosts standing by the hostess station. Since they were all mid convo, i ended up greeting them. I let them know i had reservations and two of the hosts reviewed the tablet together to find my reservation. It took about another 3mins for us to be walked to our table. Overall the entrance portion was quick.The restaurants main door is off to the side. Its a strange front door situation. When you walk in, the entrance is a little narrow but then opens up to a big space. The decor is really nice. The live music was a plus and certainly makes the night feel more romantic. The floors are NOT heel friendly. I slid a few times and do have rubber stoppers on the bottom of the heels. So just a heads up for any ladies out there looking to visit. I had to hold my husbands hand to walk in and out. Once seated at the table, it did take about 10mins for our waiter to acknowledge us or get us water, etc. He actually didnt, the runner ended up getting us water. We were given the option of flat or sparkling. We took sparkling water. When the waiter came around, he took our drink and appetizer order. Once the appetizer came, we ordered our entrees.We ended up getting two drinks. My husband got a Cadillac Margarita with Casa Migo. I got the Pomegranate Martini. The drinks here are ridiculously overpriced. The Margarita was $29 and the Martini was $21, more then the appetizers prices. I got two drinks and you can easily see the inconsistency in how it was made. The first drink was darker. The second one was way too strong and tasted like only a splash of Pomegranate juice was used. As an appetizer we got 6 raw oysters and the crab cake. I asked for one crab cake and was still given two and charged for those two as well, $49. Thankfully the crab cake was absolutely delicious. The seasoning was on point and you can taste and see the big pieces of crab. They serve it with big pieces of lemon and a sauce. The oysters were fresh. They tasted good and had a good texture. The six oysters were $23. Both appetizer were good, i recommend them. For entree my husband got the rib eye - oscar style with crab meat and hollandaise sauce, $134. I got the rib eye as well but with nothing on top, $79. For sides we got the lobster mash $40, and truffle mushrooms $24. The Steaks were delicious. Perfectly cooked. Perfectly seasoned. I loved it. The sides were also good. The lobster mash was flavorful and had large pieces of lobster throughout it. The seafood flavor in the mash was also very present. The mushrooms were really good as well. I did with that they left less thyme twigs in the mushrooms. I also wish they used less green onion on the mash. Some pieces were hard to chew because they seem to have been charred. For dessert we got the butter cake and the raspberry chocolate mousse cake to go. The butter cake was dense, sugary and full of flavor. It had so much butter in it, you could taste it. They dusted the cake in sugar which i feel was an overkill. It didnt need additional sugar. They serve it with fresh fruit, raspberry syrup and vanilla icecream - way too much. The chocolate cake was delicious. Not an overpowering amount of raspberry. The cake itself was hugeeee, i feel like we got two big slices but what i realized, its a high tierred cake and because of this, the tiers had to be split to fit inside of the takeout container. This cake was served with raspberry sauce as well. Overall my meal here was great. Expensive but it was worth it. I dislike going somewhere, spending alot of money and the food is trash. Def didnt have that issue here. What isn't the best is the service. After spending $575 i felt that the service i received didn't feel like it was worth that price. We had long waits in between being seated and our order being taken, etc. Even when our food came out, the server didn't bring it, it was a runner. We must of asked for utensils, extra sauces and hot sauce multiple times before receiving it. The server had multiple tables that night and aside from ordering the food with him, he didnt do much. His angry face killed me. He seemed really upset about being slammed with multiple tables. It made him extremely unapproachable. He seemed to change his tune when we asked for the dessert menu and items to go, sort of happy that we were 1) ordering more and 2) leaving.Overall, loved the food here. If I'm looking to have an expensive fancy dinner....i might come back. I'm glad i finally visited this restaurant.

😍

AMAZING.

5/5 by 👻 @Bijal R. on 02/21/2023

Expensive but worth every penny. Both petite filet and bone-in ribeye steak were super flavorful and well seasoned. Cooked to perfection, every single bite was mesmerizing. Super flavorful and buttery, easy to cut. So simple, yet so flavorful. Best steakhouse meal that I have experienced. Garlic mashed potatoes as a side dish was even better. Potatoes just melt in your mouth, subtle hints of garlic, and not overpowering.

😍

Great place and great location! Loved the breadbasket and

5/5 by 👻 @Jen N. on 02/20/2023

Great place and great location! Loved the breadbasket and drinks! The live music was good as well.

🤮

I went to Mastros for my birthday in February.

1/5 by 👻 @Kadija D. on 02/17/2023

The hosts is horrible, when I mean horrible. HORRIBLE! I love Mastro's food wise but the service is soo bad. It's about 4 women in the front. When you come in they don't introduce their self, nor ask what's your reservation for, one of them was playing with her eyelashes (gross). You work at a restaurant you should not be playing with your eyelashes. The manager is just all over the place no help. The waiter horrible too. He came to our table about 20 mins after we been seated. Ask for our drink and we told him we are ready to order. He said we have to wait. Oh yea food takes about 45 mins to come. My friends and I were so exhausted. My birthday was ruined.

😍

Had the best steak and the best service hands down.

5/5 by 👻 @Kat M. on 02/14/2023

Finished it off with a butter cake of course! Rachel was our server and she was incredible. Loved the way she coursed out our food and all her recommendations. Great live music - will be back!

😍

The absolute best steak I've had in my life thus far is

5/5 by 👻 @Majid J. on 02/11/2023

The absolute best steak I've had in my life thus far is from maestro steakhouse. The food is amazing on first taste and tastes even better the next day (if you can't finish). The overall ambiance here is spectacular, it feels luxurious. Our waitress knew how to recommend drinks as well.

🙂

Excellent service and great meal

4/5 by 👻 @Shawn B on 02/07/2023

Our server, Sean, was attentive, fun, and professional. He made sure we were well taken care of as we were celebrating birthdays. We were a party of 4 and the steaks were all done to perfection with delicious side dishes to share. We did not leave there hungry. Prior to our seating, we enjoyed 2 cocktails at the bar and were very pleased. We would return for another meal.

🤢

If you are steak fan - avoid this venue.

2/5 by 👻 @turist_from_NYC on 01/31/2023

We visited on Friday night. Surprisingly it was not completely full. Waiter wasn't paying attention (on couple occasions he just walked away). From the appetizer: Tuna was good. Beacon was very salty and charcoal. The biggest disappointment was steak. My friends complained about overcooked meat. Mine porterhouse was undercooked. However, meat wasn't a good quality (hard to chew). Therefore, it is not a place to have a good steak. For sides: I would recommend mushrooms. For $330 per couple - you can definitely find better steaks in NYC.

😍

Great meal

5/5 by 👻 @bigedrose on 01/09/2023

Seated us early. Dinner was awesome. It is a $$$$$ place but that's what we were looking for!! Will dine again!!

😍

Exceptional, great menu, staff, ambience

5/5 by 👻 @Ralph Wilhelm on 12/30/2022

We feel that this is one of the best restaurants in NYC….on a par with Aquavit in our opinion. This is one of about twenty Mastro’s across the US in about eight states, but does not feel like a chain. Plenty of seating in the NYC location, upstairs and down stairs. We sat downstairs and found it very quiet and comfortable. Excellent waiter (Sean) and wonderful food served hot and exactly as we would expect. We had drinks then appetizers (lobster bisque) and then a full salad and a six ounce filet…all done very well and excellent. Location to find this is a bit confusing as the 1285 Avenue of the Americas was great to find the general area, but in the collection of buildings and operations with the 1285 address on Sixth Avenue, Mastro’s is the north-most building…facing south of Sixth Avenue. Unless you are particularly “flush”, you will find Mastro’s to be on the high side of expensive….but in our opinion, very well worth it. Hope you give it a try for a special evening. You won’t regret it.

🙂

Mastro’s Steakhouse - New York City

4/5 by 👻 @Coco on 12/26/2022

I am very glad that I chose this restaurant for my family’s Christmas Day dinner as it was not what I expected at all due to past reviews. We entered the very loud first floor of the restaurant, but were then escorted downstairs to a calmer environment and our table for four. Our waiter, George, was incredibly friendly and guided us through the menu whilst providing his recommendations. The food was indescribably good. I had the Clear Lobster Roll and the Maguro Lime Roll, and both were flavourful, authentic, and left me wanting another serve (especially the Clear Lobster Roll)! Unfortunately, I have to mention the negatives. My companions ordered cocktails and wine at the beginning of our visit, and the cocktails were brought to our table at what I estimate to be 25 minutes after we had ordered them, and the wine was brought to our table as we were eating our dinner. If the slow service at the beginning had not have taken place, Mastro’s NYC would have earned a 5/5 from me! Despite the negative, if in New York, give this place a try!

😍

Yessss!

5/5 by 👻 @Wild Radek on 12/19/2022

Service, ambiance and food at its finest. Hands down the best steak house with a signature upscale vibe. Masterful fillets, lobster mash potatoes and any place that has iceberg wedges will get my vote. Across from Radio City. Like everything else in town…. Reserve early. We’ll be back:)

😒

Medium Rare isn’t Well Done

3/5 by 👻 @DonNY845 on 12/06/2022

Most of the food was good but missing something. The Brussels sprouts are amazing but when you receive a nice cut steak and ask for it medium rare, it’s a miss when it’s well done. Unfortunately after waiting too long I decided to eat. Disappointing meal due to my meal being way over cooked!

Videos & Internet Profiles of Mastro's Steakhouse New York

New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mastro's Steakhouse New York

Kyma Hudson Yards New York

Booked 2 times by Mastro's Steakhouse New York customers.

Ranked #166 in New York's Best Restaurants.